top
Anti-War
Anti-War
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Video and photos: Police violence at breakaway march

by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
Two-part realvideo of police violence during Feb. 16, 2003 anti-war breakaway march.
Copy the code below to embed this movie into a web page:
See below for part 2, photos, and a transcript of the videos.
§Police grab and club someone fleeing from the trap
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
horse-smack-drag.jpg
Police grab and club someone fleeing from the trap.
§He barely got away.
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
getaway-1.jpg
He barely got away.
§Second strike at butterfly woman
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
butterfly-down-second-strike-marked.jpg
The violet arrow shows the second club coming down as the woman with butterfly wings is already falling. Her arm is pointed to by the green arrow.
§Butterfly woman falls
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
butterfly-down-2.jpg
Butterfly woman continues falling
§Why are their batons like swords?
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
saber-batons.jpg
The horse patrol had batons which were cut like a sword, with a sharp blade and sharp tip as well.
§Their batons were scary enough without being shaped like swords.
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
horsey-scary.jpg
Their batons were scary enough without being shaped like swords.
§Cruelty to animals as well as cruelty to protesters
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
horsey-not-happy.jpg
Cruelty to animals as well as cruelty to protesters.
§#424 Horse cop even clubbed someone\'s sign!
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
horse-cop-clubs-sign.jpg
#424 \"Horse cop\" even clubbed someone\'s sign!

Here\'s a partial transcript of the two videos:

00:00 Army of motorcycles moves through to engage the crowd. Geary and Mason

00:33 Peace sign from someone in the San Franciscso Shopping Center

00:45 Crowd and drumming standoff

1:20 Smoke bomb and orange cone fly behind police lines

1:40 Police run to form new line down Market.

1:49 \"Stop the Objectification of Women\" chalk on sidewalk appears guarded by police line. Ironic considering what happened at
time 3:35 (below), with police guarding a porno theater

2:05 A rock thrown under a police car struck a woman demonstrator, she is injured and hurt.

2:27 Hats and bats emerge from the patrol car.

2:39 Anarchy symbol on their car; Just down the street, \"Support the Troops who break rank\" is stenciled on a bus ad

3:18 Passengers honk support

3:35 Defending the sex cinema

3:43 Another smoke bomb

3:59 \"Stand up for your rights\" chanted

4:14 The police begin to box the demonstration in; people aren\'t allowed to leave. A lot wasn\'t included here but people were obviously scared of what was going to happen as the walls moved in

4:32 Horses aren\'t allowed on sidewalks: learn something everyday

4:45 Horse batons look like swords, they\'re hardened and sharpened

4:54 A demonstrator gets out! Then feigns springting back in. Police don\'t seem to notice him but definitely aren\'t letting people through.

5:15 Police are clubbing people on the sidewalk. Horses rush onto the sidewalk and also use batons. Despite being \"not allowed\". I was far away when it started.

6:00 Police push man with blue jacket, then #460 walks his horse and pushes him with her

6:24 several more break through, one gets caught by a cop, a melee ensues but he gets away.

6:33 Horse patrol #424 begins his infamous rampage, striking someone at the curb, appears to have lost control of his horse and himself, charging with baton swinging, sometimes wildly, striking a sign just over someone\'s head, etc.

8:00 Horses appear to be leaving the demonstration as a crowd demands that they leave.

8:18 sparks from 424\'s horse\'s hooves as it slips on the concrete.

8:54 Police barricades have appeared in the street

9:03 Horses are out of the demo. They were really scary, in no small part because they appeared so hard to control and move so unpredictably, and so quickly, and are so large.

9:30 Police attack demonstrators, clubbing a woman wearing butterfly wings, knocking her over

[End Part 1]

[Begin Part 2]


00:00 Why is the police bicycle stuck under a police car? \"So nobody would take it\"

00:26 Police car rushes through crowd, strikes a demonstrator clad in black who flies up on his hood and then rolls off

00:36 slow motion of the aforementioned

1:00 the next car is not allowed through, someone climbs on the hood, police attack clearing the street quickly

1:43 SFPD #2170 attacked blond drummer

2:08 Suddenly cops are rushing through the crowd atacking and arresting, causing fear and a stamped. I do not know why they rushed through but a number of arrests resulted.

2:48 Cop has to put his helmet back on, it fell off

2:58 Head crushed under knee, pile of cops on top

3:33 I get name and number of the blond drummer just before he is violently arrested

4:14 The blond drummer is arrested.

#4217 stomping on foot (literally, up and down hard).

Police are trying to interfere with my right to observe. \"{1612 I have a right to observe\"

05:13 Cop grabs me by neck and shoves me (stated, not on camera)

5:43 Why is there a bullhorn strapped to a motor officer\'s off-road motorcycle?

6:06 Blond drummer boy is limp in middle of street, they keep wrenching his head off the ground and dropping it back down (not all captured on video)

6:40 Police car was smashed up a bit (broken window, circle a on the hood).

6:52 police attack, one (#1518) rushes straigt into crowd, goes out of his way to club a peaceful woman twice, another woman\'s leg is really hurt (my video doesn\'t clearly show everything but I was watching with the naked eye). I couldn\'t find the woman who was charged and clubbed.

7:25 scream therapy/criticism towards the police after all the terror

7:33 Woman in pain who police had just hurt #1929 D. Meredith (?) --- sounded like D. Merit (appropriate, \"demerit\").

8:02 Police attack women who are moving back as police line approaches despite steady movement (I was saying \"slowly\" over and over again). He then rushed me and pushed me slightly. His number, 2186, chanted.

8:40 Police line told \"do not cross the flower\" which was chalked by demonstrator.

8:50 Dead Kennedy\'s from a window with banner.

\"IRAQ\" sticker in center of \"Do Not Enter\" sign.

9:03 It\'s now dark. Motorcycles move in on the crosswalk bloc. Lots of cheering erupts over the sirens and horns.

9:41 Police lines wall in and surround the sit-in in the crosswalk.

9:57 Crosswalk is cleared abruptly. Police clearly violated the \"do not cross the flower\" directive.

10:09 Cop rebukes demonstrator about how the protesters are \"fucking it up for all the people who want peace\" and claims that business as usual is necessary in order to \"facilitate...all the people going someplace to fight the war\"

10:55 Police drive motorcycles wrong way. Still have a helicopter.

11:09 \"I need you to get out of the street\" to make the world safe for cars...which generate demand for an oil war.


Note: The identification numbers on police were frequently missing, or parts missing, and just the fact that some have four numbers made it difficult as you can usually only see three at the most when looking at their helmets.

Note: the time on my (borrowed) camera is probably about 5 minutes slow. Note also this camera had difficulty getting a clear picture especially as it got darker, may be partially a white balance issue, also things happen so fast and the cops are wearing such nondestinct colors, which hide their actions in a group. The frame rate of contemporary video is also inadequate to consistently capture fast movement such as baton blows.


§A bystander at the curb got rushed and clubbed
by Jason Meggs (( jmeggs at b c l u dot org ))
horse-cop-clubs-bystander.jpg
A bystander at the curb got rushed and clubbed before he could even react.
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by jm
I took a look at KTVU since I know their camera man was there for a bunch of the police violence.

You can watch two clips on the web at http://www.ktvu.com/

The first one, with Mayor Brown, starts off with some of the clearest video shots of the police abuses I've seen so far, which contrast rather well with Brown's propaganda that the demonstrators were out of hand. Watch a lone woman get rushed and hit hard, for example.

The second video ("tension mounts") was not that valuable in terms of exposing the police misconduct, but does show a lot of footage of the breakaway march.
by Jason Meggs
Part 2:

http://www.indybay.org/news/2003/02/1575303.php

by a
SF Prosecutors Making Headway On Protest Cases
Brown Praises Police Response To Unruly Crowd

both link to a video called "Tension Mounts at SF Demonstration". It's easier to go there and get it inline, but this might work for y'all:

Where's the first video?

by damn!
that sucks! they censored it!

my stupid explorer shit would'nt copy the link or show the source so i couldn't post the link

have since switched to mozilla, alleged open source and better

http://www.mozilla.org/

if i had time i'd be calling ktvu to get an answer about why this was censored. i hope the camera person is not in trouble.
by jm
I've been advised that it would be good for me to publish RealVideo in 320x240 format rather than full size format, and to deinterlace the footage first. This is proving too much trouble to redo right now but I'll try to do it in the future. For now, it may help to make the window smaller while it's playing. I had received some compliments for posting in the larger size and assumed that any deinterlacing issues were being handled by the conversion software.

La la la.
by notim portant (subvertone [at] yahoo.com)
I really enjoy your footage it was well put together and well shot. I am however, concerned with the fact that you missed various parts that were pretty big you cut off all the speeches made on the meag phone during the standoffat about 5:30 or so just before we got shoved back into the sidewalk. you also missed them letting us off the sidewalk and the part where we start dancing to the nice beats and the part toward the end when we stopped dancing and sat down to block the traffic some more we were then arrested I was just thinking at that point where is a goddamed camera? it was the strangest thing there was no fucking camera none whatsoever. why not? there were fifty-something-odd cameras while the other things were happening.but when sixty-seventy people were arrested for peacefully assembling and dancing there were no cameras in sight why was this? because every body seemingly got tired or thought there was nothing left to see but I would think anybody was completely aware that as long as there are people there should be at least one camera.now, I could be wrong there could have been cameras there you infact could have beenm there but i have been on the web for a day and a half now and have found nothing yet in the way on photos, footage, or even a written report.
if I am mistaken, that is my fault and I have wasted both my time and yours. I would appreciate knowing where to find some of this media if it so exists. if you could e-mail me a list of links websites e-mail addresses phone nube4rs etc I would be rather appreciative.my e-mail address is listed above it is: subvertone [at] yahoo.com

thank you (I in no way seek to offend by this post simply point out the lack of availability of important documentation and media)

by jm
Notim,

Sorry if my piece (the longest one I've seen posted) was incomplete for you. It's a lot of work to edit the video and encode it, arrange it, write up the story and log, post it, etc. I deliberately made the hard choice to limit what I showed. Also, it was a big scene and there was a lot going on. Personally I have a not-so-good borrowed camera with a short battery life. For various good reasons, including the end of my battery life, I left when it seemed to be over. When people take actions which have risk of arrest they would be well advised to make sure there are some cameras around.

There could certainly be more efforts at organizing the use of video at demonstrations. We could be a lot more effective in many ways. I too noticed the sea of cameras earlier -- I wonder what everyone is doing with their footage? I hope they've at least contacted the legal effort, as even footage that doesn't seem dramatic can be extermeley helpful.
team.
by stuart hanlon (stuarthanlon [at] mindspring.com)
i amn drummer boys lawyer. he is charged with serious crimes. we need witnesses, photos, videos. please help stuart hanlon
by Geebo
If you really are the drummer boy's lawyer, I really feel sorry for him now.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$140.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network