East Bay
East Bay
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

No Justice No BART Demands Accountability at MacArthur Station, Oakland, 4/2/09: video

by dave id
On April 2nd at the MacArthur BART station, No Justice No BART defied the intimidation of two dozen riot police and metal barricades yet again and distributed fliers with campaign objectives to over 1000 commuters coming and going during rush hour. Many riders expressed support during discussions with demonstrators. Some even joined the rally to express their dissatisfaction with BART and its handling of the murder of Oscar Grant. To this date there has been no accountability demanded by BART of any of the officers present when Oscar Grant was murdered, Police Chief Gary Gee, or Board Director Dorothy Dugger who oversees BART police. All remain in the gainful employ of BART (except for Mehserle who resigned) and no one has been disciplined in any way for their actions or lack thereof. Committed for the long haul until justice is done, NJNB is currently making plans for their next steps, including a weekend demonstration at another BART station. Additionally, they intend to diversify targets and tactics in their ongoing campaign for justice for Oscar Grant.
Copy the code below to embed this movie into a web page:
(video 9:42)

Photos from the MacArthur action on April 2nd:

NJNB at Rockridge Station, 3/19/08:

NJNB's first action at the Fruitvale Station, 3/5/09:

No Justice No BART:


BART police officer Fred Crabtree shot Jerrold Hall, who was unarmed, in the back of his head with a shotgun at the Hayward station in 1992:

BART police officer David Betancourt killed a naked Bruce Edward Seward at the Hayward station in 2001:

BART has been caught lying about these murders and no one was ever held to account.

For a flashback on the cover-up of the murder of Oscar Grant, here's what BART was reporting to the media on January first, before video of the actual murder surfaced: "A young man allegedly involved in a fight aboard a BART train was shot to death by a BART police officer on the platform of the Fruitvale Station early New Year's Day, in the midst of a brawl.... BART spokesman Jim Allison said the victim was not restrained when the gun discharged." Note that it was in the "midst" of a brawl, they said, that Oscar Grant was not restrained when he was shot (in the back), and that the gun innocently "discharged." Once the video went public, Chief Gee had the gall to say that he found the footage to be inconclusive and that the public should just be patient while they investigated. Despite the fact that BART had video footage of Tony Pirone striking Grant just minutes before he was shot, BART did not initiate any investigation into Pirone's actions until after that footage was aired on TV three weeks later. Director Dorothy Dugger then remarked that it was a "new allegation of unreasonable force."

Now BART has one supposed investigation into the officers on the platform that night (none of whom called for medical assistance or even reported a shooting after Grant was shot) and another looking into if BART even needs a police force, but these "investigations" are being conducted by people BART itself chose without public input. Knowing even a glimmer of BART history, there is little reason to expect anything more than whitewash and self-justification from these investigations without sustained public pressure.

A former BART employee talks about BART's long time racial profiling here:

Kristian Williams recently spoke in Oakland on a future without police of any kind:

Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by listen well
Do watch the entire 9 minutes. The ending is especially powerful. thank you for filming this, David.
by Joe Tougas
The speakers are well spoken, and the video was well-shot and well-edited. The message is right-on: if you don't do something to stop it then you're part of the lynch mob. Big shout out to my homies in the video! See you when I get back from Beijing!
by nojusticenobart
by nojusticenobart
these are some chants we did

Dorothy Dugger… Covered up murder
Dorothy Dugger… Everybody heard (her)
Dorothy Dugger… Lied to your face
Dorothy Dugger… Is a disgrace
Dorothy Dugger… Fire
Dorothy Dugger… Fire…
Dorothy Dugger… Fire…
Dorothy Dugger… Fire…

Killer cops… Off our streets
Killer cops… Off our bart
Killer cops… Out the stations
Killer cops… Out our nation

Police Chief Gee
Is a liar
If he don’t retire
We need to fire

Police violence is no accident!
The community must represent!

Who don’t we need? BART POLICE
What don’t we want? BART POLICE
Who shot Jerrold Hall? BART POLICE
Who shot Bruce Seward? BART POLICE
Who shot Oscar Grant? BART POLICE
Who commits murder? BART POLICE
Who covers it up? BART POLICE

Oscar Grant died and they stayed silent
They don’t care when cops get violent.

Senator Feinstein (can substitute Governor Schwarzenegger/Ron Dellums/Tom Orloff /Barack Obama)
Where were you
Did you mourn for Oscar too?

Whose life do they value? Is it yours?
If you were shot would they say a word?

How we gonna win justice!? Gonna boycott BART
How we gonna win justice!? Gonna picket BART
How we gonna win justice!? Gonna disrupt BART
How we gonna win justice!? Gonna protest BART
by wondering
Protesters have taken BART to the demonstrations before. Did that happen again?

Since you are obviously incapable of shutting down BART, please at least stop using the system you want to boycott.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!


$15.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.


Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network