From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Petition Launched over Citizens United Impact on Alameda Politics
Alameda residents have started a petition to block State Democratic Party endorsement of 18th Assembly District Candidate Rob Bonta, as he was the beneficiary of massive, anonymous spending in 2010, as a result of the Citizen's United decision.
Alameda residents have started a petition to block State Democratic Party endorsement of 18th Assembly District Candidate Rob Bonta, as he was the beneficiary of massive, anonymous spending in 2010, as a result of the Citizen's United decision.
Here is the text of the petition letter:
We are asking your help to fight against the local effects of the Citizens United decision in the City of Alameda and the 18th Assembly District. We want the California Democratic Party to block any possible endorsement of Rob Bonta for the 18th Assembly District when a local committee of Democrats will decide between Mr. Bonta and Peralta College Trustee Abel Guillen on July 15, 2012.
Because of the Citizens United decision the City of Alameda's last city council race saw a tremendous number of anonymous negative mailers attacking every viable council candidate except two. Rob Bonta was one of the two candidates not attacked in the flood of mailers and he was elected to the city council. Because of the onslaught of hundreds of thousands of dollars of negative ads flooding the mailboxes in a city of 42,000 registered voters, Alameda is one of the first small cities to feel the effects of the Citizens United decision.
The City of Alameda in the 18th Assembly District has a large area of available real estate, Alameda's former Naval Air Station, which comprises about 20% of the Island of Alameda. When a large developer failed to get what it wanted from either the Alameda City Council or the voters of Alameda (their proposal failed 85% to 15% in a special election on February 2, 2010) they threatened Mayor Beverly Johnson stating they would simply get the people they wanted elected to the city council. They proved this with their attack mailers for the November 2010 city council election. Voters were inundated with mailers attacking every credible candidate except two. Thanks to the Citizens United decision, the mailers were from an anonymous group. However, the out-of-town mailers did come from the same office building which housed a subsidiary of the developer who threatened Mayor Johnson. During that election Mayor Johnson repeatedly kept asking voters, "Look at who is NOT being attacked." (Mayor Johnson described theses threats and made that statement at the Alameda League of Women Voters. The video is available at http://alameda.ca.lwvnet.org/elections.html)
Given this electoral history, if Mr. Bonta is named as the official candidate of the Democratic Party, it will be a de facto endorsement of the Citizens United decision. Mr. Bonta's Democratic opponent, Peralta College Trustee Abel Guillen, has never been a beneficiary of massive, outside attack mailers. Therefore, we are asking the California Democrat Party to intervene so that either Mr. Guillen is designated the Democratic standard bearer or, at a minimum, no endorsement is made letting the voters of the 18th Assembly District choose their next assembly member. The 18th Assembly District has an overwhelming Democratic registration and anyone named the Democratic Party's official candidate has an overwhelming advantage. The Citizens United decision has already allowed anonymous real estate developers to give a large advantage to Mr. Bonta. The Democratic Party should not be following that example but fight against it.
To be clear, this is not a personal attack on Mr. Bonta. This is a recitation of history. We ask your help so that history does not repeat itself.
Here is the text of the petition letter:
We are asking your help to fight against the local effects of the Citizens United decision in the City of Alameda and the 18th Assembly District. We want the California Democratic Party to block any possible endorsement of Rob Bonta for the 18th Assembly District when a local committee of Democrats will decide between Mr. Bonta and Peralta College Trustee Abel Guillen on July 15, 2012.
Because of the Citizens United decision the City of Alameda's last city council race saw a tremendous number of anonymous negative mailers attacking every viable council candidate except two. Rob Bonta was one of the two candidates not attacked in the flood of mailers and he was elected to the city council. Because of the onslaught of hundreds of thousands of dollars of negative ads flooding the mailboxes in a city of 42,000 registered voters, Alameda is one of the first small cities to feel the effects of the Citizens United decision.
The City of Alameda in the 18th Assembly District has a large area of available real estate, Alameda's former Naval Air Station, which comprises about 20% of the Island of Alameda. When a large developer failed to get what it wanted from either the Alameda City Council or the voters of Alameda (their proposal failed 85% to 15% in a special election on February 2, 2010) they threatened Mayor Beverly Johnson stating they would simply get the people they wanted elected to the city council. They proved this with their attack mailers for the November 2010 city council election. Voters were inundated with mailers attacking every credible candidate except two. Thanks to the Citizens United decision, the mailers were from an anonymous group. However, the out-of-town mailers did come from the same office building which housed a subsidiary of the developer who threatened Mayor Johnson. During that election Mayor Johnson repeatedly kept asking voters, "Look at who is NOT being attacked." (Mayor Johnson described theses threats and made that statement at the Alameda League of Women Voters. The video is available at http://alameda.ca.lwvnet.org/elections.html)
Given this electoral history, if Mr. Bonta is named as the official candidate of the Democratic Party, it will be a de facto endorsement of the Citizens United decision. Mr. Bonta's Democratic opponent, Peralta College Trustee Abel Guillen, has never been a beneficiary of massive, outside attack mailers. Therefore, we are asking the California Democrat Party to intervene so that either Mr. Guillen is designated the Democratic standard bearer or, at a minimum, no endorsement is made letting the voters of the 18th Assembly District choose their next assembly member. The 18th Assembly District has an overwhelming Democratic registration and anyone named the Democratic Party's official candidate has an overwhelming advantage. The Citizens United decision has already allowed anonymous real estate developers to give a large advantage to Mr. Bonta. The Democratic Party should not be following that example but fight against it.
To be clear, this is not a personal attack on Mr. Bonta. This is a recitation of history. We ask your help so that history does not repeat itself.
For more information:
http://www.change.org/petitions/the-chairm...
Add Your Comments
Comments
(Hide Comments)
These folks continue to misunderstand the issues, misrepresent the facts and mislead the public, David Howard and his cohort should be embarrassed, but they have no shame. Anyone signing this silly petition makes clear that they have no idea what they are signing. The petition is ridiculous, skips significant facts, makes huge leaps of logic and shows the authors to be the liars and cheaters that they are......yet another losing tactic from the fringe.
Abel Guillen has never been the beneficiary of massive outside attack mailers? I'm sure Joel Young disagrees.
Anonymous comments are as suspect as the anonymous corporate donations being funneled into campaigns as a result of the US Supreme Court's Citizens United decision.
Mr. Guillen has never been the beneficiary of outside attack mailers? What a joke. Do you live in the district? He got 5 or 6 targeting Young and another few supporting him. Guillen's the special interest candidate.
It was clear to anyone in Alameda in the November 2010 election race that SunCal made good on their promise to interfere with the election and get their own crew onto the dais.
See the link to copies of some of the mailers. The mailers said only good things about Bonta, and his pal Lena Tam (they shared campaign strategists and campaign treasurer), and attacked any candidate who was not Bonta, Tam or Marie Gilmore.
It's clear SunCal and other developers will expect Bonta to do their bidding in Sacramento.
See the link to copies of some of the mailers. The mailers said only good things about Bonta, and his pal Lena Tam (they shared campaign strategists and campaign treasurer), and attacked any candidate who was not Bonta, Tam or Marie Gilmore.
It's clear SunCal and other developers will expect Bonta to do their bidding in Sacramento.
For more information:
http://www.scribd.com/Alameda500
None of those flyers mention Bonta in the slightest.
Not all of the mailers that were sent were captured on Scribd. Anyone in Alameda received several similar mailers touting Bonta's "track record" with Alameda Hospital, schools, etc.
Tam and Bonta shared campaign managers and a campaign treasurer - they were arm in arm.
Tam and Bonta shared campaign managers and a campaign treasurer - they were arm in arm.
Very disappointed on how everyone is sold on the slickness of Bonta. He has no support from actual working people, but is supported by folks who like his parents for their work but not his work. He has a circle of friends that keep secrets especially about his anti-labor actions by him and his wife and also his children being pulled out of school for bullying another child. This must stop. You cannot represent us in Alameda if you only came to our city to run for office thinking we are easily sold on your appearance. We have more substance. He is a city attorney. Do you know that city attorney's represent management not the people. John Russo was a city attorney for Oakland, he didn't represent the people of Oakland and now we also have him in Alameda. Let's not be lied to anymore about Bonta's accomplishments, he hasn't any. He made a mess of our hospital by "waffling", tried to get us all to pay more sales tax dollars because he didn't know how else to balance a budget and then tried to claim he got our schools millions when all he did was volunteer like the rest of us did. He is not a man to be trusted because he isn't about the work. He is about the prestige and he even admits that.
When you have nothing of substance to write, attack the children of candidates with unsubstantiated rumors. Stay Classy!
Have to agree with the comment made by Nice one! - I was equally disappointed by Deanna's accusations. As has been noted elsewhere, "It is the policy of the Bonta campaign to not comment on the content of blogs posted by individuals whose only intent is obviously to incite." But in this case, it's the unfounded attacks against Rob's wife and children that are inappropriate and are exactly what must stop. They have no place in this campaign, or any other. I would ask that serious readers with genuine questions or concerns email or contact the Bonta campaign directly. That way, they can hear directly from the source and come to their own conclusions about which candidate to support in this race.
Would anyone from Mr. Bonta's campaign care to comment on a report that Mr. Bonta was photographed crossing a union picket line at the Alameda Theater, to get to an event he was holding there?
I.A.T.S.E. Local 169 has been picketing Alameda Theater off and on for several years now over Kyle Connor - he leases the theater from the City - and his use of non-union labor to run the projectors.
I.A.T.S.E. Local 169 has been picketing Alameda Theater off and on for several years now over Kyle Connor - he leases the theater from the City - and his use of non-union labor to run the projectors.
For more information:
http://www.action-alameda-news.com/2008/11...
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network