From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Related Categories: Afghanistan | Iraq | California | International | North Bay / Marin | San Francisco | U.S. | Anti-War | Police State and Prisons
A Different Commemoration of the 9/11 Tragedy - 4
by Bill Carpenter (wcarpent [at]
Wednesday Sep 21st, 2011 4:57 AM
September 11, 2011
San Francisco Golden Gate Bridge
Norman Solomon, candidate for the House of Representatives in California's District #2 speaks in this four-minute QT movie, 12MB.

A Different Commemoration of the 9/11 Tragedy:
Part 1: Patty Bennett
Part 2: Stephanie Tang
Part 3: Paul Cox & Francis Collins
Part 4: This is pt. 4
Part 5: Fatima & Toby Blome

by Bill Carpenter Wednesday Sep 21st, 2011 4:57 AM
by Bill Carpenter Wednesday Sep 21st, 2011 4:57 AM
by Bill Carpenter Wednesday Sep 21st, 2011 4:57 AM

Comments  (Hide Comments)

by (A)
Wednesday Sep 21st, 2011 8:53 AM
what is the peace movement's aversion to the truth?
by billy badass
Saturday Sep 24th, 2011 12:58 PM
It's being spouted by nutcases and sometimes holocaust deniers. AND DON"T CALL ME A ZIONIST!!!
by 9/11 Was an Inside Job
Sunday Sep 25th, 2011 8:58 AM
The reason too many in the alleged peace movement do not face reality that 9/11 was an Inside Job is because they are not workingclass, not scientists, and/or not thinkers. The poorest sectors of the workingclass knew immediately 9/11 was an Inside Job because that it was the police do all the time to the workingclass: set up people, frame people, plant evidence, tell lies.

You do not have to be any kind of leftist to realize the 9/11 was an Inside Job. It was a crime and criminal investigators are of all political outlooks. That is why there are people who claim to support the 9/11 Truth Movement whose politics are otherwise reactionary. Examing the evidence is what all lawyers do in all cases, and it has nothing to do with their politics.

The scientists, architects and engineers who are defending their science come from various backgrounds, mostly reactionary. They know a controlled demolition when they see one and they know the laws of physics, a 10-second or less collapse of a building in its own footprint can only be controlled demolition.

The promotion of an upcoming DVD on Building 7 is at
It shows a series of interviews with engineers and architects answering a group of questions. The whole DVD is a crescendo indictment of the government lies. At the end is a segment of psychologists and how they came to understand 9/11 was an Inside Job. They made such statements as they trust the American government to protect them until 9/11/01. Such a statement sounds ludicrous to those of us who are either workingclass victims of daily police harassment or come from a political background of constant attacks by the US government for our politics. It appears that too many peace groups still trust the American government to protect anyone when they do not even protect themselves; there is a constant falling out among thieves over the money, which is what the 9/11 Inside Job was about: Maximizing profits from oil and munitions.

All of the lies about hijackers and Bin Laden were the anti-Muslim fairytale to justify this crime. There were no hijackers on those planes; 9 of the so-called hijackers were alive on 9/12/01; there were no Arab names on the passenger lists. These so-called hijackers were supposedly devout Muslims and drunken womanizers at the same time! The whole trip to Maine these hijackers supposedly made makes no sense. The extraordinary maneuver over the Pentagon the inexperienced so-called hijacker supposedly made is also ridiculous. The government even promotes the lie that a passport survived the fire of a jet crash! Anyone who paid any attention to the government's story knew immediately that IT WAS A LIE.

Other people cannot comprehend how such a project can be a secret. The Manhattan Project, that ended with the production of the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, was a secret. There were 130,000 participants from the US, UK and Canada. For more, see

The 9/11 Inside Job was also a military operation, with the US air force guiding the planes by remote control, setting explosives in the construction area of the Pentagon and possibly also hitting it with a US missile or small plane, and carrying out the controlled demolition with the military substance, thermate, of the Twin Towers and Building 7. The military was and is under the control of the ruling capitalist class and exists at all times to maximize the profits of the capitalist class, the primary goal and law of capitalism, with the greatest profits being in war, particularly oil and munitions.

Anyone in the peace community has heard about the heinous crimes the US government has perpetrated around the world. They also know about the attacks on the peace movement by the US government. Thus, 10 years later, there is no excuse anymore for not saying it out loud every chance you get: 9/11 was an Inside Job as that is what NO AIR DEFENSE and CONTROLLED DEMOLITION mean. And from now on, whenever any such incident occurs, you must assume it was an Inside Job until proven otherwise.

By referring to this American Reichstag Fire as an Inside Job, we end the police state and rape at the airports, the scapegoating of Muslims, and the false imprisonment of attorney Lynne Stewart and many other people. The biggest bully is the biggest coward and when you speak the truth out loud, they stop the attack on all of us.

As to parading on the freezing cold Golden Gate Bridge where no one lives, to build a peace movement, you must organize the workingclass to stop fighting these wars, and for that you must have peace marches in the workingclass communities. You are not organizing anyone with these publicity stunts on a bridge. The fact that some peace groups constantly run to the Golden Gate Bridge for a demonstration shows their very weak, bourgeois politics. They simply have no idea as to the cause of war and the class struggle.

Here is your homework in case you need more information:
DVD that is a Must See at

San Francisco Bay Area site that combines the economy with 9/11 Truth: (The 9/11 Files) which has announcement and picture of Building 7 just before controlled demolition although not hit by any plane and a picture of Dr. Steven Jones, a physics expert, who found thermate, a military incendiary substance, in the dust of the demolished World Trade Center):
Every Weekday – 1 hour – at 3pm Pacific * 6pm Eastern * 22:00 GMT
9/11 Teach-in
Don’t Miss our Sunday – 911 Teach-in Marathon – 5 hours every Sunday
9am Pacific * 12 noon Eastern * 16:00 GMT – Sunday.
a compilation of all 5 previous weekday shows.,
heard at 94.1 FM, KPFA, Berkeley, CA Wednesdays at 1 p.m. and on WBAI, New York, 99.5 FM, Fridays at 9 a.m. and online at: (Griffin: Bin Laden died Dec 2001) (Dr. Pieczenik: Bin Laden died Dec 2001 of marfan syndrome, genetic disease that shortens life span.) (DNA sample not possible in time frame given.)
(Roberts, 8/4/11: The Mysterious Death of OBL: Creating Evidence Where There Is None)
(Fiction Film on Bin Laden “death” appearing 1 month before 2012 presidential election-further proof that it was a campaign publicity stunt to boost a failed presidency.)

Go to Socialist Viewpoint at
for videos and articles on the 9/11 Truth Movement including, in Volume 9, No. 3, May-June 2009, “Exotic High Tech Explosives Positively Identified in World Trade Center Dust” by Editor, Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth, which also has this article at: based on a scientific article at
by Niels H. Harris, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley, Bradley R. Larsen.
See also: (physics tutorial) (architects & engineers) (Scholars for 9/11 Truth & Justice) (911 timeline) Veterans Medical Professionals

1.Crossing the Rubicon by Michael Ruppert
2.9/11 Facing Our Fascist State by Don Paul (Excellent research all done in 2001-2002; obviously an Inside Job from the beginning. The evidence is in this book.)
3.Waking Up From Our Nightmare by Don Paul and Jim Hoffman (Good color photos & research)
4.Cognitive Infiltration by David Griffin (2010) (The title is an insidious phrase promoted by an alleged lawyer appointee of Barack Obama, Cass Sunstein, promoting an illegal activity, joining and disrupting 9/11 Truth Movement organizations instead of open debate, providing evidence for the government’s conspiracy theory, which does not exist. Sunstein-Obama are openly promoting fascism. This book does reiterate all the evidence for the 9/11 Truth Movement in 156 pages plus 477 footnotes.)
5.The Mysterious Collapse of World Trade Center 7 by David Griffin (2009)
6.Osama bin Laden: Dead or Alive? by David Griffin (2009) (Bin laden died in Dec 2001). See also
7.New Pearl Harbor Revisited by David Griffin (2008)
8.The Hidden History of 9/11, ed by Paul Zarembka (2008), articles by David Griffin, Jay Kolar, Zarembka, Don Trent Jacobs, Nafez Ahmed, David MacGregor, Bryan Sacks, Diana Ralph, with Appendix by Bertrand Russell: 16 Questions on the JFK Assassination (teaches how to investigate a crime)
9.The 9/11 Conspiracy, edited James Fetzer (2007), articles by John Austin, David Griffin, James Fetzer, Jack White, Judy Wood, Joseph Firmage, Morgan Reynolds, Rick Rajter, Elias Davidsson, Peter Dale Scott, John McMurty plus excellent photos
10. 9/11 Contradictions by David Griffin (2008)
11. The 9/11 Commission Report: Omissions & Distortions by David Griffin
12. The New Pearl Harbor by David Griffin
13. Debunking 9/11 Debunking by David Griffin
14.Painful Questions by Eric Hufschmid
15. The Iron Triangle (on the Carlyle Group) by Dan Briody
16. 9/11 Revealed: The Unanswered Questions by Rowland Morgan & Ian Henshall
17. 9/11 Synthetic Terror: Made in USA by Webster Tarpley
18. Body of Secrets by James Bamford (Good on Operation Northwoods)
19. The War on Truth by Nafeez Mossadeq Ahmed
20. Towers of Deception by Barrie Zwicker (with DVD enclosed)
21. 9/11 and American Empire edited by David Ray Griffin and Peter Dale Scott
22. Flight 93 Revealed by Ian Henshall and Rowland Morgan
23.The Terror Timeline by Paul Thompson
24.Welcome to Terrorland: Mohammed Atta & the 9/11 Coverup in Florida by Daniel Hopsicker
25.The Big Wedding: 9/11, The Whistleblowers and The Coverup by Sander Hicks
26.The Terror Conspiracy by Jim Marrs
27.Inside Job by Jim Marrs
28.Forbidden Truth by Jean-Charles Brisard & Guillaume Dasquie
29.Pentagate by Thierry Meyssan
30.9/11: The Big Lie by Thierry Meyssan