East Bay
East Bay
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

What Milo and the Alt-Right get wrong about the Free Speech Movement

by Anonymous
A speaking event by Milo Yiannopoulos at UC Berkeley was cancelled last night after a protest erupted outside the Student Union. Yiannopoulos was scheduled to appear at the Pauley Ballroom, inside the building. Milo and his supporters have claimed that the protest and the cancellation was counter to the values of Free Speech. The Alt-Right have tried to identify their movement as an extension, or modern incarnation, of the Free Speech movement. Milo's supporters have invoked Mario Savio's name to support their interpretation of the Free Speech Movement.
The Alt-Right is misguided in asserting that they are the modern day defenders of Free Speech on campuses. They misinterpret the intent of the Free Speech Movement for their own agenda. The Alt-Right depicts Milo Yiannopoulos as Mario Savio's equal, without examining what Savio said.

Mario Savio did not believe that Free Speech was absolute. Savio spoke of the responsibility that came with Free Speech. He hoped that the new found freedom on campus would be used responsibly. Mario Savio's statements in 1964 were similar to the 1962 Spider-Man quote: "With great power comes great responsibility". It can be argued that Milo's brand of divisive rhetoric is not responsible speech. A distinction can be made that separates out hate speech from Free Speech. Standing in front of a emotionally heated crowd, stirring up sexism, transphobia, fear of immigrants, fear of Muslims, and et cetera is socially irresponsible. At a time when hate crimes have been on the rise, according to civil rights organizations and the FBI's own statistics, Milo's untempered statements fuel more hatred.

"There's a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you so sick at heart, that you can't take part! You can't even passively take part! And you've got to put your bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels…upon the levers, upon all the apparatus, and you've got to make it stop!" - Mario Savio

The most famous quotation of the Free Speech Movement is the "bodies upon the gears" portion of Mario Savio's speech given on Sproul Plaza. Savio called for people to stop odiously unjust systems. Yiannopoulos works for Breitbart, a media organization described by its own members as a platform for the Alt-Right. The former executive chair of Breitbart, Steve Bannon, is currently the White House Chief Strategist. No other media organization has closer ties to the office of the President than Breitbart. Breitbart media is a gear in the machine. The protesters at UC Berkeley put their bodies upon a gear, and shut down the apparatus from operating inside the student union.

The protest at UC Berkeley happened days after protests at SFO (and other airports in the US) against Donald Trump's ban on Muslims entering the United States from 7 blacklisted nations. Muslims, including greencard holders and citizen residents, were detained at airports, while searched and interrogated. Steve Bannon, who has ties to white nationalist groups, oversaw the drafting of the anti-Muslim travel ban. Breitbart media began supporting a travel ban in 2015, and continuing into 2016, when Steve Bannon was still executive chair. At CAIR press conference in New York to discuss a legal challenge against the travel ban, Breitbart employee Neil Munro caused a disruption and accused CAIR of not supporting the rights of "actual Americans". As part of Breitbart, Milo also deals in unmitigated Islamophobia.

Donald Trump is threatening to cut off funding to sanctuary cities which includes cities like Berkeley. Breitbart media is a sounding board for distrust against sanctuary cities and undocumented immigrants. Breitbart staff editorializes against sanctuary cities. Milo interviewed Joe Arpaio to help his 2016 re-election campaign for sheriff of Arizona's Mericopa County. Arpaio had fallen under scrutiny by the Justice Department, the ACLU and faith-based human-rights organizations. At the University of New Mexico stop in his college tour, Yiannopoulos said that the southern border "must be controlled if America is to flourish", while speaking in favor of Trump's proposed border wall. At the University of New Mexico, Yiannopoulos rallied for those in attendance to report undocumented students and workers to ICE.

On the night of Trump's inauguration (January 20), a fan of Milo Yiannopoulos shot a protester at the University of Washington in Seattle. The shooter was waiting in line to attend the Seattle stop of Milo's college tour. After becoming aware of what occurred, Milo lauded the shooting, telling the crowd "if we don't continue, they have won." Nobody from Breitbart news has condemned the shooting, nor has anyone from Breitbart condemned Milo's suggestion for more gun violence.

The Alt-Right do not share the same ideals as the Free Speech Movement. The Alt-Right did not rise from the lineage of protests in Berkeley since the 1960s. Milo is not the new Mario Savio. He and his colleagues at Breitbart are parts of the machine, a machine so odious that you've got to make it stop.
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by Legal definition
No one has a right to falsely yell fire in a crowded theater. Fascists like Milo are blaming victims, commonly known as scapegoating, for the problems of the private profit system. Further, fascists by definition adhere to a movement that has committed heinous crimes, namely mass murder as in Nazi Germany. Proven mass murderers and their supporters cannot hide behind the free speech slogan because their speech promotes genocide.

In 1964, when the Free Speech Movement became known at UC Berkeley, it was an outgrowth of the Civil Rights Movement since its proponents were veterans of voter registration drives in the South for blacks and when they came to UCB, they were told political literature tables were not allowed in Sproul Plaza. UCB attacked all political groups so the response was to demand free speech for all. This has nothing to do with the attempt to resurrect the bad old days at UCB with rich white boys promoting hate. The 1960s was a time of comparative prosperity, when our movements benefitted from the gains of the labor movement of the 1930s and 1940s. We now live in a time of poverty, much like the 1930s, when the rich white boys at UCB were used as strikebreakers in the 1934 San Francisco General Strike.

History only repeats itself as a farce. Today, the movements that were nurtured in the 1960s are now broad-based and the laws have changed in favor of civil rights for all, ethnic studies is everywhere, concern about the environment is widespread and codified into law, women are the majority at most public universities , including UCB (it was mostly white men in the student body in 1964), and the white, European population is declining rapidly in the US, which is now 64% white, Euro descent, and a median age of 42 and rising. We have to raise our voice wherever the terrible past raises its head, and in doing so, the fascist rats scurry for cover forever.
by Goat
I contacted lduval@edu on the UCB website, the folks in charge of bringing milo Yianstupolous to campus, voicing my concerns about hate speech on campus. Not what Mario Savio had in mind. I got trolled by some idiot UCB republican party guy who kept sending me emails about how the supreme court said it was OK for the klan and white aryan resistance to march, and, if they were invited on campus, would be allowed to speak. The response from the speakers bureau kinda blew my mind most bitterly. Yes, I've know the connection to UC's connection to Lawrence Livermore Labs, nuke power, weapons research for years, but inciting hatred toward immigrants, LGBT, ALL people of color, etc., by milo y. is unacceptable. When is enough enough? STRIKE! RISE! RESIST! Thank you to all who took part in keeping hate speech off the UC campus.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!


$40.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.


Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network