Immigrants fear new US policy
|
|
Badie Adouti peers nervously from behind his sunglasses at the line of people outside the offices of the Immigration and Naturalisation Service (INS) in downtown San Francisco, as he contemplates whether or not to comply with a new immigration policy or face being sent back to his country.
|
There they will be fingerprinted, photographed, interviewed, checked against criminal databases and run through international terrorist watch lists.
Flaws in the Entry-Exit Registration System were brought to light following the terrorist attacks of 11 September when it was discovered that some of the accused were in America on expired student visas.
'Not legal'
Badie admits that his own visa has run out and that he does not know whether or not to register - friends who came down earlier in the week were arrested and put in jail for visa violations.
If I go in I might be arrested and deported and I don't like that to happen to me
Chedi Fathi
|
"I am so scared, I can't sleep at night," explains Badie, who says he has worked in the city for three years and never been in any trouble.
"We have friends inside who have been arrested. I am not legal here. I don't know what to do."
Equally conflicted is Badie's friend, Chedi Fathi, who also admits to having an out-of-date visa.
Everyday this week, he says, he has come down to the offices to register - everyday he has gone back to his apartment to try and figure out the right thing to do for his future.
"With this new law I might be detained. I am standing in front of the INS building in San Francisco and I am so frustrated," he says.
|
"I don't even have a passport. If I go in I might be arrested and deported and I don't like that to happen to me."
The latest figures from the Department of Justice in Washington show that so far 400 people have been detained in California on suspected immigration violations since November, when the registration of visa-holders from countries considered high risks for terrorist activity began.
Jorge Martinez says all but 20 have been released, their names having been checked against terrorist wanted lists and criminal files.
Quiet protest
Throughout this week, a peaceful vigil organised by the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee has been staged across the road from the INS offices in San Francisco in protest against the registration process.
I am standing here in this line waiting for my future
Ghazi Balti
|
"The reason I am sitting here is that I am very concerned about the direction my government is taking in detaining and registering people born in other countries," she told BBC News Online.
"I think it's racist and designed to instil fear in all of us and immigrants and I want to see and end to it."
'Suspicious'
Bill Hackman from the Act Now to Stop War and End Racism Coalition likened the round-up to a witch-hunt of McCarthyite dimensions.
"The perception that the government is putting out is that we are supposed to be suspicious of men of colour, especially Arabs," he says.
|
"They are telling us these people are our enemy at a time when the government is trying to push for a war with Iraq and we are here today to say we oppose this."
Across the street, Ghazi Balti from Tunisia waits patiently in line with his attorney.
His tourist visa expired two years ago, and he lives in San Francisco with his wife and two children.
"I have never been in trouble. I am not a terrorist. I am hearing they are putting people in jail and I am worried for my family," he says.
"Behind this law is what happened on 11 September and we are going to pay for it. I am standing here in this line waiting for my future."
'Alienating'
The whole process is being carefully monitored by a non-profit group called INS Watch.
Volunteers in yellow armbands take a note of the names of people who are going in to register and some contact details in case they are detained.
They ask that the registrants check back in with them so they know what has happened to them.
Heba Nimr is an attorney for INS Watch. "The INS has been so secretive about this process and we are hearing all kinds of conflicting reports about what is going on," she says.
"We are here to help these people and make sure that the INS as a public institution is accountable to the public."
Civil liberties advocates say the government scheme is an inefficient way to find terrorists and will only alienated a group that could help the government.
There are 13 countries affected by 10 January deadline.
They are Afghanistan, Algeria, Bahrain, Eritrea, Lebanon, Morocco, North Korean, Oman, Qatar, Somalia, Tunisia, the United Arab Emirates and Yemen.
Another 14,000 men from Saudi Arabia and Pakistan have until 21 February to register.
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Friday is the cut-off for males over the age of 16, from 13, mainly Muslim countries, who are not permanent US residents, to have registered with the Immigration and Naturalisation Service (INS).
The controversial "special registration" effort has attracted widespread condemnation from civil rights groups and has been the subject of numerous legal challenges.
On Thursday a lawsuit filed by US-Muslim groups following the first wave of registration, seeking a block on further such detentions, was dismissed by a US federal judge.
The judge said that the men had been arrested legitimately by the INS for breaking immigration laws.
Fingerprinted
Under the scheme male foreign nationals from countries identified as harbouring terror groups must register, be fingerprinted and questioned.
Several cities reported queues of people from the early hours of Friday morning, despite many voicing concern that they may be detained.
Up to 1,000 men from Iran, Iraq, Libya, Sudan and Syria, who came forward in earlier registration processes, are currently being held by US authorities, according to human rights advocates.
US officials however, put the number at around 250.
Men from Pakistan and Saudi Arabia must register by 21 February.
Immigrant's fear
Many illegal immigrants fear that they may suffer the same fate as those being held.
"I'm totally scared," 28-year-old Chedli Fathi, whose student visa expired in 2001, told the San Francisco Chronicle newspaper.
"If I go, I can get arrested, and if I don't go, I can get arrested. In both cases, it is bad for me."
Muslim community leaders in Los Angeles, California - one of the first states where Middle Eastern men were obliged to register - said they were deploying around 160 human rights monitors to immigration stations in the city.
It was in Los Angeles - home to a sizeable Iranian community - that the majority of detentions in December last year took place.
The arrests led to mass protests, with many comparing the process to the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II.
Human rights groups said that many of the detained men were genuinely going through the complex process of obtaining permanent residency status, or a so-called "green card".
The arrests also became a public relations disaster for the Bush administration, with critics saying that it is unlikely that terrorists would take part in a voluntary registration programme.
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
So do U.S. Citizens. I was fingerprinted when I got a driver's license, and when I had to renew it via a new eye test.
The question I keep asking here, that no one seems willing to answer is ... what would you do differently?
Are you saying that we should simply open our borders up and let anyone come here no questions asked? If not, then what should the procedures be? What should happen to people who violate them? Everyone here keeps griping about how illegals are being treated "unfairly". So what is the fair thing to do?
"Chedi Fathi, who also admits to having an out-of-date visa."
Where else but in America can someone tell the news that they broke a serious law AND voluntarily have their photo taken and published! Even with this long-overdue enforcement of laws the INS is still screwed up.
I wonder how many of the hundreds arrested will show up for their hearings? I can't believe we let these criminals back on the streets!