top
South Bay
South Bay
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Quick Guide to the Anti-Maskers in Santa Cruz

by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
The anti-mask protesters in Santa Cruz have been widely criticized for using tactics that have more in common with terrorism than political speech. After storming Trader Joe's as a mask-less group on February 13, the anti-maskers returned to Trader Joe's for a second protest on February 28. They call themselves the Santa Cruz Voluntaryists. Their defacto leader is a San Jose resident named David Rodriguez, who has been organizing "voluntaryist barbecues" with anti-vaccination protesters in Santa Cruz since 2019. The anti-maskers' beliefs are both influenced by the anti-vaccination movement, as well as the far-right sovereign citizens movement.
sm_1-bernadette-alvarado-bernie-love-david-rodriguez-trader-joes-anti-maskers-santa-cruz-voluntaryists.jpg
Photo: Bernadette Alvarado and David Rodriguez, both mask-less, protest at Trader Joe's in Santa Cruz on February 13.

Since 2019, the core organizers of the Santa Cruz Voluntaryists have been David Rodriguez, Nick Clifford, and Tim Welch. When the Covid-19 pandemic hit in 2020, two "outside agitators" joined Rodriguez to organize numerous anti-mask protests in Santa Cruz: Mike Mattingly, a radical anti-vaccination protester from Campbell, CA, and Howard Lichtman, a right-wing conspiracy blogger from the East Coast whose pen name is "Etienne de la Boetie 2." Using that pen name, Lichtman has in the past written in support of the militia movement.
§Mike Mattingly at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_3-mike-mattingly-trader-joes-anti-mask-protest-santa-cruz.jpg
§Mike Mattingly at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_4-mike-mattingly.jpg
Mike Mattingly was last know to reside in Campbell, CA.
§Staci Lares at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_5-staci-lares-sunnyvale-san-jose-trader-joes-anti-masker-santa-cruz-cash-drop.jpg
Staci Lares is a resident of Sunnyvale, CA. Lares works as an Outreach Networking Specialist at 808 West Apartments in San Jose.
§Teresa Krockenberger at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_6-teresa-krockenberger-belmont-trader-joes-anti-masker-santa-cruz.jpg
Teresa Krockenberger's Facebook profile says she is a resident of Belmont, CA.
§Theresa Buccola at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_7-theresa-buccola-santa-cruz-trader-joes-anti-masker-pacific-grove.jpg
Theresa Buccola's Facebook profile says she is a resident of Pacific Grove, CA. Buccola owns the business, Theresa Buccola Glass & Design, which is located in Carmel, CA.
§Kristy Fernandes at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_8-kristy-fernandes-trader-joes-anti-masker-santa-cruz-2.jpg
§Tim Welch at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
9-tim-welch-trader_joes_santa_cruz_cash_drop_boulder_creek.jpg
Tim Welch is a resident of Scotts Valley. Welch works as a technical recruiter for TCK Partners. Welch is is a board member of the Boulder Creek Recreation & Park Foundation, the fundraising arm of the Boulder Creek Parks & Recreation District, and he helped found KBCZ, Boulder Creek’s new radio station. Welch is a drummer for the band, Funkranomicon.
§Tim Welch posted the "rules" for the anti-mask protest at Trader Joe's online
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_10-tim-welch-rules-for-maskless-shopping-staci_lares.jpg
Welch posted these rules to the Santa Cruz Voluntaryists Facebook group.
§Florence Schroeder at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 28
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_11-florence-schroeder-maskless-lives-matter-santa-cruz-trader-joes.jpg
12-nick-clifford-david-rodriguez-free-hugs-santa-cruz-lighthouse-west-cliff-anti-masker.jpg
Nick Clifford is a resident of Felton. Clifford works as Director of Sales at Monterey Bay Wine Company.
§Nick Clifford protesting in Santa Cruz in 2016
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_13-nick-clifford-santa-cruz-voluntaryists-anti-vaccination-masker.jpg
§Nick Clifford posts photos of a "voluntaryist bbq" in 2019
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_15-1st-voluntaryist-bbq-freedom-angel-1.jpg
§
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_14-santa-cruz-voluntaryists-david-rodriguez.jpg
sm_16-howard-lichtman-david-rodriguez-mike-mattingly-sanat-cruz-open-beaches-rally.jpg
This meme was posted in May of 2020 to the Keep Santa Cruz Weird Facebook page as a warning to the public.
§David Rodriguez and Howard Lichtman protest in Santa Cruz with the Freedom Angels
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_17-david-rodriguez-howard-lichtman-freedom-angels-santa-cruz-anti-vaccination.jpg
The Freedom Angels are three far-right anti-vaccination protesters who organized the anti-vaccination protests at the California State Capitol in September of 2019, and the "liberty" protests at the Capitol in 2020. Photo: May 2020.
§Howard Lichtman takes the oath with the far-right militia group the Oathkeepers
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_18-howard-lichtman-etienne-de-la-boetie2-oath-keepers-militia-human-productivity-lab-telepresence-options.jpg
Lichtman posted this photo and caption to his business website.
§
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_19-nick-clifford-santa-cruz.jpg
§Lichtman praises Clifford in 2020 for this anti-vaccination protest
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_20-howard-lichtman-nick-clifford-anti-vaccination-banner-protest-santa-cruz-branciforte-overpass-highway-1.jpg
§Unidentified anti-maskers at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_david-rodriguez-trader-joes-santa-cruz-cash-drop-daily-caller.jpg
David Rodriguez post to the Santa Cruz Voluntaryists group on Facebook.

Unidentified anti-maskers at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-1.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-2.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-3.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-4.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-5.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-6.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-7.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-8.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-9.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-10.jpg
§Unidentified anti-masker(s) at the protest at Trader Joe's on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_trader-joes-11.jpg
§Another identity
by PersonSantaCruz
The man in the grey flat cap hat and black hoodie is named Peter Goodman. He has a tax preparation service in Santa Cruz.
§Peter Goodman at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_peter-goodman-santa-cruz-trader-joes-anti-masker-protest.jpg
Peter Goodman says he is a resident of Santa Cruz on his Facebook profile. Goodman works as a tax and small business accountant.
§Identified another one
by Enough is Enough
Fellow in the brown coat & SLR camera is David Isham, from San Rafael. He'll tell you all about how the Holocaust didn't happen, if you stick around long enough.

https://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2021/03/01/18840369.php#18840399
§David Isham at the Trader Joe's anti-mask protest on February 13
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_david_isham_trader-joes-santa_cruz-cash-drop-anti-masker.jpg
David Isham's Linkedin page says he is employed by The Pasha Group as an application development manager in integration services.
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by Schla
Tim welch is NOT on any Boulder Creek rec District board and has not been for years.
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_tim-welch-santa-cruz-voluntaryists-boulder-creek-anti-mask.jpg
Correction

The caption of the photo of Tim Welch should be corrected to read:

"Tim Welch is a resident of Santa Cruz County. Welch works as a technical recruiter for TCK Partners. According to Welch's Linkedin page, he is a board member of the Boulder Creek Recreation & Park Foundation, the fundraising arm of the Boulder Creek Parks & Recreation District, and he helped found KBCZ, Boulder Creek’s new radio station. Welch is a drummer for the band, Funkranomicon."

(Photo from Tim Welch's Linkedin page.)
by Over it
Kristy Fernandes is an author of the book “she rises for tomorrow,” it’s on Amazon. She’s hoping to inspire youth to follow in her footsteps
by Bob Derber (rderber [at] gmail.com)
I am home-bound and COVID is a real threat to me. I wish to help the effort opposing those that intentionally place me at risk. My sister had polio so I am highly motivated and I am disclosing my email for those similarly inclined.
by Georgia hentz
Hello my name is Georgia! I’ve identified 3 of the people in these pictures that are still without names. How can I assist in getting you this information? I want to help put a stop to this outrageous activity. Thank you!
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
If you are comfortable with it, post your information here, Georgia. We aren't using an email address to communicate. When people named two more anti-maskers in the comments section, we simply made new comments with photos to match the rest of our article. We can help you and do that again with your information if you want, or you can create your own posts with pictures.
by Masker
Located some contact info for the employers of some of these people (in case you wish to express your opinion about their employees' actions.)

- 808 West Apartment (Staci Lares). Easy to find her email as well.
https://www.808west-apts.com/808-west-st-san-jose-ca/
- Theresa Buccola Glass & Design
https://www.facebook.com/Theresa-Buccola-Glass-Design-507018949365123/
- TCK Partners
https://tck-partners.com
- Funkranomicon
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOEsp4_4KxbCOLvzrCuQ_tQ
- Monterey Bay Wine Company
http://www.mbwines.com
- Peter Goodman Tax & Business
https://www.yelp.com/biz/goodman-peter-tax-and-business-services-santa-cruz
- The Pasha Group
https://www.pashagroup.com
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
The anti maskers have recently changed their names on social media. Here is a list of their new aliases:

Tim Welch is "TDub OnThe Tubs"
https://www.facebook.com/tim.welch.3158/

Tally Welch is "Tally Tutu"
https://www.facebook.com/tallytutu888

Kristy Fernandes is "Kristy Moonbeam"
https://www.facebook.com/kristy.fernandes.777

Florence Schroeder is "FreeFlo Schro"
https://www.facebook.com/florence.schroeder.3

Teresa Krockenberger is "Teresa Krocki"
https://www.facebook.com/teresa.krockenberger

Staci Lares is "SA Late"
https://www.facebook.com/staci.lares

Bernadette Alvarado is "Bernie Love"
https://www.facebook.com/bernie.love.391
https://www.facebook.com/bernadette.alvarado.900
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_christopher-montenegro-nick-clifford-santa-cruz-voluntaryists-kickboxing.jpg
Posted to the Santa Cruz Voluntaryists group on November 27, 2020.
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
sm_christopher-montenegro-santa-cruz-voluntaryists.jpg
Christopher Montenegro profile.
by She's hiding now
I guess Ms. Free Hug didn't like all the attention she got after being outed, because she changed her Facebook name to "Kristy Moonbeam". (Nanoo Nanoo!)
by Unmasking the Anti-Maskers
Nick Clifford is now "Nicholas J Sayers"
https://www.facebook.com/nickclifford62
by Bob Derber
I am hoping the author of this might contact me. I am also working on addressing Mr. Rodriguez and his group. I would love to collaborate and can assure confidentiality. 435-615-8000.
by Eugenio Negro
God dammit this fool Rodriguez is making San Jo look bad!!! I saw these people on the Morrissey overpass with this huge sign back in like november or something when I was coming into Santa Cruz. It said "blah blah blah psyops blah blah TAKE OFF YOUR MASK!"
by Anti-Anti-Masker
sm_screen_shot_2021-05-16_at_10.08.25_pm.jpg
This post from Kristy Moonbeam Fernandes demonstrates a few things:
1) She spreads misinformation.
2) She continues to spread misinformation even after being called out by a friend (known anti-vaxxer, Satya Orion).
3) She enjoys playing the victim role and making up stories. No, Trader Joe's employees did not assault her. But the video does show the Sovereign Citizen group push their way through the store with no regard for customers or employees.

There appears to be no evidence that Trader Joe's is doing what she is suggesting in her post but there is an article that came out recently that talks about lifting mask requirements. Hmm, what will this group protest after all of the local businesses no longer require masks??
https://www.sfgate.com/food/article/Trader-Joes-first-grocer-to-drop-mask-mandate-16177696.php

So if posts like hers can easily be proven as FALSE, what other misinformation comes from her and the other Sovereign Citizens/Santa Cruz Voluntaryists?? For a group that describes themselves as being critical thinkers who question everything, I sure hope their followers start questioning the fake news more often. Being a sheep sucks.
by Krista Freed
sm_kat-rs-kathryn-saari-mellowkat-free-hugs-lighthouse-west-cliff-drive-santa-cruz-voluntaryists-anti-mask-vaccine-masker-vaxxer.jpg
Pictured: Kathryn Saari, Florence Schroeder, Nick Clifford at a Santa Cruz Voluntaryists "Free Hugs" protest during the pandemic.

Article about Kathryn Saari:

Aptos resident and vlogger Kathryn Saari is an anti-masker and anti-vaxxer who has been harassing workers and posting confrontational videos to social media of her attempts to patronize stores without wearing a mask. Saari refers to the Covid-19 pandemic as a "scamdemic" and a "plandemic," and has made threatening statements targeting specific public officials in Santa Cruz County due to their positions on health and safety guidelines. She describes herself as a "full-time volunteer organizer for a few organizations," which includes volunteering with Children's Health Defense, the anti-vaccination non-profit run by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. notorious for spreading medical misinformation, and an affiliation with the Santa Cruz Voluntaryists, the group that stormed the downtown Santa Cruz Trader Joe's store maskless in February of 2021. Saari credits her husband, orthopedic surgeon Dr. Michael S. Nuzzo, as helping her understand scientific readings related to the pandemic. She stated in a video posted in June of 2021 that neither she or Dr. Nuzzo are vaccinated against Covid-19. Saari has a background in reality television, acting, modeling, and television production.

Keep reading:
Confrontational Anti-Mask Vlogger is Married to a Surgeon
https://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2022/01/21/18847480.php
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$260.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network