top
Central Valley
Central Valley
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Environmental and Social Justice Advocates Condemn CALFED!

by Dan Bacher (danielbacher [at] hotmail.com)
Environmental and social justice advocates today condemned the bureaucratic CALFED for "deliberately excluding" the vast majority of California residents from participating in critical decisions affecting water in the state. The California Delta is now experiencing an unprecedented food chain collapse while the federal and state governments under CALFED are planning to divert more water from northern California for agribusiness on the west side of the San Joaquin Valley and water developers in Southern California.
PRESS RELEASE
December 8, 2005

Contact: Alisha Deen, (707) 342-2052

LaDonna Williams, (707) 712-4088

Gary Mulcahy, (916) 214-8493

Martha Guzman, (916) 524-2243

David Nesmith, (510) 693-4979


ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL JUSTICE ADVOCATES ACROSS THE STATE CONDEMN
CALFED'S DISREGARD FOR LOW-INCOME & COMMUNITIES OF COLOR

"10-Year Action Plan Framework" is another example of how CALFED
deliberately excludes majority of California's residents from
participating in critical decisions affecting water


Oakland, CA-Environmental and social justice leaders across the state
expressed outrage at the utter disregard for environmental justice
concerns in the CALFED "10-year Action Plan Framework."

"The participants who hammered out this framework behind closed doors are
not interested in environmental justice," said Alisha Deen, a legislative
analyst for the Environmental Justice Coalition for Water in Oakland. "The
environmental justice commitments in CALFED are absent in the 10-year
action plan. They don't even mention the phrase in the 11-page document.
Unfortunately that has been our experience with CALFED itself.
Environmental justice has been this buzz word without any real action."

CALFED has suffered devastating blows to its legitimacy with the state
legislature, the Little Hoover Commission and the Third District Court of
Appeals calling into question the basic pillars of the program in recent
months.

Last Friday, December 2nd, only a few minutes before offices closed for
the weekend, the Bay-Delta Authority released the 10-year Action Plan
Framework, announcing that a vote would take place less than a week later.


The activists plan on giving testimony at today's CALFED Authority meeting
in Sacramento.

"This is a slap in the face to communities throughout California," said
LaDonna Williams, Executive Director of People for Children's Health and
Environmental Justice. "The Bay-Delta Authority once again exhibits their
total disregard for environmental justice and true public participation in
the vital decisions concerning water in California."

"Even though the CALFED Record of Decision established a commitment to
environmental justice that was to cut across all programs, the
environmental justice element of CALFED is pretty much lip-service," said
Gary Mulcahy, the Governmental Liaison for the Winnemem Wintu Tribe.

"Originally we were encouraged by what seemed like a real commitment on
the part of CALFED to ensuring public participation," said Martha Guzman,
legislative advocate for the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation.
"However, over the past five years it has become crystal clear that CALFED
never had any intention of truly implementing its environmental justice
obligations."

Environmental and social justice advocates call on the Governor and the
Legislature to ensure that CALFED allow meaningful public participation,
particularly from communities of color and low-income communities who
clearly suffer disproportionate effects from industry-driven water
projects and policies. CALFED has failed to improve the environmental and
environmental justice problems facing the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta,
the areas of origin and the regions now-dependent on water shipments
through the Delta precisely because the Bay-Delta Authority has lacked the
strength and commitment to ensure open decision making processes and
balanced projects that fully consider environmental justice impacts.

"Now is a moment of rare agreement that the system is broken," said David
Nesmith, coordinator with the Environmental Water Caucus.   "The Governor
and the Legislature must ensure that CALFED does not repeat the same
mistakes of exclusion and discrimination that have characterized it for so
long."

###


The Environmental Justice Coalition for Water is a network of more than
sixty grassroots and intermediary organizations building a collective,
community-based movement for democratic water management and allocation in
California. EJCW works to empower community members to become strong
voices for water justice in their communities by participating in water
policy, planning and decisions. We hold policy makers accountable for the
disproportionate impacts water policy has on low-income communities and
communities of color.

The Environmental Water Caucus works to achieve comprehensive, sustainable
water management solutions for all Californians. EWC and its members
employ political, legal and economic strategies to restore ecological
health, improve water quality and protect public trust values throughout
the San Francisco Bay-Sacramento/San Joaquin Delta estuary and the Central
Valley/Sierra Nevada watersheds.


Environmental Water Caucus
319 Lenox Avenue
Oakland, CA 94610
510-893-1330  OR  510-693-4979


Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
654 13th Street
Oakland, CA  94612
(510) 286-8400
http://www.ejcw.org
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by PG&E corporate giveaway
In CA there are also communities struggling against PG&E, one of those communities is Hunter's Point/Bayview in SF, a mostly African-american neighborhood on the less windy eastern side of the SF peninsula that is daily exposed to airborne toxins by PG&E's Bayview power plant. The smog from PG&E's natuiral gas combustion settles in the still air of the eastern slope of the penninsula and nearby Bayview/HP residents frequently experience asthma, breathing difficulties and exhibit high rates of lung cancer. The effluent from PG&E releases a toxic chemical brew directly into the water and the fish are considered too toxic to eat. This environmental racism occurs despite constant community protest and demands to shut down this outdated and polluting plant..

"The PG&E Hunters Power Plant is the largest stationary source of air pollution in Bayview Hunters Point, putting out almost 600 tons of pollutants annually into the air over Southeast San Francisco. According to the USEPA, these emissions include: 321 tons of nitrogen oxides; 164 tons of carbon monoxide; 52 tons of particulate matter; 13 tons of ammonia; 13 tons of volatile organic compounds; and 12 tons of sulfur dioxide.

“We’re sick of being sick,” said Tessie Ester, President of Huntersview Tenants Association. “If these people breathed the air we do, this plant would have been closed years ago.”
"

http://www.greenaction.org/hunterspoint/pr032305.shtml

The operation of PG&E's Bayview plant does not provide the nearby residents with any power themselves. Most of the electricity produced from the Bayview plant is exported to unknown energy consumers. After a temporary shutdown of the Bayview plant, no net energy loss was recorded on the SF grid. So where is Bayview's energy going??

In Sacramento a local utility provider SMUD (Sacramento Municipal Utility District) is being sued by PG&E for not filing an EIR. PG&E claims that the proposal of SMUD annexation of three nearby communities (Woodland, DAvis, West Sacramento) in neighboring Yolo county will require additional utility lines not provided by PG&E. However, SMUD is encouraging solar cells, windmills (including bird friendly vertical windmills) and other forms of renewable energy as an alternative to the outdated nuclear, hydroelectric, and natural gas facilites operated by PG&E at great taxpayer expense. What it comes down to is PG&E is threatened by SMUD's ability to implement renewable electricity instead of depending on outdated nuclear/petroleum facilites..

"PG&E filed a lawsuit Thursday, complaining that SMUD has not studied key environmental issues, including plans to build a substation and 15-to 18-mile, high-voltage line between Elverta and Woodland.

The suit seeks a court order halting annexation and requiring a detailed study - a time-consuming step that would keep SMUD's plan off the Yolo County ballot next year. ...

... SMUD General Counsel Arlen Orchard said the annexation review process complies with state environmental requirements. If and when voters approve the plan, he said, more detailed studies and mitigation plans will be done for specific projects - including the Elverta-Woodland transmission line being considered for a wide corridor that includes wildlife habitat and land near Sacramento International Airport at a cost of $10 million to $12 million."

http://smud.typepad.com/smud_annexation_updates/2005/11/pge_files_lawsu.html

Under capitalism SMUD has the same potential to become the force of destruction that PG&E currently is due to unregulated consumption primarily by corporations (greatest consumers of electricity, NOT the little old lady heating up some soup on her stove). This is another factor that PG&E omits from their advertisements, most of their energy is in the form of free giveaways to other corporations, enter the ENRON "energy crisis" in CA where consumers were duped by Ken Lay and his golf buddie Arnold the Nazi Actor, who usurped the state capitol from an unaware, blindfolded and gagged Gray Davis in total recall election. Now the Hollywood actor Arnold smiles and reads the scripts provided by the corporations and wealthy financeers. Currently Arnold is the sole individual "deciding" the fate of former gangmember Stanley "Tookie" Williams, a death row inmate and now anti-gang writer who prevents youth from joining gangs via outreach..

http://savetookie.org/

Another factor to consider is that a great deal of energy consumption by corporations and government is wasteful and unneccesary. We don't need 24 hour lighting at McDonalds or(substitute other sprawl corporations here), and the streetlights of suburbia's sprawl are a form of light pollution. The only spotlight we need is the one that educates people on the wastefulness and ecological destruction caused by multinational corporations like McDonalds..

"McDonald's spends over $2 billion a year broadcasting their glossy image to the world. This is a small space for alternatives to be heard."

http://www.mcspotlight.org/

Exposure to ambient nighttime lighting isn't good for humans either, lack of nighttime darkness (24/7 light exposure = sleep deprivation torture in prison) can increase sleep disorders, irritation/agitation and other physical/mental reactions. This lighting all requires an input of energy that is coming at great cost to the environment and human ecosystem health from exposure to various pollution and ecosystem distrubances..

Here's a group in Tuscon working to reduce light pollution so we can all see the stars once again (and save energy tambien);

International Dark-Sky Association

"To preserve and protect the nighttime environment and our heritage of dark skies through quality outdoor lighting."

http://www.darksky.org/

In Lassen Volcanic foothills, PG&E is leasing land out to Sierra Pacific Industries for clearcut logging operations, as if SPI didn't rob enough timber from the public trust..

SPI facts from endgame;

"Facts
Largest private landowner in North America, with 1.3 million acres.
Owns 28 percent of the 4.57 million acres of timber industry land in California.
Largest purchaser of public timber in California.
Ranked 192 on the Forbes 500 list of private corporations in the U.S.
SPI chairman Red Emmerson is ranked 161 on the Forbes 400 list of richest Americans (based on an estimated worth of $1.1 billion).
Funded timber industry campaign against Forests Forever initiative in California.
Helped create the Sierra Accord and Quincy Library Groups."

http://www.endgame.org/spi.html

PG&E says they will not remove any of the outdated dams on the Feather River despite evidence that salmon migrations are negatively effected by the presence of outdated and sometimes dangerous dams. One example is the earthen OROville Dam just a few miles upriver from downtown Oroville. There was recent seismic activity (74) in Oroville and there are several tensoin faults nearby..

"The Foothills Fault System – which includes faults with names like Cleveland Hill, Spenceville, Deadman, Maidu, Prairie Creek and Swain Ravine – passes just east of Folsom Lake and runs through locales such as Auburn, Placerville, El Dorado Hills and Shingle Springs. The system runs from Mariposa to the Chico area. The 1975 magnitude 6.1 Oroville earthquake was caused by movement along the Cleveland Hills fault."

http://www.consrv.ca.gov/index/news/2003%20News%20Releases/NR2003-08_Sacramento_Earthquake_Potential.htm

The reason the Oroville dam remains standing is the dependency of Central Valley agribusiness on large amounts of water for irrigation and export style plantation corporate farming. Small time conventional (nearly extinct) and organic farmers usually can manage to irrigate with less water and use ground/well water, though depletion of the groundwater table is an issue from inefficient irrigation methods..

Other options are available, though it will take community organization initiatives to pressure these changes to sustainability to take place. Community organic gardens like in Cuba's huertos intensivos can deliver needed nutritionally diverse food available with less demand on resources. Solar, wind and other renewable forms of energy can provide humans (not corporations) with needed electricity without destruction of the ecosystem..

"Organic Agriculture Can Feed the World
GM WATCH daily
Nov. 4, 2005
http://www.gmwatch.org
---
EXCERPTS: If GMOs cannot feed the children in the country that is the world's third largest producer of GMO crops, how will they feed the rest of the world?

It costs tens of millions of dollars and takes many years to develop one genetically modified plant variety.

Organic agriculture is the quickest, most efficient, cost effective and fairest way to feed the world.

Organic Agriculture Can Feed the World

Leu, Andre F.

Chairman, Organic Federation of Australia

Abstract

Proponents of industrial agriculture state that synthetic biocides, soluble fertilisers and genetic engineering are necessary to feed the worlds growing population. Several authorities further state organic agriculture is not capable of this task.

This paper looks at numerous and diverse data sets from around the world, showing that given the right conditions, organic agriculture can deliver sustainable high yields. Organic agriculture programs initiated by several organisations have substantially increased yields for many third world communities. This has been done with very low input and infrastructure costs to these communities and has substantially increased their standard of living. Data from the advanced agricultural economies of North America, Australia and Europe show that best practice organics can deliver equal and to significantly better yields than current conventional agricultural practices."

http://www.organicconsumers.org/organic/110705.cfm

Though some claim that conversion to organic agriculture will result in lower yield, this ignores the fact that global famine and malnutrition is primarily caused by problems with food distribution, not availablity. Plantation monoculture cash crop export ties up land and people who cannot grow traditional subsistence food crops. Waste of food in western nations also indicates a food surplus but inadequate distribution, primarily caused by economic inequality..

Back to electricity options;

Vertical axis windmills can harness to nearly constant valley/estuary wind from any direction without needing to be turned like horizontal axis windmills. Their longer vertical blades also make them bird friendly..

"Wind Power to the People!

by Christopher Paddon

Hipfish

August 2005

But what about birds? New designs have reduced the hazards to birds to zero percent. The old-style, (propeller type) horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWT's) of the 1980s did cause bird deaths: two hundredths of one percent (1/5500) as many as buildings and windows and one tenth of one percent (1/1000) as many as cats, fourteen hundredths of one percent (1/700) as many as cars. (Erickson et al, 2002, Summary of Anthropogenic Causes of Bird Mortality) However, new designs now minimize, and even prevent birds colliding with the rotors. The newer, more efficient propeller-style turbines rotate much more slowly--and visibly--without reducing the amount of power they produce. Vertical axis wind turbines (VAWT's), such as those now being produced by TMA, Inc. of Wyoming, stand upright and spin much like the old-fashioned barbershop poles. There are even designs that rotate parallel to the ground in an open-and-close "Pac Man" fashion. One such turbine design, by Encore Clean Energy of Vancouver, BC, sits in a river with a set of collapsing rotors both above and below the water. The rotors above the water harness the wind, while those below simultaneously harness the water current. By rotating in opposite directions, the dual rotors double the amount of power generated."

http://www.postcarbon.org/lifeboat/page31.html
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$210.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network