top
North Coast
North Coast
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

SPI Plans Intensive Old-Growth Logging

by TBear & Rx
Sierra Pacific Industries plans a patch work of clear-cuts in highly sensitive area. Public comments needed.
daviscrk_harvestunits.jpg
Public comments are needed on an extreme logging plan proposed by Sierra Pacific Industries (SPI). For two years, SPI has been pushing for a 540-acre logging plan that would clear-cut on steep slopes that “frequently exceed 100%,” according to a regional manager at the Department of Fish and Game. The plan, which is laid out over the Davis Creek and Bear River watersheds, proposes to cut 29 units to create a patch work of clear-cuts in old-growth forest that is home to threatened and endangered species, including Northern Spotted Owl, Golden Eagle, Mountain Beaver, Sonoma Tree Vole, Chinook and Coho salmon.

SPI chairman Red Emmerson is the largest private landowner in North America. He owns 1.5 million of the 4.57 million acres of timber industry land in California. Mr. Emmerson is ranked #192 on the Forbes 500 list of private corporations in the U.S and is ranked #165 on the Forbes 400 list of richest Americans (based on an estimated worth of $1.5 billion) and ranked #378 on the 2003 list of world richest people, up from #421 in 2002.

In the 1970’s, the forest was magnificent with many trees exceeding 10’ in diameter. The current harvest plan area was then owned by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) until a land swap with SPI in 1983. This land swap was a part of a package deal to consolidate land holdings in the BLM King Range. This land had remained mostly un-entered virgin forest until a series of Timber Harvest Plans were filed by SPI starting in 1990. Since that time 14 harvest plans have been cut in the planning watershed which removed all but 4% of the original forests in the area. The sensitive area and the rapid rate of harvest in this watershed have left a series of impacts that have worsened over time and are not addressed in this harvest plan.

Davis Creek has been greatly impaired by the logging of large trees in zones near waterways. Landslides from recent harvesting caused a higher than natural rate of aggradation in this small coastal salmon bearing stream. Every inch of salmon habitat is precious to the people of the state of California.

As tree farms proliferate and wood–products substitutes come on the market, cutting of old growth is an antiquated practice. The value of old growth cannot be measured in current market price by board feet only. The value of Old Growth must also be measured in conservation values such as acres of habitat provided for isolated populations of endangered wildlife, and stability for sensitive and unstable hill slopes. The higher value of these trees is in their conservation values. It is economically feasible for SPI to exclude ancient trees and inner gorge areas from this logging plan.

The end of public comment period is on or around March 3, 2005, depending on timing of a written response from SPI’s Registered Professional Forester (RPF) that addresses the concerns and issues aired by the Dept. of Fish and Game and citizens during a January 26th review hearing held at the Fortuna office of the state Department of Forestry.

Send Public comments to:

California Department of Forestry
Attn: Forest Practice
135 Ridgeway Avenue
Santa Rosa, CA95401
santarosapubliccomment [at] fire.ca.gov

For more pictures of the threatened area, go here: http://gallery.wildcalifornia.org/THP-1-03-232-Sierra-Pacific-Industries
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by 2 SPI + new mechanized scotia mill?
If Palco is claiming bankruptcy this follows Maxxam's pattern. The same happened after Maxxam's hostile takeover of Kaiser steel..

The new mechanized mill in Scotia cost millions and was responsible for laying off hundreds of mill workers. Why would Maxxam build a mill and then declare bankruptcy after only a year?

Is it possible that after Maxxam is finished with Palco they'll sell their holdings (including the new mill 4 plantation forestry) to the highest bidder?

SPI's base in Anderson puts them in a centralized location for logging both the Sierras in the east and the Coast Range to the west. Maxxam/PL land claims in the Mattole borders SPI already. Is anyone aware of a possible deal between Maxxam and SPI?
by Wall Street broker
What a great idea. Having PALCO and SPI becoming one of the same. First PALCO declares bankruptcy which makes the HCP go away with other enviornmental restrictions. Merger takes place and new owners can cut more on the PALCO property than the old PL. Then they could subdivide the properties based on patent parcels. New landowners could then cut the remaing trees as exemptions for building sites, new roads, and fire protection sending the remaining logs to the new sawmill. Maxxam is then gone along with wildlife protections and all trees are gone. Sub-standard sub-division roads filling the creeks with silt killing the last remaining salmon. Water pumps pumping all the water from the fish bearing creeks to supply the new homes. Domestic dogs and cats killing the remaining wildlife along with teenagers shooting everthing that moves. Great idea. Keep up the good thinking. Corprate America needs people like you. $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
by stop SPI
davis_creek_aerial-1974.jpg
The 1974 photo shows a section of Davis Creek prior to acquisition of former BLM virgin fir forest in Davis Creek by SPI in 1983.
by stop SPI
davis_creek_aerial-1998.jpg
The 1998 photo shows devastation by SPI with the remaining stands of old-growth on the chopping block of Timber Harvest Plan 03-232 -- the Windmill THP.
by stop SPI
daviscrkaerial1974vs1998.jpg
Overlay of photos shows reveals Sierra Pacific Industires destruction of virgin douglas fir forest.
by stop SPI
98closerup.jpg
Closer view of SPI's destruction of Davis Creek.
by author required
cut all but 4%. how much will it matter to cut the rest ?

The higher value of these trees is in their conservation values.

really. do these values pay money ? if they did and that were true there would be no need to log it would there

The value of Old Growth must also be measured in conservation values such as acres of habitat provided for isolated populations of endangered wildlife, and stability for sensitive and unstable hill slopes.

you mean you can measure old growth value in $ form ? why do you have to protect something just because it is old ?. i ask you this. how many animals can you name that are extinct or endangered because of logging ?
and im sure there are laws in place to prevent erosion.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$40.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network