top
US
US
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Bush Admin Moves Toward Dropping Murrelet Protections

by reposter
Portland, OR-- In a move that heralds increased coastal old-growth logging,
the Bush administration today redefined the population of marbled murrelets
in Washington, Oregon, and northern California in preparation for removing
its Endangered Species Act protections.
murrelet_sm.giff91zg9.gif
Bush Administration Moves Toward Dropping Murrelet Protections

Politics trumps science as government seeks to open rare old-growth forests
to logging.

September 1st, 2004

Contact Info:
Susan Ash, Portland Audubon Society,503-504-7151
Kristen Boyles, Earthjustice, 206-343-7340 x33
Dave Werntz, NEA, 360-319-9949
Doug Heiken, ONRC, 541-344-0675
Cynthia Elkins, EPIC, 707-923-2931
Noah Greenwald, CBD, 503-243-6643

Print-Friendly Version

Portland, OR-- In a move that heralds increased coastal old-growth logging,
the Bush administration today redefined the population of marbled murrelets
in Washington, Oregon, and northern California in preparation for removing
its Endangered Species Act protections. Washington, D.C., officials
announced today that they will no longer consider Pacific Northwest
murrelets as isolated from murrelets in Canada and Alaska, blatently
disregarding recent recommendations by independent, private-sector
scientists, as well as their own scientists, to keep federal protections in
place.

³The report of the scientific review team could not have been more
compelling in its call for continued protection for murrelets, and its
conclusions that these birds are on the path to extinction,² said Susan Ash,
Conservation Director with the Portland Audubon Society. ³Once again, the
Bush administration is doing the bidding of its campaign contributors ­
ignoring sound science in order to serve up more precious old-growth forests
to the timber industry.²

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service agreed to conduct a status review of the
old-growth dependent birds in response to a timber-industry lawsuit that
sought to remove those protections. EDAW, a private environmental consulting
firm in Seattle, conducted the scientific review of the birds¹ status over
the past year.

The status review, released in March, recommends keeping the murrelet¹s
current population status, stating that ³marbled murrelets should be
considered to include at least three distinct populations: (1) the Aleutian
Islands or northern population; (2) the Alaska Peninsula to Puget Sound or
central population; and (3) the California, Oregon, and western Washington
or southern population. In April, the Fish and Wildlife Service¹s Regional
Office in Portland confirmed that the Pacific Northwest murrelets deserve
federal protection.

³Everyone agrees that marbled murrelets may soon be gone forever from the
coastal forests of the Pacific Northwest,² said Dave Werntz, Science
Director at the Northwest Ecosystem Alliance, ³This announcement is a slap
in the face of sound science and open, credible decision-making.²

In 1997, the Fish and Wildlife Service estimated that the marbled murrelet
population in the Pacific Northwest was declining four to seven percent a
year. More recent demographic models indicate that populations in
Washington, Oregon, and California are still declining rapidly and will be
extinct within the next 50-100 years.

³Apparently, the Fish and Wildlife Service under the Bush administration no
longer protects species, but simply presides over their extinction,² said
Kristen Boyles, staff attorney with Earthjustice. ³This twisting of law and
science for political ends has got to stop.²

Marbled murrelets are shy, robin-sized seabirds that use old-growth forests
for nesting and rearing their young. First protected in 1992 after
widespread logging of their old-growth forest habitat, marbled murrelets are
listed as a threatened species. A 2002 lawsuit filed by the timber industry
challenged the marbled murrelet listing, as well as its habitat protections.
The Fish and Wildlife Service will be reviewing the murrelet¹s critical
habitat protections over the next several years.
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by ESA
Marbled Murrelet Fact Sheet

5-Year Status Review Scientific Findings

· The Washington, Oregon, and California murrelet population is a
distinct population from the murrelet populations in Canada and Alaska, due
to major differences in habitat ownership and management in Canada and the
United States.
· The Pacific Northwest populations also are considered distinct
populations because each likely has a suite of different behavioral,
ecological, and genetic characteristics that have developed under very
different ecological conditions within these 3 global marine ecosystems.
The genetic characteristics of murrelets in California are significantly
different than Alaskan murrelet genetics.
· 91% of marbled murrelet habitat is on federal lands.
· Continued declines in murrelet population in Washington, Oregon, and
California due to loss of nesting habitat from logging and urbanization are
predicted.
· Models indicate that murrelet populations are declining more rapidly
than previously understood, and may disappear from the Pacific Northwest
within 100 years if more habitat is not protected.
· In California, predicted probability of extinction is 100% within the
next 40 years.
· Murrelets will not recover until there is significant improvement in
the amount and distribution of suitable nesting habitat.
· Protection of nesting habitat on Federal land could be severely
compromised if the Northwest Forest Plan is altered.

History of Endangered Species Act Protections

· The marbled murrelet is a small, elusive seabird that nests mainly in
old-growth forests along the Pacific coast.

· In 1992, after many years of study and public comment, the U.S. Fish
and Wildlife Service listed the Washington, Oregon, and California
population of marbled murrelets as ³threatened;² the Service designated
critical habitat for the bird in 1996. A district court found that ³[t]he
principal factor affecting the murrelet population through this tri-state
area is the loss of old-growth and mature forests as a result of commercial
timber harvest.² In short, where coastal old-growth forests have been
destroyed, the murrelet has disappeared.

· In 2002, the timber industry lobbying group, American Forest Resource
Council, filed a lawsuit to force the Service to undertake a review of the
murrelet¹s status and to void its critical habitat designation.

· The independent status review report was completed in March 2004 and
determined that the murrelet population are declining more rapidly than
previously and require federal protection.
· Scientists at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in Portland, Oregon
agreed with the assessment in April, but were reversed by officials in
Washington DC.

Canadian Protections

· There is currently no management plan for murrelets in Canada.
· Only 1% of lands in British Columbia are publically owned and
managed.
· Under forest practice rules for the remaining lands, logging
companies are responsible for identifying the habitat needs of murrelets and
documenting impacts. Protection for endangered species habitat, including
marbled murrelets, cannot reduce prescribed logging levels by more than 1%.
Since logging levels are based on economic factors, any habitat protected
during one year could be logged when economic conditions change.




Ecology and Conservation

· The murrelet is a small, long-lived (up to 25 years), diving seabird
about the size of a robin.
· Once called ³the enigma of the Pacific,² the marbled murrelet was the
last bird in the United State to have its nesting site discovered. This was
in 1974 by a tree-trimmer high up on a Douglas fir tree in California. To
this day, it is extremely rare to see an occupied murrelet nest.
· Murrelets make their nests in natural depressions of large,
moss-covered old-growth tree limbs. In fact, for the most part they don¹t
actually build ³nests,² but simply deposit their individual eggs in these
mossy depressions.
· Murrelets only come off the water at dawn or dusk, and fly up to 60
miles an hour, making sighting a challenge to land-based observers.
· Females lay only one egg per year.
· During incubation, the female and male take turns sitting on the egg
for 24-hour shifts.
· Both parents share responsibility for bringing fish from the ocean
back to the chick¹s nest in the old-growth forest.
· Parents stay with their newly hatched chick just one to two days,
then leave the chick entirely alone, returning only to feed it.
· Murrelet pairs return to the same forest grove each year and
sometimes nest repeatedly in the same tree.
· A murrelet chick's first flight is critical. It must make it all the
way to the ocean or hope to crash land in or near a stream that will then
carry it to the ocean.
· In addition to old-growth logging, marbled murrelets are threatened
by oil spills and fishing nets, especially from gillnet fishery operations.
· Murrelets are counted at-sea, and they are scarce or absent offshore
of areas where most of the old-growth forests have been logged.

For more information:
· Download 5-year scientific status review at:
http://www.ecosystem.org/projects.html. Scroll down to ³Wildlife.²
· For information on murrelet ecology, or the content of the Status
Review, contact the following panelist: Kim Nelson, Oregon State University
Wildlife Biologist, at 541-737-1962; Tom Hamer, Hamer Environmental, 360-
422-6510; and Vicki Friesen, Queens University, 613- 533-6160.
· For information on the murrelets in California, call Esther Burkett,
California Department of Fish and Game, 916-654-4273.

We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$230.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network