From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Splinter March report
Breakaway March report
Roughly 2,000 people initially went on the "unpermitted" march, which left Jefferson Square at approximately 2:40pm. The march was a mixture of black bloc, pink/carnival bloc, queer bloc, and general hangers-on/observers.
The march went down Golden Gate Avenue, turned south down Van Ness, & headed towards Mission Street after turning off Market. I think it was in between 8th and 9th Street on Mission, the Police then gave everyone a verbal warning, saying the protest was unpermitted and anyone not standing on the sidewalk would be subject to arrest. This is where the first group of people sat down and linked arms, and after a tense stand off they were arrested and taken away (http://www.indybay.org/news/2003/03/1583032.php). The march then moved back to Market Street, but was confined to the sidewalk.
The crowd headed back towards Market and was slowed down by a very heavy police presence at every step. An attempt to retake the street was made but police moved in on the 'dirtbike' white bikes very quickly cutting off people arriving, and the numbers of people trying to hold the street position were insufficient. It was back onto the sidewalk again (to chants of "Whose sidewalk? Our sidewalk!").
The cops were definitely a lot more organised than February 16th. They didnt bring any horses with them this time after they bolted when frightened at the intersection of 8th and Market on the previous breakaway march. There were also a lot more of them than F16.
The march went several blocks up Market, and people ran down different side streets in surprise attempts to take the streets again, but the sheer numbers of cops meant that every attempt was thwarted. At one intersection, on Mission, and 2nd (I think? There is a cinema on the corner), after another sprint, the cops caught up with 3 or 4 masked in black at the front of the charge, and threw them to the ground quite violently and cuffed them with the plastic ties almost instantly. This was well before the majority of the run arrived at the corner, and I dont think any media or legal observers saw this incident.
After a few cat-and-mouse runs back and forth, the march was back on the sidewalk on Market Street. Police were making it very difficult to move any way at all, splitting the march up as much as possible at pedestrian crossings.
I left around 4.45pm, was knackered after all the running! Things seemed to be dying off at that stage, the lack of bodies meant it was proving difficult to do anything constructive. I didnt see the mass arrest taking place, maybe someone else can write that up.
There was no property vandalism whatsoever, and as has been pointed out already, the cops arrested more people than any previous breakaway march. Next time lets fuck the shops over good and proper.
Today's march was a bit all over the place, definitely not as cohesive or effective as F16. There was a lack of communication and unity of purpose. When the first bunch of people sat down at Mission and 9th, nobody could see what was happening until they'd been coralled onto the sidewalk and could only watch and shout as the people were hauled away. Also the attempts at bringing the march back onto the street were frustrating as the crowd was spread out through people not keeping tight, and easily split or pushed back onto the path.
There was also a journalist present in the Bloc from the SF Chronicle. He told me his name but I forget. I chatted to him at length about direct action and Black Bloc methods, and gave Rob Morse our love, asking him to come down in person again next time and we can have a discussion with him. It will be interesting to see if there's any report about it. Probably not.
Alright, time for bed, again.
The march went down Golden Gate Avenue, turned south down Van Ness, & headed towards Mission Street after turning off Market. I think it was in between 8th and 9th Street on Mission, the Police then gave everyone a verbal warning, saying the protest was unpermitted and anyone not standing on the sidewalk would be subject to arrest. This is where the first group of people sat down and linked arms, and after a tense stand off they were arrested and taken away (http://www.indybay.org/news/2003/03/1583032.php). The march then moved back to Market Street, but was confined to the sidewalk.
The crowd headed back towards Market and was slowed down by a very heavy police presence at every step. An attempt to retake the street was made but police moved in on the 'dirtbike' white bikes very quickly cutting off people arriving, and the numbers of people trying to hold the street position were insufficient. It was back onto the sidewalk again (to chants of "Whose sidewalk? Our sidewalk!").
The cops were definitely a lot more organised than February 16th. They didnt bring any horses with them this time after they bolted when frightened at the intersection of 8th and Market on the previous breakaway march. There were also a lot more of them than F16.
The march went several blocks up Market, and people ran down different side streets in surprise attempts to take the streets again, but the sheer numbers of cops meant that every attempt was thwarted. At one intersection, on Mission, and 2nd (I think? There is a cinema on the corner), after another sprint, the cops caught up with 3 or 4 masked in black at the front of the charge, and threw them to the ground quite violently and cuffed them with the plastic ties almost instantly. This was well before the majority of the run arrived at the corner, and I dont think any media or legal observers saw this incident.
After a few cat-and-mouse runs back and forth, the march was back on the sidewalk on Market Street. Police were making it very difficult to move any way at all, splitting the march up as much as possible at pedestrian crossings.
I left around 4.45pm, was knackered after all the running! Things seemed to be dying off at that stage, the lack of bodies meant it was proving difficult to do anything constructive. I didnt see the mass arrest taking place, maybe someone else can write that up.
There was no property vandalism whatsoever, and as has been pointed out already, the cops arrested more people than any previous breakaway march. Next time lets fuck the shops over good and proper.
Today's march was a bit all over the place, definitely not as cohesive or effective as F16. There was a lack of communication and unity of purpose. When the first bunch of people sat down at Mission and 9th, nobody could see what was happening until they'd been coralled onto the sidewalk and could only watch and shout as the people were hauled away. Also the attempts at bringing the march back onto the street were frustrating as the crowd was spread out through people not keeping tight, and easily split or pushed back onto the path.
There was also a journalist present in the Bloc from the SF Chronicle. He told me his name but I forget. I chatted to him at length about direct action and Black Bloc methods, and gave Rob Morse our love, asking him to come down in person again next time and we can have a discussion with him. It will be interesting to see if there's any report about it. Probably not.
Alright, time for bed, again.
Add Your Comments
Comments
(Hide Comments)
If any of the editors are still awake and reading this - there's a bad link on the front page, I think it's Photos number 4 of the breakaway march, just a slight HTML code glitch. I think you're missing a bracket somewhere.
re: unpermitted march routing, south of market is just a bad idea. very long blocks where you can be boxed in, and dead-end alleys. running is great, but preferably run down market and north of market (not up market or south of market)...... please use caution on sidewalks, you may be subject to arrest for such activities as standing, walking, or dressing funny.
"Next time lets fuck the shops over good and proper."
Maybe the police are deliberately trying to provoke you into property destruction, in the belief that it will hurt your public image and bolster theirs. As it is, Saturday's unpermitted, undestructive march was out-and-out repressed, which will make people sympathetic to you and to unpermitted marches in general.
Israel has used this strategy in the past: unprovoked attacks, over and over, until people get so pissed off they finally respond violently, which is used to justify the ensuing Israeli "retaliation".
Maybe the police are deliberately trying to provoke you into property destruction, in the belief that it will hurt your public image and bolster theirs. As it is, Saturday's unpermitted, undestructive march was out-and-out repressed, which will make people sympathetic to you and to unpermitted marches in general.
Israel has used this strategy in the past: unprovoked attacks, over and over, until people get so pissed off they finally respond violently, which is used to justify the ensuing Israeli "retaliation".
It's true - the march was repressed, but wouldn't have been with smaller affinity groups and better communication between them.
The success was that the cops had to follow everyone all over and thus were continually blocking traffic, blocking shoppers, disrupting business, etc. Stores like Old Navy had their metal grates down even though the stores were open. BB filled the sidewalks in front of them so shoppers couldn't get by. Cops had to run and didn't know where people were going.
And the complete lack of vandalism was a success - it shows the BB is adaptive and can easily outmaneuver the corporate media when it comes to trying to spin it.
For my part, just being in the streets in that way is a success - the crowd of shoppers were mixed in with everyone at times and it became complex as the cops blocked everyone from crossing, forcing everyone in together on the sidewalk. The band was playing and people were dancing in front of shuttered Old Navy, and you have a sense, for a moment, of what streets could really be, what they maybe once were.
The success was that the cops had to follow everyone all over and thus were continually blocking traffic, blocking shoppers, disrupting business, etc. Stores like Old Navy had their metal grates down even though the stores were open. BB filled the sidewalks in front of them so shoppers couldn't get by. Cops had to run and didn't know where people were going.
And the complete lack of vandalism was a success - it shows the BB is adaptive and can easily outmaneuver the corporate media when it comes to trying to spin it.
For my part, just being in the streets in that way is a success - the crowd of shoppers were mixed in with everyone at times and it became complex as the cops blocked everyone from crossing, forcing everyone in together on the sidewalk. The band was playing and people were dancing in front of shuttered Old Navy, and you have a sense, for a moment, of what streets could really be, what they maybe once were.
It's a good thing you live in this country "tons of vandalism" if you existed in a society that didn't shelter you it would be a sorry sight. Felonies do not automatically give you a FBI record. Prison rape is not common unless you are a little bitch like yourself. Like all war mongers you attack the people willing to take a stand not their opinions or ideas. Because you are an ignorant fuck I'll tell you why this is. This impending war is not just and it will not make us any safer. After the next terrorist attack who will you want to kill then. Keep the cycle of violence and imperialism going and it will kill us all.
>Butt Raped?
This refers to a comment that was removed.
This refers to a comment that was removed.
Thanks for removing the trolls. These have turned into some productive conversations.
Okay - as for vandalism, I have a few thoughts and hope to hear some response, as my thoughts are cemented.
I believe I have an idea why (and am respectful of) people participate in vandalism, though I think the tactic is not effective right now. The person who mentioned closing off business in other ways is right - Old Navy shutting their gates, Sony Metreon being blocked by cops. Very good.
I believe in Revolutionary overthrow of the government/system, though I don't believe immediate anarchy will be a success without an interum move (and most likely another future revolution) towards truly democratic, human nature social operation. I do believe in the solidarity of those who believe this system is not working - even though many of us have different ideas on how to go about this or what could come of it.
With that said, building the movement towards a revolution happens both spontaneously (a lot of people are effected by what's going on in the world right now) and with planning. Education, discussion, "unconditioning", real life experience with action (which a lot of the folks joinging this movement have very little of and deserve the chance to experience), etc.
We don't have the numbers right now to destroy physical property without it resulting in the divide & conquer seperation of *any* movement going on. We do have the numbers and passion to *move* this forward, reaching out, educating ourselves and others, building solidarity, practicing real life action, making the connection and becoming strong.
Okay - as for vandalism, I have a few thoughts and hope to hear some response, as my thoughts are cemented.
I believe I have an idea why (and am respectful of) people participate in vandalism, though I think the tactic is not effective right now. The person who mentioned closing off business in other ways is right - Old Navy shutting their gates, Sony Metreon being blocked by cops. Very good.
I believe in Revolutionary overthrow of the government/system, though I don't believe immediate anarchy will be a success without an interum move (and most likely another future revolution) towards truly democratic, human nature social operation. I do believe in the solidarity of those who believe this system is not working - even though many of us have different ideas on how to go about this or what could come of it.
With that said, building the movement towards a revolution happens both spontaneously (a lot of people are effected by what's going on in the world right now) and with planning. Education, discussion, "unconditioning", real life experience with action (which a lot of the folks joinging this movement have very little of and deserve the chance to experience), etc.
We don't have the numbers right now to destroy physical property without it resulting in the divide & conquer seperation of *any* movement going on. We do have the numbers and passion to *move* this forward, reaching out, educating ourselves and others, building solidarity, practicing real life action, making the connection and becoming strong.
I loved your article: I looked around at other publicatoins, but they all left so much out, and none of them seemed like they were written by someone who was actually there (in the breakaway group, I mean). I was there, and your version of what happened is right on with what I saw. I live in Sacramento and missed my bus home because I was one in a crowd that was surrounded by police on a sidewalk (surronded on three sides and up against a building). They proclaimed themselves a 'police line' and said we simply could not go past them. That was all they would say. I was on the corner in front of the Four Seasons hotel (probably the rear of the hotel: the street went down and into a parking structure), and thei paddy wagon was right in front of me. They were maching people, one by one, in those zip- tie cuffs, into the wagon. So many arrests. . . I would say I saw easily thiry people arrested, just in that incident. I was also there when the first group of 15-18 sat down in the street, and saw several people picked up by their jaws, and one very onfortunate man had his arm twisted very hard many times, so that he was screaming in pain.
Anyway, I think it's great that you're writing about what's really happening, so that people have a way of knowing what's really going down on the streets.
Anyway, I think it's great that you're writing about what's really happening, so that people have a way of knowing what's really going down on the streets.
folks... again, we all saw that kid with the north face jacket and mask spray painting anarchy "a's" on the gap and other store fronts and we also saw the guy get caught for stealing out of a store on market and fifth(powell), i saw people punch the glass of the gap and kick sidewals signs(breaking them) but yet no one says a damn thing, you all just smile and nod your head and agree that there was no nothing....
This is from today's SF Chronicle.
"At Fourth and Market streets, several demonstrators tried unsuccessfully to break windows at the Old Navy store. That was the only attempt at vandalism, police said. "
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2003/03/16/MN85413.DTL
"At Fourth and Market streets, several demonstrators tried unsuccessfully to break windows at the Old Navy store. That was the only attempt at vandalism, police said. "
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2003/03/16/MN85413.DTL
For more information:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?...
Its good we're recognizing the value of image finally. The more peaceful the protest is, and the more resistance it is met with, the more positive the response. I've read elsewhere here on Sf indy that many uninvolved people were arrested. This increases our numbers by showing the repressive nature of the State and its security forces.
As an addition to the Israel point, India also resisted oppressive outside rule. Ghandi used the repression of the enemy as his only weapon, and because of this India gained it's independance. Palestine reacted against tyranny with violence, and so has propetuated the cycle (which may continue indefinitely).
Remember this, remember this lesson....
As an addition to the Israel point, India also resisted oppressive outside rule. Ghandi used the repression of the enemy as his only weapon, and because of this India gained it's independance. Palestine reacted against tyranny with violence, and so has propetuated the cycle (which may continue indefinitely).
Remember this, remember this lesson....
the ghandianproudonian's logic is that of a mental slave.
only comfy liberals think the soft repression visited upon demonstrator's the other day galvanizes resistance to the status quo.
the only thing that's sure to inspire resistance is resistance that succeeds.
only comfy liberals think the soft repression visited upon demonstrator's the other day galvanizes resistance to the status quo.
the only thing that's sure to inspire resistance is resistance that succeeds.
We hadn't participated in prior breakaways, but did so this time in part to get the real story and in part to enjoy the energy (while was sorely lacking in the permitted march.)
The only property damage that we saw in our three or so hours of following (and often trailing) the breakaway was police damage to protester property. At the Third Street mass arrest, a police officer destroyed signs and flags, to the boos of hundreds of onlookers. We tried to remind the police that there job was to protect property, but they somehow forgot.
This march was militant and energetic, but was not violent. There wasn't even that much resistance during the arrests. There was often noncooperation, but the police (as almost always is the case) were the one's who were using force to deny constitutionally protected rights to the people that they are supposed to serve.
To folks whe think that these breakaways are harmful to "the movement", you can all be proud of the behavior of the Black Bloc folks, as far as I could see. Let go of the "good protester" rules and consider that this type of resistance is a necessary part of raising the costs of war. Thousands of shoppers saw that non-violent (if non-permitted) protesters were being subject to police state tactics for walking down the sidewalk.
Resistance is fertile!
The only property damage that we saw in our three or so hours of following (and often trailing) the breakaway was police damage to protester property. At the Third Street mass arrest, a police officer destroyed signs and flags, to the boos of hundreds of onlookers. We tried to remind the police that there job was to protect property, but they somehow forgot.
This march was militant and energetic, but was not violent. There wasn't even that much resistance during the arrests. There was often noncooperation, but the police (as almost always is the case) were the one's who were using force to deny constitutionally protected rights to the people that they are supposed to serve.
To folks whe think that these breakaways are harmful to "the movement", you can all be proud of the behavior of the Black Bloc folks, as far as I could see. Let go of the "good protester" rules and consider that this type of resistance is a necessary part of raising the costs of war. Thousands of shoppers saw that non-violent (if non-permitted) protesters were being subject to police state tactics for walking down the sidewalk.
Resistance is fertile!
"the only thing that's sure to inspire resistance is resistance that succeeds. "- aaron
vision inspires. only vision.
this is pandemonium vs. panopticon.
are these really the options? do we really have to buy into the notion that there is only so much to go around when there are those who believe that we have all the resources we need, just no will to make things better?
let's talk practicalities. who wins in a chaotic situation like the dreamed for revolution? the ones with the numbers or the ones with the guns?
is Revolution the only possible solution? i see parallels between those who can't remember the features of my city but are more than willing to plot a Revolution starting there with the words that come out of George Jrs. mouth.
i don't believe this is a "last resort" plan you guys are suggesting here. i don't see any evidence of "good faith" or that you've exhausted all your options.
call me a troll if you want... I actually care what you think. i want to know why i don't see calls for targeted political action- for demands to change the corrupt two party system here with something that might work better.
enlighten me. but ask yourself this: is this really the last hope- or do you just hate so much that you can't bother with trying to make things better?
vision inspires. only vision.
this is pandemonium vs. panopticon.
are these really the options? do we really have to buy into the notion that there is only so much to go around when there are those who believe that we have all the resources we need, just no will to make things better?
let's talk practicalities. who wins in a chaotic situation like the dreamed for revolution? the ones with the numbers or the ones with the guns?
is Revolution the only possible solution? i see parallels between those who can't remember the features of my city but are more than willing to plot a Revolution starting there with the words that come out of George Jrs. mouth.
i don't believe this is a "last resort" plan you guys are suggesting here. i don't see any evidence of "good faith" or that you've exhausted all your options.
call me a troll if you want... I actually care what you think. i want to know why i don't see calls for targeted political action- for demands to change the corrupt two party system here with something that might work better.
enlighten me. but ask yourself this: is this really the last hope- or do you just hate so much that you can't bother with trying to make things better?
Before this turns from a news article into a pro/anti violence thread, can i point out that Gandhi was well up for property destruction (esp. arson), and had pretty backward views about gender and caste?
It will shatter too many illusions.
i happen to be a supporter of the break away marches...i used to partake in them during the old yippie days....i happen to like the idea of us being a thorn in the side of asscroft, bush, scumsfeld, etc.
even though i am physically unable to partake in the break aways....lets kick ass
even though i am physically unable to partake in the break aways....lets kick ass
the protest ended at the point when the 15 or so participants sat down clutching hands in a circle and prepared themselves for arrest. we had been moving along pretty well until this point. as we slowed down (and wore on the patience of the police) we were boxed in like cattle until the point when the announcement was made that our assembling was now an illegal activity. once the protesters sat down and the police began closing in on them, the exterior police barracade dissipated. they only had so many police, and it was taking more than they had to encircle the sitters and keep the rest of us on opposite sides of the street. i looked around at this point and noticed that the direction we came had reopened... now i don't know the city that well, but i know if we didn't all make suck a fucking spectacle of the sitters and arrests, we could have gotten our asses on the freeway and really got some attention. i'm surprised the police didn't do this earlier given how amazingly effective it was at blinding us to other opportunities that opened up. pigs in circle formation trying to look like terminators really don't deserve that much attention. we've got better things to do.
EVERYONE KNOWS THAT SADDAM HAS PAID BLACK BLOC TO PROTEST AGAINST USA.
WHEN WAR STARTS, THE CIA, FBI, AND SFPD HAS BEEN GIVEN ORDERS TO SHOOT ON SITE ANYONE WHO IS TRYING TO SABATOGE AMERICA.
ANY SADDAM SUPPORTERS WILL BE SHOT BY THE AUTHORITIES.
WHEN WAR STARTS, THE CIA, FBI, AND SFPD HAS BEEN GIVEN ORDERS TO SHOOT ON SITE ANYONE WHO IS TRYING TO SABATOGE AMERICA.
ANY SADDAM SUPPORTERS WILL BE SHOT BY THE AUTHORITIES.
Help is needed by the author of this article or anyone that witnessed the arrest of Mitzy and Omar. As they were leaders of the initial bolt down Market onto 3rd (i think?), many failed to see their arrest. If you did, please speak up. The brutal force of the police needs to be testified by a bystander, for as of now, it is their word against the police.
Omar wears a styling mohawk and Mitzy was adorned by a multi-colored scarf covering her head and face.
They will be released today and face charges of assaulting an officer. This charge is devastatingly off, as the only assault committed was that of those in blue.
Please respond if you have any information: salofsonoma [at] yahoo.com
Peace out... see you on the streets.
Omar wears a styling mohawk and Mitzy was adorned by a multi-colored scarf covering her head and face.
They will be released today and face charges of assaulting an officer. This charge is devastatingly off, as the only assault committed was that of those in blue.
Please respond if you have any information: salofsonoma [at] yahoo.com
Peace out... see you on the streets.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network