Santa Cruz
Santa Cruz
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Newsom plans full reopening in June as deaths hit 60,000
by Melody Isley (WSWS repost)
Monday Apr 12th, 2021 7:26 AM
The practices of the ruling class have been completely negligent and arbitrary. Tiered reopenings, completely lackluster economic relief, dangerous working conditions throughout the whole pandemic and continuous infections have led to more than 3.7 million infections and 60,082 preventable deaths in California alone.

California Governor Newsom halts COVID-19 tiered restriction system, plans full reopening in June as deaths hit 60,000

Melody Isley at the World Socialist Web Site

There is a growing gulf between the anti-scientific policies of the ruling class and the grim reality of the current stage of the pandemic. The Democratic Party-run state of California was just months ago the epicenter of the winter COVID-19 surge where hospitals were pushed to the brink at zero percent capacity, however this past week Governor Gavin Newsom announced plans to fully reopen the state by June 15.

The plan will allow the full range of businesses, workplaces, schools and public areas to remain open with even fewer restrictions, adopting nothing other than “common sense” safety measures like mask-wearing. Throwing out its current color tier metrics for restrictions, the new “plan” hinges on two vague and entirely unspecified prerequisites: a “sufficient vaccine supply” and “low hospitalizations.” What the state deems acceptable has been left totally unspecified, giving Newsom maximum flexibility and ease to fully reopen the economy in a little over two months as more infections and deadlier variants of the virus are circulating widely.

By these intentionally vague standards, the delivery of vaccines would not be required, so long as there are doses being stored and available. The “low” number of acceptable hospitalizations and COVID-19 deaths is essentially arbitrary.

As most California counties lower their own restrictions, there are still more than 2,300 COVID-19 patients in hospitals and 534 COVID-19 patients in intensive care. To compare, an average of 2,300 COVID-positive patients were in the hospital in October, just before the deadly winter surge. However, it was during this period that Newsom ordered half-hearted lockdown measures, which kept all workplaces open and allowed open schools to remain so. Now, even those insufficient measures are to be dispensed with.

In his latest announcement, Governor Newsom aimed straight for the heart of the suffering population, and declared it was time to “begin planning for a life post-pandemic” and to look forward to a fully reopened economy, by “continuing the practices that got us here.” The practices of the ruling class have been completely negligent and arbitrary. Tiered reopenings, completely lackluster economic relief, dangerous working conditions throughout the whole pandemic and continuous infections have led to more than 3.7 million infections and 60,082 preventable deaths in California alone.

The new June plan marks an end to California’s highly flexible color-coded tier system which has been used to classify counties as purple, red, orange, or yellow depending on their testing and hospitalization rates. The state briefly added an even more severe blue tier during the winter to indicate zero percent ICU capacities.

For the last six months, most of California’s 50 counties were placed in restrictive purple or red tiers, indicating widespread and severe positivity rates, and these counties were required to implement measures like reducing capacities at restaurants and other businesses, or discouraging large indoor and outdoor gatherings. In the last week, however, the majority of counties in California have been moved to the “orange” tier, allowing for double the previous capacity for outdoor events, indoor live events, places of worship, fitness centers, amusement parks and full capacities at retail stores, shopping centers, office workplaces and bars with outdoor accommodations.

Importantly, the new tier configuration perfectly coincides with the Democratic Party’s goal of returning children and teachers into classrooms before the pandemic has been put under control, in the sole interest of getting parents back to work full-time and making profits for the financial elite. President Joe Biden declared in February that K-8 schools must be reopened within his first 100 days in office, and California’s policymakers appear to be aiming to lead the pack of the back-to-school drive.

Newsom’s announcement also doubles as cover for businesses and universities to implement full, unsafe reopening plans. California’s universities have had fits and starts in attempting to reopen, only to become outbreak sites, throughout the pandemic. Universities have continuously risked the health of staff and students in unsafe housing and in-person classes in order to gain as much profit as possible during the pandemic. Eagerly awaiting their chance, numerous universities in the California State and University of California system declared, just days after the June reopening announcement, that they will proceed to the fall semester with limited to non-existent restrictions for full service.

The tier system, from its inception, has had purposefully flexible criteria for shifting restrictions—criteria that only became more vague and impermanent as the pandemic progressed. As it currently stands, the system has worked primarily to create a false sense of safety. Nevertheless, this system has outlived its usefulness in California, as the ruling class moves to finish its return to school campaign and the Democrats’ “return to normal.”

The recent shift of most counties to the less restrictive tiers is clearly irresponsible. For example, San Diego County’s COVID-19 case rates are nearly identical to the rates the county suffered six months ago before the devastating winter surge. San Diego County currently has a case rate of 8.2 cases per 100,000 people, a rate that is actually higher than October’s average of 7.4, when San Diego and the rest of Southern California entered the red, and then purple tier in November, with a case rate of 8.9. Similarly, just a few months ago, Los Angeles County was the epicenter of the pandemic for the Western hemisphere, averaging more than 10,000 new cases per day throughout December and January. But this week the county has reopened indoor dining, movie theatres, and reduced capacity indoor concerts. Los Angeles County cites low case rates and vaccination supply, paying no mind to decreased testing rates and the unequal and still limited administration of the vaccines.

In the period from January to April, COVID-19 tests have gone down by more than 50 percent throughout the state of California. It is no coincidence that during this time the ruling class has rapidly accelerated reopening plans through their use of unscientific lies, misrepresentations and legislative force against working people. The platitudes and lies of the ruling class and policy makers would have the working class believe that the pandemic is nearing its conclusion, however, the surge in cases in the Midwest and globally shows that this is far from reality.

As Newsom, the Democratic Party and their allies force students and teachers back to face-to-face learning, MIS-C cases among children are rising dramatically. California leads the United States in the number of children documented with the condition, with more than 300 of America’s more than 3,000 cases and 36 deaths.

As the devastation of the pandemic intensifies, the ruling class actually demands the acceleration and normalization of mass death and disease through their herd immunity policies and reopening plans, and complete disregard for rational policy and science.

Epidemiologists warn that the globe is actually already in the beginning of the fourth wave of the pandemic, and that reopenings will facilitate a worse surge than the winter. In a recent interview on “Meet the Press,” Dr. Michael Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota, and former COVID-19 policy adviser for Biden, referred to the extreme rise in cases in Michigan as a “wake up call” against other states’ reopening plans. Osterholm explained that the spread of variants like B.1.1.7 has led to the recent steady rise of cases in the United States, even before full reopening causes an explosion of infections.

Osterholm elaborated: “We are the only country in the world right now experiencing this increasing number of cases due to this variant and at the same time, opening up, not closing down.” He also warned of vaccine nationalism and vaccine-evading COVID-19 variants in his interview. A fraction of the world’s population has seen a drop of the vaccine, predominantly in wealthier countries, leaving poor countries and billions of people without access.

Biden and the United States government have access to some of the best and most precise COVID-19 data and projections in the world, and yet, a class decision is made to ignore the dangers, reopen schools and workplaces with full knowledge that they will be condemning workers and their families to unnecessary suffering and death by doing so.

The Democratic Party stronghold of California has taken the lead in both the spread of COVID-19 and irrational pandemic policies. From the state’s arbitrary and ineffective tier system to their superficial “equitable” vaccination pledges, to the drive to reopen schools, the state has led the nation by example for how to reopen the economy and shift blame for mass death and disease to the working class.

The Democrats hope to offer the appearance of improvement and political cover for their homicidal policies and profiteering. Meanwhile, the grim reality is that the pandemic is not ending. The same day that Newsom announced his June reopening plans, a new COVID-19 “double mutant” strain was discovered in California, illustrating the dangers that exist from allowing the virus to spread.


Add Your Comments

Comments  (Hide Comments)

by Earth to WSWS
Monday Apr 12th, 2021 7:49 PM
It is clear WSWS does not live in California. You could look up data. For example, we have 40 million residents as any census data will tell you. See the following for California's 58 counties' statistics (better known as the Great Fifty-Eight)

Out of 40 million residents of California, in the past 12 months, there have been a little over 60,000 COVID19 deaths. Out of the 10 million residents of Los Angeles County, in 12 months, there have been 23,503 deaths. Bringing it home, out of 892,000 residents of San Francisco County, in 12 months, there have been 502 deaths. This is a good record, compared to lots of countries in the world. The State of California has provided free food at food banks, and people to hand out the free food throughout the state including in San Francisco. I walk by the weekly food bank at Columbus near Lombard by the playground-swimming pool-library complex in the heart of Chinatown which all of North Beach is by definition. The State of California has also used FEMA money to rent and buy housing for the homeless, including hotels, and provide food to the homeless in these hotels. The State of California also bought ventilators and encouraged the manufacture of ventilators right here in California. The State of California has set up testing sites throughout California from the beginning and now is coordinating a statewide vaccination program. My vaccine was obtained through a statewide website, with vaccines administered by Kaiser at the Moscone Convention Center in San Francisco. The State of California has provided money to the schools so they can reopen, which means providing money for social distancing, plastic partitions, cleaning, and for teachers. The teachers in San Francisco who do not want to return to the classroom were given a medical leave for the remainder of the spring semester while the school district hired substitutes. About half of San Francisco teachers took the medical leave. This is generous; it is not forcing anyone to return. This year-long effort to slow the spread of COVID19 while we waited for the vaccine which will provide us with herd immunity came while California had to spend millions to fight horrific forest fires caused by climate change. COVID19 is here to stay; all we have for our survival is the vaccine. That's right: COVID19 WILL NEVER DISAPPEAR so get your vaccine now.

As a case study, the County you forgot all about is my hometown of San Francisco. You need to look at our good statistics at:
Scroll down on the right to
San Francisco Covid19 Data Tracker. Click on it.
Check Key Public Health Indicators, Vaccination Overview, Hospitalizations, Hospital Capacity. You will see under Hospital Capacity that as of April 8, 2021, there are 3 COVID19 patients in Intensive Care and 25 COVID19 patients in Acute Care. That is good by any standard, and when you consider that 25% of San Francisco residents are over age 60, the most likely to die from COVID19 and just about all other diseases, that is extraordinary.

The smiling faces on the children at Bret Harte Elementary School in San Francisco, in the black community, where the mayor was today, reminded us of the urgent necessity to open the schools. Both parents and students were happy, and 80% of the children attended the school reopening. This was broadcast on local TV which have websites online and is available at:

The complaints about children falling behind in school and being suicidal because they have to sit in front of a screen at home to try to learn have been heard and are legitimate. The workingclass children, mostly black and brown in California, were already having difficulty in school due to their impoverished circumstances. They have fallen further behind with Zoom school and many just do not bother to tune in anymore.

Taking this step forward by reopening the elementary schools first is wise and careful. The private schools are already open. With the vaccine, we now can hope to reopen the economy.
by Mike Holmes
Thursday Apr 15th, 2021 4:46 PM
So you don't like what the state has been doing. But what would you do that would be better? It's really easy to just say you don't like what the state government has been doing, but you don't seem to have any better ideas.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!


donate now

$ 240.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.


Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network