Central Valley
Central Valley
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Comments on Shasta Dam raise proposal due on Monday, January 14!
by Dan Bacher
Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
The deadline for email delivery or postmark of comments against the Shasta Dam Raise is TODAY, Monday, January 14, 2019 (email by 11:59 a.m.)
Westlands Water District has begun their effort to raise Shasta Dam and flood most of what is left of the Winnemem Wintu's sacred sites on the McCloud River in northern California. This is a wasteful, expensive, unnecessary, destructive and illegal boondoggle opposed by the California Legislature and leadership. Raising Shasta Dam would do irreparable environmental damage and harm the Winnemem culture.

Westlands Water District has begun the Environmental Impact Review (EIR) process and is seeking comments on the scope of the EIR document.

What You Can Do To Help

Please email comments to: ShastaDamEIR [at]

or snail mail written comments to:
Shasta Dam Raise Project
c/o: Stantec
3301 C Street, Suite 1900
Sacramento, CA 95816

Deadline for email delivery or postmark is Monday, January 14, 2019 (email by 11:59 a.m.)

Here are the environmental documents:

Here are some more talking points about the dam raise:

Here is a draft letter you can copy and paste into your email or letter:

To: Shasta Dam Project -- ShastaDamEir [at]
Subject: Comments on Scope of EIR for Proposed Shasta Dam Raise

Westlands Water District:

I would like to express my concern about the proposal to enlarge Shasta Dam and Reservoir. According to the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, the dam raise would cost more than $1.3 billion but would increase California's surface water supply by no more than 1%.

Tribal and environmental groups have expressed concern over the cultural and ecological impacts of the dam raise. This proposal is wasteful, expensive and destructive.

I urge you to address the following issues in your EIR. Please notify me when the draft EIR is available for public review.

Winnemem Wintu cultural sites along the McCloud River will be submerged by increasing the level of the reservoir.

* The EIR should provide an in-depth look at how the dam has already affected and harmed the Winnemem people, burials, culture, archaeological and ceremonial sites. It should also address the potential impacts on all remaining tribal cultural resources and sacred sites if the dam is raised.

Before the era of the dam, Chinook Salmon born in the McCloud River migrated to the ocean and returned to spawn and die in their home waters. The ceremonial cycle of the Winnemem is tied to seasonal salmon runs. When Shasta Dam was built, no plan was made for fish passage around the dam. Salmon began to die off.

Raising Shasta Dam is likely to threaten or endanger species listed under California and federal Endangered Species Acts, including Sacramento River winter-run Chinook Salmon and Sacramento River spring-run Chinook.

* The EIR should include a broad biological study of endangered salmon, factors that have harmed habitat and warmed the waters of the Sacramento River, the cost and need for a salmon bypass swimway around Shasta Dam, and cost analysis and a feasibility study to build a swimway to get salmon to the McCloud River.

* The EIR should study and map how an 18.5 foot dam raise will flood the free-flowing McCloud River above McCloud River Bridge. The study and maps should include all documented and known Winnemem archaeological and sacred sites that would be affected by increasing the level of the reservoir.

This list is by no means exhaustive. I also urge you to take into consideration the submissions of the Sacramento River Council, Friends of the River and the Winnemem Wintu Tribe.

Thank you.

Your Name

More information about the 2018 Winnemem Wintu Run4Salmon is available in the article below:

Winnemem Wintu Fight for Restoration of Winter Chinook Salmon to McCloud River above Shasta Dam

By Dan Bacher

In the short time that I was waiting at Discovery Park, located at the junction between the American and Sacramento rivers, for participants in the Winnemem Wintu’s Run4Salmon to board the boat making the journey from Sacramento to Colusa on the morning of September 22, anglers in two boats arrived back at the dock with their one fish limits of salmon.

Larry Mabalot, Benny Tayag and Oliver Pascual came in with three bright salmon up to 18 pounds. They landed their fish while trolling with Kwikfish and Silvertron spinners around the I Street Bridge.

“It was epic, “said Mabalot. “We landed our three fish in 30 minutes of fishing. It’s the best day we’ve had yet this year.”

Mike Morales of Sacramento returned to the ramp with his one salmon. “I caught the fish while using a jig,” he explained.

While the salmon fishing on the Sacramento River has been much better than expected this fall, the salmon are still in deep trouble.

2017 was the third year that the Sacramento River fall run didn’t meet its conservation goal of 122,000 to 180,000 fish set by the Pacific Fishery Management Council, prompting the designation of the fishery as “overfished,” even though it was water exports, diversions, dams, habitat destruction, and poor federal and state water management over the decades that have led to the collapse.

Meanwhile, low numbers of winter and spring run Chinook salmon continue to return to the Sacramento River and its tributaries.

To help restore native winter run Chinook salmon back to the McCloud River, Captain James Netzel of Tight Lines Guide Service and Alyx and Brennen Howell of Santa Rosa, both members of the Wappo Tribe, donated their services this September to take leaders of the Winnemem Wintu Tribe and their allies in jet boats on the Run4Salmon.

Netzel drove the Pittsburg to Sacramento stretch of the river in his boat on September 18 while Alex and his brother boated the section from Sacramento to Colusa section on September 22. This was the third year of the Run4Salmon.

The Run4Salmon is a “participatory, prayerful journey” that took place this year from September 15 to 30 to “raise awareness and build public support to help protect and restore declining salmon populations, California river systems and indigenous lifeways.”

Different sections of the run featured running, walking, boating and bicycling and ended with a paddle in dugout canoes up Shasta Lake and the McCloud River arm, as well as a horseback ride to a village site where the tribe conducted a ceremony.

The run for salmon traces the route of winter run Chinook salmon from the estuary at Vallejo all of the way to the McCloud River where it enters Lake Shasta.

The tribe is trying to reintroduce the original run of McCloud winter run Chinooks, now thriving on the Rakaira River in New Zealand, where they were introduced over a hundred of years ago, back to their ancestral home on the McCloud. The tribe set up a Go Fund Me site to raise money to conduct DNA Testing of the Rakaira River salmon.

During our section of the trip, we passed many fishing boats on the way, but also saw evidence of some of the many threats posed to the river and its fish.

Gary Thomas, a Pomo Roundhouse leader from Lake County, pointed out the natural gas wells that line the river and the many pipelines that cross the river, posing a threat to the river and the environment, particularly in the Pittsburg to Rio Vista section of the river. We also boated by the Delta Cross Channel that diverts water from the Sacramento River to the Mokelumne and San Joaquin rivers.

We also took videos and photos of The Southport Levee Improvement Project, one of four designed to bring West Sacramento up to the state-mandated 200-year level of flood protection.

Caleen Sisk, Chief of the Winnemem Wintu Tribe, said UC Davis now has the DNA collected from 100 samples their tribe and other tribes collected on the Rakaira River in New Zealand this summer. The samples are now at UC Davis, where they are being tested by Dr. Michael Miller.

“We have to fight for these samples to be validated even though we know they are the original salmon,” said Sisk, as Netzel skippered the boat down up the river for the second year in a row. “The New Zealand government says these are our salmon. Maori officials say they are from the McCloud. And the Bureau and NOAA have no doubt they are our fish.”

“It’s a matter of the federal government wanting to utilize the hatchery winter run Chinook they have been raising,” said Sisk. “After testing, they will submit the samples to the Bureau and also to New Zealand and UC Davis.”

After the salmon are certified as the original winter run, then the Tribe will have to fight for passage on the Sacramento to the McCloud above Shasta Dam.

“Getting the fish around the dam is cheaper than truck and haul. The tribe wants to provide for fish passage by connecting a channel from Cow Creek, a tributary of the Sacramento River below Shasta Dam, to Dry Creek, a tributary that now flows into Shasta Lake,” said Sisk, who is currently running for the California Assembly in Assembly District 1.

One major problem is that the federal government won’t let the Winnemem participate in the meetings where fish passage and restoration plans are discussed, since over three decades ago their federally recognized status was taken away from them by means of a clerical error. More recently, Bureau Officials said the fish passage project has been suspended.

“They won’t let us on the committee for the restoration pilot project. They said it would take an act of Congress for us to get on the committee, even though the Tribe joined a 2009 lawsuit pushing for the restoration of the run,” she said.

Meanwhile, the U.S Bureau of Reclamation continues to move forward with its plan to raise Shasta Dam. Over the next several months, Bureau of Reclamation geologists will be extracting core samples from on, around and deep within Shasta Dam. Gathered data will be used to characterize concrete and geology conditions related to a proposed 18 ½ feet Shasta Dam raise, according to Todd Plain, Bureau of Reclamation spokesman.

The federal government has been studying the idea of raising the dam and enlarging Shasta Reservoir on and off since the 1980s. The Tribe held a “war dance” in 2004 and again in 2014 at the Shasta Dam opposing the raise.

“The current Shasta Dam and Reservoir Enlargement Project envisions raising the existing dam by 18 ½ feet, providing an additional 630,000 acre-feet of stored water for the environment and for water users,” according to Plain. “Enlarging the reservoir will improve water supply reliability for agricultural, municipal and industrial, and environmental uses; reduce flood damage; and improve water temperatures and water quality in the Sacramento River below the dam for anadromous fish survival.

Chief Sisk strongly disagrees that the raise will help anadromous fish survival and improve water temperatures and water quality.

“This is the most idiotic waste of millions of dollars since the 1980's with another billion dollars or more on a very old DAM. Will the BOR's drilling make people in Shasta County aware of how much toxic sediments exist in the bottom, will it show how big the water cave waves are that might not hold the new tonnage of an 18.5-foot raise?” asked Sisk.

The raising of the dam would not only threaten salmon and steelhead runs, but it will inundate many of the Tribe’s remaining sacred sites that weren’t already flooded when Shasta Dam was built, according to Sisk. She views the dam raise as part of bigger plan to export more Northern California water to corporate agribusiness and Southern California water agencies in conjunction with the proposed building of Sites Reservoir and the Delta Tunnels.

”Whatever happens to the salmon, happens to us,” Chief Sisk summed up.

Big thanks go to James Netzel of Tight Lines Guide Service, who is now guiding for fall salmon in the metropolitan area, and Alyx and Brennen Howell for donating their time to the Run4 Salmon.
§Caleen Sisk
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
Caleen Sisk, Chief and Spiritual Leader of the Winnemem Wintu Tribe, in the cabin on the boat driven by James Netzel of Tight Lines Guide Service at the Pittsburg Marina before going up the Sacramento River to Discovery Park in Sacramento. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Protest outside Reclamation
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
The Winnemem Wintu Tribe and their allies held a protest against the Shasta Dam raise at the Bureau of Reclamation Offices in September. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Fund Restoration Not Dams!
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
Chief Caleen Sisk says, "Fund Restoration Not Dams!" Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Restore the Salmon
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
These two supporters of the Winnemem hold up a beautiful banner supporting restoration of the winter run Chinook salmon to the McCloud River above Shasta Dam. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§No Dam Raise
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
"No Dam Raise" banner in front of the Bureau of Reclamation offices in Sacramento. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Run4Salmon Boat
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
Alyx and Brennen Howell skippered this boat up the Sacramento River on the Sacramento to Colusa segment of the journey. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Desirae Harp and Niria Alicia
by Dan Bacher Monday Jan 14th, 2019 2:09 AM
Desirae Harp and Niria Alice, Run4Salmon organizers, speak at the concert in Sacramento after the Bureau of Reclamation protest. Photo by Dan Bacher.

We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!


donate now

$ 77.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.


Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network