From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Ignacio Chapela's last class
This is a photo account of the last class of ESPM 6, introduction to Environmental Sciences, with Ignacio Chapela. He is being denied tenure by UC Berkeley in a fairly well publicized case, where despite an excellent record of publications, teaching, and the support of his department, he was denied tenure because a professor in another department opposed him. An agriculture corporation opposed the results of his research on the spread of pollen from transgenic corn in Mexico, and strongly pressured the top journal Nature to retract his published work.
I think it is important to emphasize that Professor Chapela has very strong support from people in the biology and environmental sciences departments. In fact, during conversations with other students in these departments, I haven't encountered anyone who isn't on his side. I have suspected that to an outsider it might seem like Chapela is really some sort of eccentric radical who is making a big fuss, but that the university might have a legitimate reason to push him out, but everyone I have spoken to within our field is aware that Ignacio Chapela is a great professor, with great teaching skills, and Monsanto was not able to criticize the results of his study, about the distance that pollen from transgenic corn was able to drift and interbreed with native corn strains in Mexico. They just disagreed with his policy recommendations in the discussion section of the paper he did with graduate student David Quist.
The tenure justice committee http://www.tenurejustice.org wanted to emphasize that the university decided late Tuesday to call a press conference regarding cleanup efforts at the polluted Richmond Field Station/Campus Bay at 10am Thursday, right at the same time of this protest. This would serve to dilute coverage of both events.
During his last class, outsiders has been invited to sit in. Chapela has a very verbal (as opposed to visual) and interaction teaching style. He invited students to report on news stories that could relate to environmental issues from the international press. Then he did something of an open-mic, where he read passages from three books, and mentioned a lot of others. Chapela stands out as having particularly broad interests, often venturing outside of the narrow topic at hand. This is particularly clear when you have a normal conversation with him. He is one of those people who speaks several languages and is able to recommend book titles and he can cook and sing and play guitar.
Several other professors made statements in his classroom at the end, and then the crowd regrouped outside, and marched towards California Hall.
There was a list of very notable speakers in front of the administration building. A professor of biochemistry since 1952 lamented how the university has really changed recently with the decrease in state support, and increase in costs paid by tuition and corporate funding. Whereas earlier, the university was clearly indebted to think of public interests in the choice of research topics and service, they are now pressured to produce results for private donors. Pr. Carol Merchant, a big name in philosophy of science in environmental science spoke as did a number of other faculty. The chancellor wouldn't come out of the building to accept letters or address the crowd.
If one reads into the tenure process which can be a bit flexible and political when a candidate might be near the cut -off point, it is fairly clear that Chapela has all of his evidence and points lined up very well for his lawsuit.
The tenure justice committee http://www.tenurejustice.org wanted to emphasize that the university decided late Tuesday to call a press conference regarding cleanup efforts at the polluted Richmond Field Station/Campus Bay at 10am Thursday, right at the same time of this protest. This would serve to dilute coverage of both events.
During his last class, outsiders has been invited to sit in. Chapela has a very verbal (as opposed to visual) and interaction teaching style. He invited students to report on news stories that could relate to environmental issues from the international press. Then he did something of an open-mic, where he read passages from three books, and mentioned a lot of others. Chapela stands out as having particularly broad interests, often venturing outside of the narrow topic at hand. This is particularly clear when you have a normal conversation with him. He is one of those people who speaks several languages and is able to recommend book titles and he can cook and sing and play guitar.
Several other professors made statements in his classroom at the end, and then the crowd regrouped outside, and marched towards California Hall.
There was a list of very notable speakers in front of the administration building. A professor of biochemistry since 1952 lamented how the university has really changed recently with the decrease in state support, and increase in costs paid by tuition and corporate funding. Whereas earlier, the university was clearly indebted to think of public interests in the choice of research topics and service, they are now pressured to produce results for private donors. Pr. Carol Merchant, a big name in philosophy of science in environmental science spoke as did a number of other faculty. The chancellor wouldn't come out of the building to accept letters or address the crowd.
If one reads into the tenure process which can be a bit flexible and political when a candidate might be near the cut -off point, it is fairly clear that Chapela has all of his evidence and points lined up very well for his lawsuit.
Add Your Comments
Comments
(Hide Comments)
Well, UC Berkeley loses a great thinker because they prefer the short term profits of Novartis, Monsanto and whatever other biotech corporation provides funding to scientific honesty that reveals the negative effects of biotech..
When the truth finally emerges about the fallacies of biotech like an air raid siren we cannot ignore (ex. famine from massive GE monocrop failure, GE resistant insect plague, etc..), we may find ourselves directionless in a world of transgenic mutants, (some being our own children) because the real knowledge of fluid ecological phylogeny was stifled by finacially obsessed administrators like Berkeley's cowardly chancellor..
What Chapela offers the students of Berkeley and the people of Earth is an real alternative that draws on the ancient wisdom of Oaxacan maize farmers and their adaptable varities (>50) of maize, also the risks of GE pollen transfering to maize's wild cousin teosinte. There was also something said about the possible benifits of recombining non-GE maize with their wild cousin teosinte to ensure greater resistance to insects and such. Could this also be applied to rice?
Selecting adaptable strains of maize happened in Oaxaca for at least 500 years before Dupont's introduction of petrochemical pesticides in the 1950's (leftovers from WW2 chemical weapons) that begun our nowhere run on the pesticide treadmill. Ditto that for the biotech GE toxins that create GE resistant weeds/insects, then farmers purchase the "latest" GE seed, etc..
The funny thing is we am really uninformed about the details of this "rewilding of maize" we heard Chapela talk about previously. Since he is no longer teaching at Berkeley, we probably won't find out unless he writes a book or something about this topic..
Well here's a website about the details of Oaxacan maize, teosinte and the effects of GE gene transfer via pollen drift..
http://ucmexus.ucr.edu/index.php?content=publications/n41Sp04/maize.html
No matter how hard we flap our wings, we still haven't found a way to fly to the moon, the air up there just doesn't seem to breathable, something about oxygen, guess we'll be staying on Earth for a while..
When the truth finally emerges about the fallacies of biotech like an air raid siren we cannot ignore (ex. famine from massive GE monocrop failure, GE resistant insect plague, etc..), we may find ourselves directionless in a world of transgenic mutants, (some being our own children) because the real knowledge of fluid ecological phylogeny was stifled by finacially obsessed administrators like Berkeley's cowardly chancellor..
What Chapela offers the students of Berkeley and the people of Earth is an real alternative that draws on the ancient wisdom of Oaxacan maize farmers and their adaptable varities (>50) of maize, also the risks of GE pollen transfering to maize's wild cousin teosinte. There was also something said about the possible benifits of recombining non-GE maize with their wild cousin teosinte to ensure greater resistance to insects and such. Could this also be applied to rice?
Selecting adaptable strains of maize happened in Oaxaca for at least 500 years before Dupont's introduction of petrochemical pesticides in the 1950's (leftovers from WW2 chemical weapons) that begun our nowhere run on the pesticide treadmill. Ditto that for the biotech GE toxins that create GE resistant weeds/insects, then farmers purchase the "latest" GE seed, etc..
The funny thing is we am really uninformed about the details of this "rewilding of maize" we heard Chapela talk about previously. Since he is no longer teaching at Berkeley, we probably won't find out unless he writes a book or something about this topic..
Well here's a website about the details of Oaxacan maize, teosinte and the effects of GE gene transfer via pollen drift..
http://ucmexus.ucr.edu/index.php?content=publications/n41Sp04/maize.html
No matter how hard we flap our wings, we still haven't found a way to fly to the moon, the air up there just doesn't seem to breathable, something about oxygen, guess we'll be staying on Earth for a while..
Miguel teaches Agroecology in the ESPM dept at UC Berkeley, and is also outspoken about biotech issues and corporate control of University research since the College of Natural Resources signed the research funding deal with Novartis years back.
Transgenic Helter Skelter. Has anyone seen Ganesh, the Indian guy who is part elephant yet?
I lost job in San Francisco at the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation as a bank examiner because the management there on Ecker Street in 2000 was stacking their employment heirarchy with willing conspirators in crime.
A dead man in his office labeled suicide. I survived two attempts, and now this professor told to hit the bricks over his honesty in fears of what is our upcoming nightmare, Transgenic Helter Skelter
http://www.angelfire.com/zine2/democracyordeath/index.html
Mobile Audit Club, music art comedy science investigations, and my own personal horrors and others deaths and the reasons behind them. Never trust any government agency or hospital. Not all are bad, but they have their war criminal element.
At least you are Berkeley, if you can afford the place. Alabama is under siege by corporate outsiders in Mobile Alabama where we can not vote, and people are conned into complaceny while a silent war wages. A dead senator Michael Figures, a blood clot after going to their court in my case. What is up is our nation has gone down. Best of luck in trying to right it.
I lost job in San Francisco at the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation as a bank examiner because the management there on Ecker Street in 2000 was stacking their employment heirarchy with willing conspirators in crime.
A dead man in his office labeled suicide. I survived two attempts, and now this professor told to hit the bricks over his honesty in fears of what is our upcoming nightmare, Transgenic Helter Skelter
http://www.angelfire.com/zine2/democracyordeath/index.html
Mobile Audit Club, music art comedy science investigations, and my own personal horrors and others deaths and the reasons behind them. Never trust any government agency or hospital. Not all are bad, but they have their war criminal element.
At least you are Berkeley, if you can afford the place. Alabama is under siege by corporate outsiders in Mobile Alabama where we can not vote, and people are conned into complaceny while a silent war wages. A dead senator Michael Figures, a blood clot after going to their court in my case. What is up is our nation has gone down. Best of luck in trying to right it.
For more information:
http://www.angelfire.com/zine2/democracyor...
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network