top
Afghanistan
Afghanistan
Newswire
Calendar
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Ted Rall: Political cartoon about Pat Tillman
by anonymous
Monday May 3rd, 2004 11:33 PM
Pat Tillman is not a hero.
rallcartoon.gif
§TR Reposts
by TR Reposts Thursday May 6th, 2004 6:59 PM
Pat Tillman

Today's cartoon is getting a lot of coverage from right-wing media outlets as well as more legitimate ones like Editor & Publisher. As is often the case in these situations, it's impossible to reply to each email individually, so I'll just say what I have to say here.

My cartoon is a reaction to the extraordinary lionizing of Mr. Tillman as a national hero. First of all, the media's decision to genuflect to a cult of death is terrifyingly similar to the cult of Palestinian suicide bombers in the Middle East and the glorious coverage given by the Japanese during World War II to fallen kamikaze fighters. Nowhere has this excessive praise for the act of voluntary death been more extreme than in Mr. Tillman's case.

The purpose of a political cartoon is to stimulate discussion, and there was no discussion about America's post-9/11 death cult.

Second, Mr. Tillman served an evil president and an evil cause. Anyone with an open mind after 9/11 could easily have learned the truth, that the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq occured instead of a war on terror, not as part of one. A person who planned to risk his life in combat should reasonably be expected to dig a little deeper rather than to fall for Bush's transparent lies. We all judge each other, and while Tillman's decision to sacrifice millions of dollars for his beliefs is admirable, his belief that killing the citizens of Iraq and Afghanistan had something to do with defending America was not. At best, Tillman was foolish and misguided.

Finally, it's time for troops who signed up post-9/11 to take a little personal responsibility. It's one thing for a career soldier to go where the politicians tell him or her to go, but quite another to join the military when the "president" is an illegal usurper occupying the White House, he's an out-of-control warmonger using the deaths in New York, Washington and Pennsylvania to promote a partisan political agenda and his wars are nothing more than grabs for control of oil and gas resources and pipeline routes. Liberals tend to let volunteer soldiers off the hook, but let's not forget the hard, cold truth:

If no one had enlisted after 9/11, we wouldn't be fighting these immoral wars based on lies and greed now.

Update as of Tuesday: I'll be the lead on tonight's O'Reilly Factor, on Fox News, 8 pm Eastern time.

.: posted on 10:59 PM
http://www.rall.com/rants.html
§TR Repost
by TR Repost Thursday May 6th, 2004 7:00 PM
More on Tillman

This post will be my last word on my cartoon about Pat Tillman. Having read more than 6,000 emails about it, a number of random thoughts cross my mind.

First and foremost, this country is in the throes of a militarism that is frightening. Militarism is an ideology that sees war not as a means to an end, but rather as a self-perpetuating purpose in and of itself. The excitement of the waving flags, the sense of common purpose, the thrill of risking lives--ours and our fellow citizens'--in a grand crusade to expand our nation's influence, avenge some slight, whatever.

Even what passes for the "left" in this country insists that we "support our troops." Why? Because during Vietnam, some veterans reported having been insulted as "baby killers." These stories are largely fictional, but whatever--let's take them at their word. What irony! Vietnam vets, many of whom were drafted, were insulted. Now our army is 100% volunteer--and we're not allowed to point out that picking up a gun and shooting people they tell you to shoot is a choice.

Others on the left point out that poor people from rural areas with high unemployment see joining the military as a means of overcoming economic disadvantage. At a starting salary of $12,000, however, your average private would do better taking a job at McDonald's, where the pay is the same and nobody's shooting at you.

Obviously the lion's share of the blame for our current atmosphere of warmongering based on lies must be placed on the disgusting creature named George W. Bush as well as his demented greedhead cronies in the Administration. After that comes the media, which lionizes people like Tillman because they gave up everything--money, a bright future, even their life!--to serve their coun--well, to fight in Afghanistan and Iraq. (Tillman fought first in Iraq, then Afghanistan.) It's the same sales pitch used by Hezbollah and Hamas to recruit suicide bombers: die for the greater good. Except these wars are not good. They're not defending us from terrorists; they're recruiting them. And the 9/11 terror attacks remain utterly unavenged.

Even so it's time for Americans to start boycotting the military. If there hadn't been a spike in recruitment after 9/11, the Pentagon would not have had the ability to wage war in Iraq, where even now they are so shorthanded that they sent for another 47,000 troops. The last thing anyone should do with their life is sign it away as a blank check to George W. Bush--a man who did everything in his power to dodge the draft when he had his chance to fight in Vietnam, a war that he supported as long as other guys were doing the dying.

I've been asked what I would have done, as president, after 9/11. I've written about this extensively, in books and essays, but to summarize:

I would have leaned on Egypt, which receives $2 billion annually in US foreign aid, to track down the masterminds of Egyptian Islamic Jihad. IJ is the group that killed Anwar Sadat, and all 19 hijackers were members. They were also all Egyptian--the 15 "Saudis" merely held Saudi passports. I would have demanded that those leaders be prosecuted for mass murder on 9/11.

Regime change, if necessary, should have focused on Saudi Arabia, which funded the attacks, and Pakistan, which is--contrary to media myth--Al Qaeda HQ. General Musharraf's ISI intelligence agency created the Taliban and spread militant anti-American Wahhabiism throughout South and Central Asia. Get rid of him, and you eliminate funding for the camps in Afghanistan, a nation that was before 9/11 nothing more than a back lot for Pakistan's misdeeds.

There's more--much, much more--but as I said, I've written about all this before and I am seriously tired.

Pat Tillman died for nothing. He may have been an admirable person in many respects--we're all complicated--but he made a terrible decision by joining Bush's mercenary military after 9/11. If someone dies because they screw up behind the wheel of their car, it's a tragic accident. It's awful and we're sad--but it ain't heroism, folks.

Heroism? That's pretty damned rare. Shooting at people for pay, unless you're defending your country, surely ain't that particular bird. And America has never been endangered by Iraq or Afghanistan. North Korea, Pakistan, and Saudi Arabia, on the other hand...

.: posted on 10:34 PM
http://www.rall.com/rants.html

Comments  (Hide Comments)

by Pearce
(TheEvilBLueSmurf [at] hotmaill.com) Wednesday May 5th, 2004 10:10 PM
The artist rapes a soilders good name and character for his own personal gain. I believe the artist needs to give an apology to Tillmans family, tell them why their son, their father, their husband was an evil man deserving of this. Would anybody on this forum goto a funneral home and say that the person who died was a racist, hateful, murderer. Mr. Tillman left a life of riches from the NFL to help america win the terrorist fight. The artist discredited Mr. Tillmans name so he can make TV deals and sell his book. It's so wrong no matter if your a democrat, conservative, black, white, poor or rich.
by Chris Henson
(hurricane555 [at] hotmail.com) Thursday May 6th, 2004 6:14 AM
I hope your happy for ruining the name of a fine soldier. Make a cartoon about me I am a soldier but I didnt turn down millions to join. Pat Tillman was a soldier and an american hero quit exploiting his name.
by Fred Fletcher
(fletchfb [at] bellsouth.net) Thursday May 6th, 2004 6:53 PM
How sick can one person get. I will protest this with my $$. Any newspaper in my area that carries this "artist" trash will not be supported by me and I will talk to their major advertisers. THis must not go uncheck.

But bottom line - I think this came from teh Bay area! Is it really a surprise??

We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

donate now

$ 97.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network