top
Haiti
Haiti
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Haiti and Venezuela: Reverse Solidarity of International Labor Organizations

by Upside Down World
Pacfica Radio's Flashpoints' Dennis Bertsein interviews Kim Scipes, an assistant professor in Sociology at a branch of Purdue University and Jeb Sprague, Freelance journalist, graduate student, and Special Correspondent for Flashpoints.
picture1.png
Dennis Bernstein/ Flashpoints: Many in the U.S. see the AFL-CIO as a huge effective union [federation] representing tens of thousands of workers in this country, which may be true and is but it is not widely understood that the union joined hands with the U.S. State Department and spy and propaganda agencies to undermine foreign governments in the guise of supporting democracy in the good old USA fashion. In recent days this is no where more obvious than in Haiti and Venezuela – the United States has been heavily engaged in both countries and has availed themselves of various subsets of the AFL-CIO to subvert the will of the people and to undermine self determination in both these countries. Joining us to talk about this is Jeb Sprague. He is the author of "Failed Solidarity," an article about the AFL-CIO and other organizations and their secret and not-so-secret work to undermine the will of the people in Haiti. It appears on the web and magazine Labor Notes. Also appearing with us is Kim Scipes, an assistant professor in Sociology at a branch of Purdue University. He is an expert in the foreign operations of the AFL-CIO. We appreciate both of you joining us on Flashpoints. Let me start with you professor. Give us a blueprint because of those of us who are unionists get nervous when we think about the AFL-CIO abroad it could be the CIA. Kim Scipes: Well that’s true. But it’s a little more complex. The AFL-CIO leadership, and this is the top leadership, I want to state from the beginning, it’s [going on] behind the backs of [AFL-CIO] members. But the top leadership going back into the nineteen teens-has run its own independent foreign policy. They were involved in the Mexican revolution, they were involved setting foreign policy about the Soviet Union. Coming forward, they were involved in helping to overthrow the democratically elected government of Guatemala in 1954, the democratically elected government in Brazil in 1964, the democratically elected government in Chile in 1973 and the attempted coup against the democratically elected government in Venezuela 2002. So they’ve got this long foreign policy that is done behind the back. They refuse to come clean to individual members such as myself but the California AFL-CIO has also rejected [critique of] the foreign policy programs. So despite different efforts at all kinds of levels within the labor movement they have hid, they operate behind our backs although in our name. See the rest of the interview at http://upsidedownworld.org/main/content/view/327/1/
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by Sue
Yes, the CTV in Venezuela was being supported by the AFL-CIO. and now we see the ICFTU was supporting pro-coup labor. the ICFTU and ORIT works closely with AFL-CIO. We can see this from past research on their role in Nicaragua .
by Jean
Jeb Sprague, who doesn't want his readers to know that Aristide stole at over $21 million from Teleco, as referred to in Lucy Komisar's excellent article on the CorpWatch website. "Haiti Telecom Kickbacks Tarnish Aristide," http://www.corpwatch.org/print_article.php?id=12990. For background on Sprague's own questionable background and honesty, best to read "Reported Long Beach Union theft cause for last minute Elections Commission meeting, " an article from the California State University Long Beach (where Sprague attends) chronicling his dubious activities there. It can be found at http://www.csulb.edu/~d49er/archives/2005/spring/news/volLVno105-union.shtml.

by CSULB
Ryan Holliday and Elijah Bates are republican fascist goons. They attempted to go after Sprague and a number of other campus progressives at CSULB with false charges. The charges were dropped and Elijah Bates himself was put under investigation by the campus police for assault and battery on one member of the campus progressives. Get your facts straight.
by Claude - BC
Great interview! Just Listened to it!
by Jean II
It is a shame to see Jeb Sprague resort to epithets and name-calling (under assumed names) instead of addressing the intentional inaccuracies and omissions in his reporting, as well as his own background of fabrication and distortion.

Jeb Sprague would have readers believe that Ryan Holliday and Elijah Bates are "republican (sic) fascist goons," while never addressing the fact that California State University Long Beach 49er reporters Jamie Rowe and Lesley Nickus outline that after Sprague was spotted tearing up copies of the Long Beach Union, he fled the scene, courageously leaving a female companion, Jayme Hall, to fend for herself. When Sprague later sent out an email claiming that Holliday and Bates "yelled obscenities at Hall, and forced her to the ground and pinned her down with his elbow in her spine," that also turned out to be false.

"Sprague later said his email was written in reaction to information with multiple parties," Rowe and Nickus write. "He said he realizes that his statements were based on information that may not have been accurate."

So much for getting one's facts straight.

by Jim Tracy / California
Excuse me? An assumed name? Who is this Jean? That sounds like an assumed name to me. Just did a search on this issue & I found two 49er articles that state "Sprague was cleared of the charges." So Jean why don't you tell the whole truth instead of resorting to burning those at the stake whom you can't present a logical argument against?
by Abe
A search of the 49er website turns up no such phrase as "Sprague was cleared of the charges."

What one does find is the article below:

http://www.csulb.edu/colleges/cla/departments/history/about/Newsletter2005.html

Which states that "Jeb Sprague has been awarded a summer internship with a thinktank in Washington, D.C., where he will work on matters relating to Venezuela and Non-Governmental Organizations."

Sprague has as of yet refused to name the organization or reveal what if any funding he received from it. Hmmm....



by D. Simidor
Yes right here it says he was cleared
http://www.csulb.edu/~d49er/archives/2005/fall/news/volLVno148-senate.shtml

Is your search engine not working?
Gosh Darnit I was wrong all along. I wish to god I could find something to discredit him that way I wouldn't have to make a logical argument. My life is boring. Maybe I can troll around some more today.


by Lucy
RE: "Lucy Komisar's excellent article on the CorpWatch website. "Haiti Telecom Kickbacks Tarnish Aristide," http://www.corpwatch.org/print_article.php?id=12990."

Note: It was as an "editorial consultant" contracted by the Haiti Democracy Project, that Komisar worked on this article. HDP's connections to the U.S. State Department, intelligence agencies, and Haitian elites, are discussed in other threads...See her bio. HDP is in fine company as Komisar's other jobs as "editorial consultant" are with the Ford and Rockefeller Foundation's: http://www.channer.tv/past%20programs/monday.htm.%2002-20-06.htm.
by Kissinger and Friends
That's funny. Right below Komisar's "editorial consultant" bio you learn that she is a member (since 1994) of the Council on Foreign Relations. Gold star for an "excellent" smear article, Lucy! Bravo Haiti "Democracy" Project for a fine choice in propagandists! She's (FAR...) Right up your alley!
by Abe
"Haiti Telecom Kickbacks Tarnish Aristide" was written as a special to the website of CorpWatch, an organization that investigates and exposes corporate violations of human rights, environmental crimes, fraud and corruption around the world.

CorpWatch was founded in the Bay Area in 1996 as the Transnational Resource & Action Center and became CorpWatch in 2001. CorpWatch's Executive Director is the eminent investigative journalist Pratap Chatterjee, author of "Iraq Inc.: A Profitable Occupation."

Of course, critics of the article could always discuss its content (not least of which is the impressive gallery of politicians in the United States - both Democrat and Republican - that benefited from the Aristide government's corrupt practices), but then that would appear to be beyond their realm of discourse. Don't worry about the money that was stolen from the poorest people in the hemisphere, protect you hero at all costs.
by Saniel Dimidork
lucy_july_2003_north_fork.jpg
I think I failed, once again, to see the reference to the Haiti Democracy Project in Ms. LUCY KOMISAR's internet biography at http://www.channer.tv/past%20programs/monday.htm.%2002-20-06.htm Now I realize she was, as mentioned above, working as a consultant for the lobby agency in Washington DC of said Mr Bolous. Apologies for my ignorance.

"EDITORIAL CONSULTANT
Author of report for Tax Justice Network, “Citigroup: a history and culture of tax evasion,” Jan. 2006. http://www.taxjustice.net/cms/front_content.php?idcatart=8&lang=1&client=1 Author of report for Haiti Democracy Project, “Follow Aristide's Money Offshore: How Haiti was looted with the help of tax haven shell companies & secret bank accounts and U.S. Citizens & Corporations.” Nov. 10, 2005. http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/3319.htm Author of strategic briefing paper for Rockefeller Foundation on how to approach human rights situation in South Korea (1995). Editor of Ford Foundation reports, “The Ford Foundation's International Human Rights Program: A History and an Agenda” and an untitled report on U.S. public involvement in foreign policy issues. (undated)."
by Sam
The hypocrisy on both sides of this debate is incredible. One side ignores the HDP's connections to wealthy and reactionary forces in Haiti, and the other, repeatedly on this forum, posts statements and reports by the IJDH, many of whose directors became millionaires while working for the Aristide government while it was in power. Is there any side passing commentary on the Haiti situation not tainted by gutter political concerns and/or a suspect money trail?
by Claude
Smells like Diebert. All points are wrong only you are right, I get it now. Can I bluster up your power complex?

IJDH was doing great things in Haiti. Look at the dozens of political prisoners they have helped and the perpetrators of massacres they have persecuted in the court of law. Spend 10 minutes on the IJDH website and you can see the positive they have done. You on the other hand post anonymously (with fake name) on the internet attacking an organization without providing any information (much unlike the detailed analysis on the HDP posted wide and far). You don't provide a shred of evidentiary based discussion as per your charge that IJDH ripped millions. Tell me, how much guts does it take to make blanket denunciations across the internet, claiming all sides of an issue are wrong (you are so noble!), especially when the dominate mainstream corporate cida/usaid funded dialogue (or should I say CIA disinformation campaign) has the media and YOU (so it seems) by the balls.

Yeah, I'm sure you'd love to see IJDH out of business and the HDP reign supreme with your annual scant liberal criticism on the appetizer menu. Fuck that. You don't set the debate parameters. Fuck that. Go write some more about "saving Haiti" with your Latortue quotes.




A poem on the spot just for you
Over 10,000 dead and you still don't have a clue
Listen to the cries of the city of sun
Can you dare acknowledge the jailed and on the run?
On the Internet you'll sit and stew
Thinking of apologies for the Oh-Four coup



by Sam
So it is ok for some organizations in the U.S. to be bank-rolled by Haitian politicians but not others? Again, as I wrote before, what hypocrisy. Jeb Sprague and the others posting anonymously should be ashamed.
by Kevin
Daniel Simidor, the indybay 'troll', makes more baseless attacks without providing evidence or his real name. A classic CIA maneuver. I Suggest he be ignored as he is probably being paid in some form to post on this site.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$190.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network