top
East Bay
East Bay
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Serial Killers of the Oakland Police Department Strike Again

by Revolution Books (revolutionbooks [at] sbcglobal.net)
Eight months after the murder of Oscar Grant by BART police—after protests in the streets, after several meetings about a citizen’s review board, after saccharine official apologies mixed with vicious official threats against the people—the police are still shooting people on the streets of Oakland. On August 1, a Saturday night, Brownie Polk, a 46-year-old father, was shot to death by an Oakland cop. This is the second killing of a Black man by the Oakland Police Department in less than a month. Parnell Smith was shot by OPD on the same street, International Boulevard, about 55 blocks away, on July 15.
640_brownie_portrait_for_newspaper.jpg
Serial Killers of the Oakland Police Department Strike Again

Eight months after the murder of Oscar Grant by BART police—after protests in the streets, after several meetings about a citizen’s review board, after saccharine official apologies mixed with vicious official threats against the people—the police are still shooting people on the streets of Oakland. On August 1, a Saturday night, Brownie Polk, a 46-year-old father, was shot to death by an Oakland cop. This is the second killing of a Black man by the Oakland Police Department in less than a month. Parnell Smith was shot by OPD on the same street, International Boulevard, about 55 blocks away, on July 15.

A woman officer shot Brownie Polk multiple times at close range. The police claim he was advancing on the cop and threatening her with a hatchet. But Brownie’s friends and relatives say that Brownie carried tools everywhere he went, and would not threaten anyone. Police say that the liquor store owner called them because Brownie was creating a disturbance, but the store owner denies that he had called police, saying that Brownie was well known at the store, came there every day. A clerk there told Revolution that he was shocked to hear about the shooting, and couldn’t believe that Brownie would threaten anyone. Another clerk told the media that it was the officer who charged at Brownie—and then shot him. Brownie Polk’s sister told the San Francisco Chronicle, “He would never charge at police with a hatchet. He would never do it. I would bet my life on it.” The OPD says the shooting was justified, and that a surveillance video from the store backs their story, but as of the writing of this article the police refuse to release the video.

Revolution newspaper, the Revolution Club and others went to the East Oakland neighborhood shortly after the incident was reported, to investigate, to expose the system behind this murder, and to build resistance, as part of building a revolutionary movement. The revolutionaries distributed the statement “The Revolution We Need...The Leadership We Have,” and pointed people to the part which reads: “It is up to us: to wake up…to shake off the ways they put on us, the ways they have us thinking so they can keep us down and trapped in the same old rat-race…to rise up, as conscious Emancipators of Humanity. The days when this system can just keep on doing what it does to people, here and all over the world…when people are not inspired and organized to stand up against these outrages and to build up the strength to put an end to this madness…those days must be GONE. And they CAN be.”

Five minutes on the street and you knew two things: Brownie Polk was loved. And people were angered at his unjust execution. “It was murder. It was something we always feared growing up, being killed by the police,” said Tony, a childhood friend. “I loved Brownie, and every day I go to the memorial [outside the liquor store] to light the candles.” Another friend wrote a statement about how she loved Brownie, and sarcastically referred to the cops’ lies in the Oscar Grant case, asking, “Was this a mistake again? Maybe they thought they were reaching for their taser, but instead they reached for their gun. Did their finger slip and accidentally shoot him four times instead of one? Do you think that a hatchet could travel as fast as a bullet?...No, I don’t think so. It’s his line of work, that was a tool of use to do his job and I don’t think it would have been as fatal as a bullet...oh excuse me...four bullets!”

Brownie grew up in Oakland, and had lived in the same house in that neighborhood for many years; everyone knew him and relied on him as a handyman; he did construction, painting, fixed the kids’ bikes. He was always working and always ready to help.

Friends said Brownie had a playful saying, his way of talking about the oppressed, he said it all the time, “Don’t forget about the little people.” And this appeared on tribute t-shirts and on memorials inside and outside the liquor store, and outside of Brownie’s house. “Don’t forget about the little people.”

The revolutionaries distributed the statement from the RCP in front of the liquor store where he had been killed. People stopped to talk about their outrage against this latest police murder. Soon a small number of revolutionaries and people from the neighborhood took off down the street toward Brownie’s house, chanting, fists in the air: “Justice for Brownie Polk” and “No More Stolen Lives, Enough is Enough.” By the time they marched back to the store there were about 50 people.

People from the neighborhood spoke on the bullhorn and talked of Brownie’s love for his neighbors: Black, white, and Latino. And they loved him. An older Mexican couple told us that they were one of the first Mexican families to move there many years ago, and Brownie was the first one to break the ice, to welcome them to the neighborhood, and called her “Ma.” “The police think they can do whatever they want. And that can’t go on anymore. We have to do something,” said an older Latino man. “We need a much better future for our little ones.” Women pointed out that Brownie respected them, and would escort the women wherever they had to go. In front of the house where he had lived, many people cried as others spoke out about Brownie and against what the police had done. One man talked about the hopes that Brownie had for the “little people” changing the world. The revolutionaries agitated that we need a revolution, and that we have a plan, organization, strategy and a leader, Bob Avakian. The chants became: “What do we need?—Revolution! Who’s gonna make it? The little people. Who’s gonna lead it? Bob Avakian.” Some people already were familiar with this revolution through the newspaper, and one woman had worked with the October 22nd Coalition to Stop Police Brutality, Repression, and the Criminalization of a Generation, but many were just hearing about the RCP and Bob Avakian for the first time. People wanted to know who Bob Avakian is and more about him, and the revolutionaries summed up there’s lots of openness, but that we have a lot of work to do to help people delve into materials like the statement and the DVD—Revolution: Why It’s Necessary, Why It’s Possible, What It’s All About. A man from the neighborhood told people to find out for themselves by getting the newspaper and urged them to “get with this revolution family.”

The next evening we returned and many people welcomed us again. People were still grieving, hurting, but quite a few wanted to give expression to their outrage. So there was another march through the neighborhood, and young women from the neighborhood played a big role, taking up the bullhorn, and challenging people to come off their porches and join it. They led chants in English and in Spanish. We soon ran out of the posters we had made with the excerpt from the statement with the faces of Brownie Polk and Oscar Grant. Some people in the neighborhood who had been active with the RCP in the past embraced us as old friends, and spoke out, answering some of the political questions others had, about revolution, about Bob Avakian, and whether revolution, and this party is for real, like the stickers say. As the evening continued, some Cuban neighbors played a rhumba on congas, cowbell and shekere in front of the house. Friends and family had a barbecue in Brownie’s honor and generously and warmly invited the revolutionaries to eat, and stay and talk some more about ending police murder, about revolution and about the far better future that is possible as well as urgently needed.
§Brownie Polk (courtesy of Marsha Polk-Townsend)
by Revolution Books
640_brownie_s_house_34_crop.jpg
August 4, 2009 in the neighborhood
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by an anarquist
Why is the RCP glomming on opportunistically to this police murder? And who the fuck cares about what Bob Avakian thinks about this?
by a different anarchist
Hey comrade, no offense, I think its kinda lame for you to hate on the RCP for this particular action. There are many critiques of them which are hella legitimate, (The ubiquitous newspapers, the cult of Bob, their history with queer people, Kronstadt, etc.) but I feel like their biggest redeeming value is their engagement in anti-police projects. They have a very tough line to walk, trying to be as militant and visible as possible while still keeping things completely legal. Yeah, their graphic design, leader worship and sloganeering are off-putting for me, but there are a few things which they do pretty well that we anarchists should learn from.

For example the March for Stolen Lives they put on a few months ago was the most militant peaceful demonstration I've ever been to. The cops really wanted to intimidate people that day, and made the march walk a gauntlet for several blocks. It looked like they would attack at any second. That shit was intense! I've had more respect for them since then, because they refused to back down and not march, but they still didn't give the cops an excuse to attack.

Also, when one of their young activists was in court over the Oakland rebellion, they made sure all their people were at the hearings. When the DA dropped the charges, they had a rally at the court house. I think that was really nice of them, and it straight fucking warmed my heart to think of how stoked they must have been to see their friend's charges dropped. There have been a few occasions when I've been really underwhelmed by the local anarchist milieu's response to court hearings, and I think that's something we should work on.

Anyway, I know I'm rambling about some unrelated shit, but I really do think that despite all the sloganeering that their intentions are sincere. I respect them for taking on these local issues instead of focusing on things on the other side of the planet like many leftist groups do. I think that if we, as anarchists, were in that neighborhood talking to people and trying to organize a non-vanguardist response to this murder, then we'd have a place to criticize their specifics. But unfortunately we tend to organize amongst ourselves and not reach out to other communities. Except for the really awkward "who's gonna lead it? bob avakian!" bit, this sounds like the kind of work a revolutionary group should be doing. If we really want to destroy capitalism, we need to unite with potential allies and struggle from a place of mutual respect, mutual support for a diversity of tactics, and the desire for a real dialogue instead of tired ass name calling. I don't agree with them about dialectics, vanguardism, dictatorship of the proletariat, or the infallible sagacity of Bob Avakian. but I do agree with them that it is a fucking tragedy that the police murdered Brownie Polk, and that the only way things are gonna improve is if people rise up and kick the pigs out of our neighborhoods.
by (A)------->
those dumb asses glommed all over the oscar grant stuff too. I wouldnt mind it if i trusted it but i see it as an avenue they use to gain credibilty. It is another venue to sell papers and pat themselfs on the back for' being with the people'. I think that unfortunatly they also make things look like a political circus. they will go down to the court house when other groups are trying to do real, hands on support work, and sell papers and scream revolution(the word they invented), it just makes everyone there look stupid. and confuses things
by CK
Oakland is certainly in crisis these days, and it seems like it's getting continually worse. I just wanted to make one correction - to put the information out there - so that those who are interested will know. You were correct when you said that in the months following Oscar Grant's shooting death by BART Police that there have been several meetings about a citizen's review board. Those have been meetings to create a BART Citizen's Police Review Board. However, you then made the comment that the police are still shooting people on the streets of Oakland. Please note.. OPD has nothing to do with BART Police. Oakland ALREADY has a Oakland Citizen's Police Review Board that in fact does hold hearings and accepts/investigates ALL complaints by citizens against OPD. Complaints often range from procedural/rudeness/excessive force/failure to investigate to death. If you want to file a complaint you need to go to City Hall and be directed to CPRB. Thank you.
first, I agree with "a different anarchist" on about everything said

then I read between the lines of the glom talkers and it becomes apparent that that's why you don't see anarchists, as such, building relationships with people of color in oakland - they don't want to appear to be "glomming," appearances being more important than action. so the anarchists stay detached from fighting police violence right here in the bay area and are more comfortable holding big marches in SF against police violence half a world away in greece. really, that greece solidarity march was over 100 people yet oscar grant and other local police murders don't draw a tiny fraction of that from bay area anarchists, if any, nor do local anarchists organize related events or offer mutual aid for the efforts of non-anarchists. like it or not, anarchists are largely irrelevant to the struggle against police violence in the bay area

people here on indybay will huff and puff about that last paragraph, but I dare you to name anything, anything at all, that anarchists are doing now to fight against police violence in communities of color in the east bay, show solidarity, anything. cops continue to mow down black men at will and all you hear from so-called anarchists are snotty put-downs of other groups who try to get involved and show support


oh, and yes, Oakland has the CPRB, but currently it only handles about 10% of complaints against OPD. a move is currently under way to change that and make it 100%
by time to act

Gun Control for the Police???

it seems that the Police can't handle the responsability of carrying guns.
At least on Bart and in Oaland PD. why do we allow them to kill us?
why don't we just disarm them.
1. No guns
2. No Tasers
3. no Swat Teams (Death Squads)

What would happen if we just said No More!

ask yourself;
who would Jesus shoot?

We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$110.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network