top
North Coast
North Coast
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Felony Charge Against Treesitter Reduced

by Remedy
Treesit Extractors should be investigated for "sadistic torture," attorney says.
Eureka, CA - Felony charges will not be pressed against treesitter Ramsey Noah Gifford, who has faced bogus charges of assault with a deadly weapon for nearly two years following an April 2003 tree-top altercation with Maxxam/Pacific Lumber climbers hired to eject protestors in order to clear-cut old-growth redwood forest.

PL treesit extractor Eric Schatz of Schatz Tree Service, who is the alleged victim of the assault, gave three days of testimony, mostly in answer to heavy questioning by defense attorney Michael Acosta. Attorneys for Gifford played footage of the incident taken with the extractor’s helmet cameras, and asked Schatz to stop the tape at the time Gifford allegedly tried to unhook Schatz from his safety gear. Schatz was unable to pinpoint an assault.

In closing statements, prosecutor Tim Stoen moved to strike the strike aspect of the felony charge, which would have been charged as strike one under California’s barbaric “three strikes law.” The DA’s office was apparently unaware that a felony strike charge has been pending against Gifford for nearly two years. However, Stoen described Giffords actions as “felony conduct through and through,” opposing the defense’s motion to reduce the charge to a misdemeanor.

Attorney Omar Figueroa made closing statements on behalf of Gifford, and contended that his client was the actual victim of an assault by extractor Michael Oxman, who can be seen in the footage standing on Gifford, putting his foot on Giffords chest and neck, and using a forearm to the throat. Schatz described “Ox” as weighing 230 pounds at the time of the incident. Figueroa asked that the DA’s office “investigate the sadistic torture committed by Mr. Oxman."

Judge John Feeney stated that the purpose of the preliminary trial was to establish probably cause. The actions by Gifford did not rise to the level of a felony assault, he said.

The trial date will be set at a hearing on May 26, 2005 in Eureka.

###
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by concerned citizen
After watching you in the court room last week I have to ask if you are for real? You must have passed your bar exam in some gay bar in S.F. I have never watched an attorney make such a fool of himself in the court room. I hope you don't plead your client out before the next court date. The people of Humboldt need a good laugh watching you defend your client with the evidence he has against him. Why don't you go crawl back under a rock and save the embarrassment to your fellow lawyers.
by sinnsaoirse (distortedcollective [at] hotmail.com)
yeah, if the best response to a cogent report is a petty Ad Hominem attack (one where you resort to petty personal attacks and AVOID THE ISSUE) like that, then well, that's pretty pathetic...
by michael acosta
Yeah I'm for real, and come trial it'll be PL and supporters like YOU bending over like the bitches ya'll are. I'm going to mop the floor at trial with what's left of Eric Schatz's credibility on this issue, although I don't have anything personal against Eric myself and have great respect for his technical climbing skills. Mr. Schatz and I had kind words just before the ruling by Judge Feeney, and Eric himself congratulated me after the hearing. You Joe Sixpacks can't stand it when treesitters kick your asses in court. As for courtroom strategy and presentation, I'll remind you that our motion to reduce the charge was granted, and the theory of assault against Michael Oxman was totally destroyed. so have one of your inbred, backwoods spawn children get a bar card and then we'll talk. word to the motherf*cker...
by A VERY CONCERNED CITIZEN
MR ACOSTA IS FOR REAL!! HE WENT TO STANFORD UNIVERSITY UNDER GRADUATE SCHOOL THAN ONTO STANFORD LAW SCHOOL. TO MY KNOWLEDGE NO FOOLS HAVE GRADUATED FROM STANFORD. HOWEVER IT IS SAFE TO SAY YOU HAVE GRADUATED FROM THE SCHOOL OF HOMOPHOBICS IN PL COUNTRY AND NEED TO STOP ROMANCING THE SHEEP ON THE HILLSIDES.
by another concerned citizen
And afterwards we can all go over to mr. stoen's for some koolaid to celebrate.
by a concerned local
I have to ask, haven't you lost site of the subject? the FOREST....let's lay off the testostorine for a while and stick to the real issue...and please remember, you are representing the FOREST everytime you go to court or are involved with a treesit or an arguement or a character assault....I live here, always have, always will, and I want my children to see the beauty and spirit of the sacred place and everytime you show imaturity instead of tolerance, you make it that much harder to reach the people who have the power to stop Maxxam.... so please work toward a solution, not more conflict.....EVERYONE!
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$210.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network