East Bay
East Bay
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Johannes Mehserle's 995 Hearing: video, photos, and court documents including ruling

by dave id
Mehserle's defense attorney filed a 995 motion to dismiss the murder case against his client, alleging that improper conduct on the part of Superior Court Judge C. Don Clay during the preliminary hearing amounted to a violation of Mehserle's right to a fair trial. Judge Thomas M. Reardon oversaw the 995 hearing on September 4th. During the hearing Reardon seemed a little too chummy with the defense, but he did make clear that he was well versed in the issues of the case, having read all thousand-plus pages of testimony from the preliminary hearing that ended in June as well as having watched the related videos. Unexpectedly, Reardon did not issue a ruling at the hearing itself, but instead decided to submit his ruling in writing the following week in which he declared that the magistrate's conduct during the preliminary hearing was indeed proper and that Mehserle should proceed to trial for murder.
What follows are shorthand notes from inside the 995 hearing:

judge:  reviewed all transcripts, filings, and video, so no need to repeat in hearing

Vargas video shown -- frame 1022, Mehserle yellow taser seen, Jon Woffinden, Pirone far off

- questions -- where on utility belt was taser?  not in transcript
	- answer: on left towards front
	- rains: taser butt faced front for cross-over right-hand grab

- arrest record of Oscar Grant not admitted into prelim hearing: Oct 2006 San Leandro
	- admissible, with 352 exclusion not done 

- page 1060 of prelim transcript  - magistrate (Clay) said: "not certain I can trust what Pirone said"
	- not a finding - DA O'Connor
	- rains: but I'm certain that he believed Grant posed imminent thread of death
	- judge: transcript unclear

- rains, pages 1056-1060: "defendant didn't give statement" so only way to know state of mind is through witnesses (not video)    
 (( observation: this is convenient as rains didn't call JM to testify, which keeps "state of mind" fuzzy ))

- pages 921-922 - judge: 3 weeks prior taser training for JM (inadequate training
	- rains: JM meant to pull taser so no malice
	- similar incidents of taser/gun accident in other police not examined in prelim hearing

- judge Clay: JM intended to use gun and (rains says) "denied" experts 
	- defense didn't really request trainer from BART (Officer Lehman) or taser expert Mr. Meyer 
	- 1) two hands used, Rains asserts expert would have testified is okay
	- 2) strong hand draw

- judge question: thumb movement about drawing taser (testimony from cops about JM thumb up in taser mode)

- judge question: Mehserle stood back and warned Pirone as if taser (from vid & testimony)
	- center mass firing, Rains said, like taser  (( observation: but guns fired at center body too ))

- rains questions not being able to bring in character of victim as "massive error"
- clay quote from prelim: I have no doubt JM intended gun not taser 
- rains: capricious and absurd exercise of discretion by clay interferred with JM's rights
- DA office O'Connor: character evidence would not have effected outcome when video and testimony covered victim "resistance"

- written ruling on 995 to come before Mehserle's change of venue motion scheduled for October 2nd


Mehserle's defense attorney, supposed super-lawyer Michael Rains, is 0-2 so far in defending his client...

Murder Charge Sticks for Johannes Mehserle in Preliminary Hearing

Murdering BART cop Mehserle's attempt to get case dismissed with 995 motion FAILS

Unless Rains can get the trial moved to a majority white county where a judge or jury rules based on prejudice in favor of police and against people of color rather than the facts of the case, the evidence of the case as laid out in the preliminary hearing makes clear that Mehserle should rightfully be convicted of murder.

§Cephus Johnson, Krystof, and the Revolution Club
by dave id
Copy the code below to embed this movie into a web page:
(video 5:24)

This video was shot after the hearing, in the foyer outside of the court room and on the sidewalk in front of the Alameda County Superior Court House. It features Cephus "Uncle Bobby" Johnson answering corporate press questions about the case, Krystof speaking about BART's failure to hold anyone accountable, and the Revolution Club with the Stolen Lives wall.

Krystof mentions an informational campaign on BART trains earlier that morning:
§995: DA reply to motion - August 10th, 2009
by dave id
(29-page PDF)

Includes DA office's 3-page motion from July 24th to delay filing of DA opposition at end of document here.
Add Your Comments
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!


$60.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.


Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network