top
US
US
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Minuteman Project Misconceptions - Confessions of two Indymedia Reporters

by Walt & Jessica (walt [at] 218style.com)
For the last two weekends, Jessica and Walt have spent time on the Arizona-Mexico border, interacting with both the Minuteman Project volunteers and the ACLU Legal Observers. What they saw revealed problems with the activist movements.
starint-into-the-desert.jpg
Jessica

In the weeks leading up to the Minuteman Project (MMP), all I knew was that "armed vigilantes" would be coming to Arizona to take the law into their own hands and stop the flow of "illegal aliens" across the U.S.-Mexico border. Most of what I knew came from activists or the media.

On April 1, the start of the project, I was terrified. Nearly 60 protestors showed up in Tombstone, Arizona to demonstrate against the "armed, racist" people to show the Minuteman volunteers and the media that Arizonans were not going to tolerate this type of behavior and that there were opposing voices.

What I did not realize until now, is that before laying an eye on a Minuteman volunteer, my view of them was already biased and tainted. True, real vigilante activity has been documented across the border region before, but it was the activist groups and the media that immediately tied the MMP to this behavior, labeling what they would do before things happened.

The opening weekend of the MMP was an absolute media circus. Hundreds of media representatives, from all over the world, swarmed southern Arizona. Often times, there was more reporters than actual Minuteman volunteers and/or protestors. The media was interested because of the "sexy" appeal of "red-necks with guns coming down to take the law into their own hands" and wanted to be there to document the moment someone was shot or illegally detained. After the buzz of the weekend, most of the media left, leaving just a few reporters and documentary projects around.

First, the majority of the Minuteman volunteers are not "scary vigilantes." While many of them are armed, it is likely it is because they are NRA enthusiasts, not people who have come to Arizona to shoot people. Most of the volunteers are in their 40-50s and are white males. Their duties are to sit in chairs or in their trucks and watch the border for 8 hour shifts. If they actually see an undocumented migrant, they radio in to the MMP command center and call U.S. Border Patrol. Some have gone out on foot and helped Border Patrol agents look for migrants hidden in washes. Except for one or two individuals, I have not felt threatened or scared by any of the volunteers. (I am a 24 year old female.)

After getting "the story" the first weekend, meaning the story that most media tried to tell, I returned to the border last weekend with a different angle. After talking with border activist groups, both Chris Simcox and Jim Gilchrist, MMP organizers, and several of the volunteers, I picked up on an interesting detail. There are many similarities in beliefs between the border activist and humanitarian groups and the Minuteman volunteers when it came to the "border problem." For example, both groups of people would likely agree that: our border policy is messed up, the Bush administration is not trying to fix the problem, the guest worker program needs to be improved, U.S. businesses need to pay higher wages and offer benefits to immigrant labor, that U.S. foreign economic policy is largely to blame, free trade policies hurt both Mexicans and Americans and that the borders are not secure when it comes to drug traffic and possible terrorist threats.

As a reporter, I found these similarities striking. But, why then were some people joining border activist groups to offer humanitarian aide to immigrants and working on policy, why others were deciding to come to the Arizona-Mexico border for a week or a month to help shut it down?

With that pivotal question, I spent last week interviewing Minuteman volunteers trying to get at why they decided to devote time and personal resources to this project as a solution to the border problem.

Without my notebook and camera, I approached Minuteman volunteers just to talk. I had my press pass on, but came across as a non-threatening journalist, someone who was more interested in talking than just getting a quote. With each volunteer or team of volunteers, I would ask them how they felt the media was covering their project, what their general sources of media are, and why they thought defending the border was the solution, rather than tackling NAFTA or other economic policies.

Some of my conclusions are that many of the volunteers get their news off of corporate broadcast news channels, predominately FOX news. They also rely on their local newspapers. Many of them were unfamiliar with the consequences of NAFTA, and how that correlates to "the flood of illegal aliens streaming across the border." This I believe is related to the inability of the mainstream news services, in particular broadcast news, to holistically and adequately cover issues. While the media is good at producing "fear stories" about crime, violence, terrorists, etc., they are not very good at focusing on an issue in the long term and trying to truly find the truth and report it to their viewers.

My opinion is that the MMP is a consequence of the state of the media in three respects. First, it is Americans becoming scared by what they learn from the mainstream media, and finally taking action they believe will solve the problem. Secondly, most of the Minuteman volunteers have bad information, thus are reacting to a situation that is based on incomplete facts and details. Thirdly, due to the lack of international-focused stories and the patriotic focus of the media since 9/11, many feel that the MMP is about defending the United States and our freedoms.

As part of the conversations with the Minuteman volunteers, I would tell them about indymedia and the independent media movement, and what is wrong with the mainstream media. All of the people I spoke with were very receptive to this, and many had heard of alternative media. I had fliers prepared that described some facts about media conglomeration, indymedia, alternative media and literature and how to publish on indymedia. I gave these out and I believe they were welcomed. One Minuteman volunteer told me that I was the first person that made things click for him about the border situation and that we was going to look into Democracy Now! and watch the movie "Outfoxed."

Because I think the mainstream media is largely to blame for the misconceptions that have led hundreds of people to join the Minuteman Project, I think media activism is the only way to approach the volunteers to tell them that further militarization of the border is not the solution to this global crisis. No border activist groups have been proactive in approaching the Minuteman volunteers to educate them, nor have the leaders of the MMP decided to hold "teach-ins" to further enlighten people within their own movement.

I urge anyone going to the border in the next couple weeks to approach the Minuteman Project volunteers with an open mind and heart, and rather than immediately brand them as "crazy vigilantes," rather spread the word about alternative media. Please contact me if you are interested in this endeavor.

Walt

I only spent a day on the border as a legal observer, watching a handful of people who had their eyes trained on Mexico. That was nearly a week ago, and after thinking and talking about it, I think the Minuteman Project (MMP) has made me much more critical of ourselves than these so-called vigilantes.

I expected to arrive at the border and see a line of pissed-off, racist vigilantes waiting for a group of Mexicans to make a desperate dash through a hole in the fence right into the barrel of a gun.

Instead, I found myself growing upset with the activists opposing the MMP and their rhetoric that shaped my views of them.

Right now, the border is like a huge classroom with pupils all sitting at their desks, pencils sharpened and waiting for their teacher to show up. But the teacher never does.

The project’s organizers, Jim Gilchrist and Chris Simcox, do not seem interested in hosting teach-ins on economics and U.S. history. Border groups like Border Action Network, BorderLinks and the others, as far as I know, haven’t planned to hold any movie screenings or discussions on migrant labor for the Minute(wo)men. The only thing I’ve read about are continued protests and opposition to them.

So, then, what do we need to do? Listening, learning and teaching.

Honestly, the biggest problem the MMP’s volunteers are facing is boredom. There’s nary a migrant for miles from where they are situated – the Mexican government and aid agencies have done their best to let people know not to cross west of Douglas until April is over. After spending the better part of seven hours watching the minute(wo)mens’ every movement, it’s obvious they are bored out of their gourd. Some stay put, others slowly drive from outpost to outpost, like an old fashioned game of telephone, passing along news and rumors.

Basically, they’re all sitting out there wondering why in the hell they’re sitting out there. They, also, have been lied to.

We need come up with something to reach these people (and perhaps ourselves?)

A couple days ago, I read on Indymedia.us that a group of human rights activists from California was coming to protest in Douglas. But now, I can’t say I’m looking forward to that, unless they’ve got something really constructive planned. If not, here are some ideas:

Listen to these minute(wo)men. They have interesting stories and experiences. They are confused and afraid. They don’t know why Bush won’t seal the border. They don’t want drug dealers in their towns. They don’t want their hospitals going down the tubes. Are these not valid concerns, especially knowing what the media spews at them on a daily basis. So go and listen to them, don’t interrupt. Hear what they have to say.

Yes, many of these people are racist, some subtly, some overtly, although it seems to come more from nationalism and fear than hate for a certain skin color. But listen to that too.

Then, after offering a sympathetic ear, try a conversation. Many of them would support a legalized guest worker program. Maybe we could explain how that would grant migrants higher wages, which is something that corporations (aka U.S. government) don’t want. We could talk about NAFTA, now it has tightened the noose on the Mexican government and caused many people to lose their land, driving them to attempt the perilous journey into the States for work. Although it may seem like migrants are a drain on many of our systems, they are hard working and many have taxes and Social Security taken out of their wages.

And, many return home to Mexico or Central America. But since the border has been more heavily militarized, it’s harder to return, so more and more are staying and keeping their families here. This list can go on and on...

After this, maybe we could have a sheet with some resources: books, movies and web sites. My latest favorite is Confessions of an Economic Hit Man by John Perkins.

What we really need to do is set up an infoshop on the border and let the MMP volunteers check out books, fliers and zines for the day. We should find a venue to screen Out Foxed and The Corporation each night for the rest of April. We should be leading discussions with them, finding out what kinds of solutions would really benefit everyone involved. Maybe some of them would then go home and start harassing their congressmen and senators for immigrant rights.

If we don’t do this kind of work, then I don’t know what activism is, or at the very least, I don’t want to be a part of it anymore. They call us lazy, jobless communists. We call them consumer-driven, racist right-wingers.

I say we all have a lot to learn from each other.

Now, I don’t defend the MMP to the slightest, but I think we’ve got a great opportunity to reach out to a group of people we rarely have the opportunity to talk to. There are hundreds of them, all day long, just sitting in lawn chairs staring through binoculars into an endless sea of desert chaparral. They want to chat, to learn, to teach, to understand.

So pack your bags with some literature, but also bring a healthy dose of patience and empathy. Leave the signs, slogans and bullhorns at home. See you at the border at high noon!

§Minuteman Observing Post
by Walt & Jessica (walt [at] 218style.com)
element_post.jpg
Behind this Honda Element, a MMP volunteer kicks it in a lawn chair from 10:00 am until 6:00 pm.
§Walt in a Chair
by Walt & Jessica (walt [at] 218style.com)
observing_the_border.jpg
This was most of my day, not much different than the Minuteman volunteers's. Sitting in a chair as nothing really happened.
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by c
It's a not so hidden secret that it is actually the republican legislators representing central valley districts that favor lax enforcement of immigration because their economy depends on sub-minimum wage workers. Just like wages of computer programmers fell in Silicon Valley when large numbers of immigrants were allowed to compete with H1B visas, the service industry and working class does have to disproportionately bear downward competition in wages due to a larger pool of laborers. With his guest laborer program, Bush really only wants to allow wealthy people to take advantage of rock bottom labor prices.
It is irrational to care more about people on your side of the border than the welfare of people on the other side, because you only personally know a much smaller group of people. What you should care about is the ability of labor movements to make real gains on both sides of the border.
In the past year, even though the economy has been going out of a recession, inflation adjusted wages actually dropped, which hasn't happened in a long time. This is because tweaks to the system under Bush such as the tax codes don't have the estate tax and various capital gains taxes, or enforcement, plus infrastructure which allows extreme real estate and stock speculation, have allowed money to funnel upwards.
'free trade' has been around for centuries, and when they instituted NAFTA, everyone was promising that this would make Mexico have a much highger standard of living, which hasn't happened, which is clear by the observation of all these people who have to cross through the desert to take substandard jobs.
by deanosor (deanosor [at] comcast.net)
I thank the indymedia reporters for trying to show the similarities between some of the "Minutemen" and some of the counter-protestor. And giving people who seem to be duped counter information is a good thing.

But one thing that bothered me about the whole 'similarities" scenario they paint, is that some of the similarities between the groups seem to be where both groups are buying into right-wing scenarios. More specifically, both groups are buying into an idea that drug-trafficking, and "terrorism" are resons for border security. Even if you believe that drugs are bad, no drug-trafficker hurts anybody who doesn't voluntarily wants to be hurt except maybe in the fight against officers trying to enforce these silly yet draconian laws on what people can put into their own body. And compared to the expense both in dollar amounts and in immigrant lives lost onthe border, very few "terrrorists" enter from the highly policed Mexican border.

The real answer to the broder question is to have no border between dfiferent parts of what once was Mexico and to let people travel whereever they damn well want to. And to send any actual white racist trying to stop this home in a pine box. And for the lower classes that feel threatened by people taking away their jobs, abolish capitalism and the jobs it needs. Then people will get together to figure out ways to solve their own problems including helping each other to survive and flourish.
by mamacat
I really appreciate this alternative viewpoint about this whole scenario.

I feel like part of what you're trying to put out there is that we (we being white activists/organizers, presumably?) need to work to educate the minute men people, to counter the misinformation they are exposed to, and so forth. I think you make really good points about how they are forming their opinions and where they get their information, and that we really ought to consider how to counter that stuff.

But I'm uneasy with the just below the surface condemnation of the folks who are opposing the minute men people, and the lack of a broader analysis.

The idea of countering the misinformation, etc, is good, and it also focuses on the Minutemen people as the most important people to think about and deal with in this whole border showdown scenario.

I think the folks who are out there opposing the minutemen are considering the targets of those activities (specifically, undocumented immigrants, and broadly, brown folks) as the most important people to think about in this scenario; the people who are crossing the border for a vast variety of reasons.

The broader analysis, which I don’t claim to fully grasp (tho I’m workin on it) has to include some thought about what the broad impacts of the minuteman project on national (and beyond) policy and opinion is. I think it’s likely that some or many of the mmp volunteers have a simplistic view, formed by reactionary media and misinformation, however, to ascribe that level of naivete and simpleness to Gilchrist and the other people behind this project is in itself naive and I’d say, dangerous.

The image of the brave (white) american doing their unsophisticated, simple and earnest best to defend our country and our land from the (brown) hordes trying to get in and take it from us is powerful and appeals to the worst in amerian nature, to the clear benefit of the right wing. Maybe the folks out on the border with mmp right now are not overtly, consciously racist, but the overall impact of their project is likely to include a heightening of anti-immigrant feelings and actions, and those are pretty much always directed at immigrants of color. (I know undocumented European immigrants and they are never attacked as “illegal aliens”.) I do not believe that the organizers of the MMP are simply trying to protect the border for the month of April. Count on it that this project is just a strategic piece in a larger campaign.

So, yes, we activists and organizers do need to think about how it is that white folks are being recruited to take action for the right wing, and we need to figure out how to counter that; but not at the expense of looking at the big picture, knowing the right wing are far more effective at enacting strategy than we are right now, and certainly not at the expense of standing in solidarity with the targets of their attacks..
by @
...what both reporters are saying is that they talked to the MMP volunteers and found them to be primarily Republicans who are poorly informed: how redundant.
by thinking deeper
Yes, they are un-informed republicans, which is what we expected. The redundant part is how activists are handling it - by protesting and not talking to them. This is what needs to be addressed and changed...
by immigrant from the border
i think you need to do more research on the issue, before you start assuming that we are similar to vigilantes, spending a couple of days in arizona is not enought, there are groups who have a deeper analisys (anti-imperialist, resisting white supremacy) to the border issue than aclu legal observers or churches who do humanitarian work.
by Hourman
The Minutemen have no lives or Jobs if they can waste all day in

a lawn chair "watching the border".

If they want to watch the border so much they should apply for

jobs in Immigration!

I have no problem with people watching the border but in my

opinion it is a big waste of time if your not being paid to be

there,
by Civil Rights Activist
Thank God! Jessica and Walt's reports are a breath of fresh air. Yes, they aren't perfect...but I think they tried to be fair...and not slander the Minutemen...who are just average Americans (although I understand many are retired police officers/vetrans).

The Constitution is squarely on the side of the Minutemen. The interesting thing is that you so called "activists" are alligned with Bush, Corporate America, greedy lobbyists, and Congressional powerbrokers, against these true patriots, who have been vilified for exercising their constitutional rights.


by Plato
This last post demonstrates how ignorant some people are. If we would institute his or her ideas, everyone would starve...what a great solution!
by MM Supporter
The theory that people joined the MM project due to "mainstream" media is incorrect. Mainstream media did everying in its power to isolate the MM project.

It's obvious that some of you folks havn't done your homework.

These people volunteered because there are REAL problems, affecting a great number of REAL Americans.

I've studied this issues for 2+ years...this is a contest between Americans (Minutemen) and the tag team of Vicente Fox/Corporate America/Bush/Congress/Hispanic power-brokers.

Also--this has nothing to do with RACE. In fact, many Hispanics support the Minutemen (some of the MM are Hispanic).

If you want to find RACISM, take a look at Voz de Aztlan and M.E.Ch. A.
by Fellow American
Please excuse this if it's a duplicate.

It was very refreshing to read that the two journalists were able to put their preconceptions aside and write from the heart. The press often goes into events, especially those as divisive as the MMP, with inflexible agendas. It is really wonderful to read that Indymedia has broken through a bit on this topic and was able to look at the bigger picture.

While the writers do have a pretty good idea of what the MMP is like, there are plenty of people who are quick to write their opinions down without much thought. One thing I really don't like are the generalizations made about the personnel volunteering. However, generalizations are damaging for all sides. Just ask Jessica how she felt walking around Cochise County proudly wearing her Indymedia T-shirt (If you see this, don't forget your promise).
Sure, there were middle aged males in lawn chairs, blabbering ignorance day and night. There were also very intelligent, thoughtful, and professional volunteers who gave up a lot of time to make what little difference they could. I will be the first to admit that border stability is just a piece of the puzzle when it comes to physical, environmental, and economic security for all Americans. This doesn't have to be made into a partisan battle, we all want the same thing. Lets embrace people exercising their consitutional rights to stand up for what they believe in. The public discourse is important, so keep writing, judgements are easier to make than retract.

Oh, and The Corporation was much better than Outfoxed.
by um
" Lets embrace people exercising their consitutional rights to stand up for what they believe in"

You may have a "constitutional right" to not have "illegal" immigrants comming into the US but one has to question why a bunch of white people dont want illegal Mexicans comming into the US. If it were really about immigration in general you would see a more diverse group down there but you dont so one has to guess that the prime motivation is a racist desire to not want more nonwhites comming into the US.

Who are immigrants from Europe who engaged in one of the largest genocides in world history, stealing land and violation their own signed treaties to complain about immigrantion when many of those "illegally" comming into the US have ancestors who lived in N America before the Native American genocide took place.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$330.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network