top
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Suicide Bombers Go PC

by COLLIN LEVEY
Suicide Bombers Go PC
It's springtime on campus -- that time of year where any excuse to sit outside will do. And lo, like clockwork this week, college students across the country got out their Frisbees and their politics.

The must-have opinion of the season is on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. You get one guess which side the loudest ones are on.

The University of California at Berkeley, that bastion of sun-kissed young adults with a chip on their shoulder, was among the first to stomp the grass. Earlier this month, a sit-in for Palestinian statehood on the ramps of an interstate snarled traffic badly enough to need intervention by the California Highway Patrol.

On Tuesday at the University of Michigan, protestors paraded through the campus bound and gagged. One, out in his skivvies, explained via a signboard that "I am one of tens of Palestinians who were asked to strip naked by the Israeli Army, lie on their stomachs and then taken to an unknown location." (Yes, tens.)

All told, students at some 30 universities across the country -- from the University of Nebraska to Georgetown to Rutgers -- are expressing their solidarity with a group of people who send college-age kids out to self-detonate near as many Israeli civilians as possible.

Most of the tactics on display are recycled from every other protest movement -- from Vietnam right up through the antisweatshop brigade. Berkeley students this week even demanded that the school stop buying stocks in companies like General Electric that do business with Israel à la apartheid divestment.

The problem is that the parallels don't work. At a time when Americans willingly arrive at the airport hours before flights to comply with new security measures, the outrage of University of Michigan undergrads at similar measures in Israel doesn't really resonate. That's the campus where students today are confronted on the way to the library with activists running mock "Israeli checkpoints" and demanding to see their school ID.

The University of Michigan, one presumes by all available statistics, is teeming with some of the brightest young minds in the country. But someone might point out to the kids that this isn't exactly the kind of stuff that gets you sent to a human rights tribunal.

Still, there are plenty of new acronyms on campus supporting the Palestinian cause, and this too is part of the issue. At many institutions, anti-Semitism has long been one of the handful of dirty words like racism, sexism and homophobia. Jewish students have too often played into this, turning the Holocaust into an occasion for a sit-in in the college center -- an act which demeans the Nazi atrocities by putting them on par with "Take Back the Night." Jewish groups like Hillel have tried to find common ground with groups like the Black Student Union by playing up the fact that they are victims too.

The coming clash on campus seems destined to play out as a contest to determine who wins the prize as the biggest victim. The whole thing is tedious, not to mention confusing for college students and their nascent herd-like politics. Some Jewish students, so accustomed to being among the cheerful bands expressing outrage against oppression, are so confused by the latest turn of events that they have in fact joined the Justice for Palestinians groups condemning Israel's "occupation" of Palestinian land. From Brown University comes the heart-melting story of a Jew and a Palestinian joining hands to . . . condemn Israel.

For their part, Palestinian groups have been keen to draw a moral equivalence between recent Israeli actions and the Holocaust. A West Coast student recently called the situation "exactly like the ghettos that were created by Poland and Germany in the 1930s and '40s."

But beyond the usual angry sputtering and name-calling, there are some signs for concern. The Jewish student center at Berkeley recently had a window smashed and "F -- ing Jews" scrawled on the garbage cans. Students coming out of synagogues got egged. And worse, near the Berkeley campus, two Orthodox Jewish men were attacked.

If it sounds an awful lot like what's been happening in Europe, that's because it is. In the ivory towers of American academia, as in Paris, Rome and Madrid, the workaday fascination with hating the U.S. and its foreign policy has been transposed to one of its allies. That's not good news for Israel. But for the moment Ariel Sharon has more important things to worry about.
by learn to tell the difference
Nobody attacking Jews or Jewish religious institutions in France or in Berkeley is making that distinction between Zionism and Jews.

To wit, lLets just recap recent events:

Within the last 2 years in Berkeley,

Two Orthodox Jews got assaulted, because they looked Jewish.

Berkeley Hillel, the religious and cultural center for Jews had a cinderblock smashed against its window and "F-- the Jews" scrawled as grafitti.

Jews coming out of Yom Kippur services two years ago at I-House were egged.

A Jew was attacked during Simchat Torah observances at Bancroft and Telegraph last fall.

A Jew was followed from the Berkeley BART to College and Bancroft, by a youth, who confronted him and asked if he was Jewish. When he said yes, he was beaten. He wasn't asked if he was pro-Israel!

And in France
A Jewish soccer team was assaulted with crowbars, a Jewish cemetary was firebombed, a school bus of schoolkids was pelted with rocks, a couple including a pregnant Jewish woman were beaten by thugs, several synagogues have been attacked.

The common denominator:
All of the above were attacked because people or buildings were Jewish, regardless of whatever other ideological baggage the attackers had in mind.

If you think this is merely anti-Zionist, what is going on right now, you are sadly deluded -- this is also a virulent anti-Semitic outbreak.

I am a liberal and a progressive on many issues. But I am ashamed at how much denial of blatant prejudice is being enabled and even encouraged by people on the left who I thought were supposed to be against prejudice and hatemongering of all kinds!

As you know not every Jew supports Israel. If this is not anti-Semitism then why is every Jew bearing the brunt of this for being a Jew? Or is it possible that some who should know better are stereotyping and stigmatizing Jews because they assume that all Jews support Israel?

And if Jews are attacked for being Jews then doesn't that make the case for Jews needing Israel in the first place?


Bias crimes d
by me again
Because Zionism encourages anti-Semitism. Not only have the Zionists created the least safe country on earth for Jews to live in, but they have shamed the Jewish People. They have done to Jews what Nazis did to Germans. Maybe that's why so many Jews have been demonstrating against Zionism in front of the Israeli consulate here the last few days. Maybe they are sick of a handful of villians making them all look bad.
by DD
You again.

Stop this shameful act of blaming the victim. Jews have a right to safe haven and justifying anti-Jewish prejudice on any pretext, as well as justifying anti-Muslim bias, is patently offensive. Beating Jews
and attacking our institutions and places of worship is NEVER justified! Invoking and appropriating the symbolism and the very day of rememberance of the Holocaust against us is viscerally repulsive, morally reprehensible and patently, verifiably false. It is shameful anti-Semitism and I will call it such wherever and whenever I encounter it.

If I turned around your logic and said that anti-Muslim bias was justified by the awful campaign of fundamentalists engaged in terrorism and suicide bombing against innocent civilians and that righteous Muslims rejected suicide bombing as the obscene taking of life, how would you feel? Put the shoe on the other foot for once in your life and acknowledge that there are two sides to this coin.
by check your sources
WHAT I LEARNED FROM MY RUN-IN WITH ARAB HATRED

The "Palestinian" Yeshiva Boy
Reflects on His Near-Death Experience

by Tuvia Grossman for Am Echad

As the violence in the Middle East continues, we all have our opinions about the Arab uprising, the peace process and what might be done to halt the bloodshed. There are many lessons we might learn from the events of the past weeks but an important one is the one I personally learned in a rather unwelcome way.

Shortly after the violence first broke out, I happened to be traveling in a taxi in Jerusalem with two friends when our car was attacked by a mob of Arabs who stoned it, forcing us to stop. The crazed mob then dragged us out of the vehicle and proceeded to severely beat and stab us. Somehow - miraculously is the only way I can understand it - we were able to break away and escape to an Israeli Army position down the road.

As a Jewish American student studying in a Jerusalem yeshiva, I had little experience with the hatred that so many Arabs seem to have for Jews. Indeed, I had conflicted feelings about the Arab- Israeli conflict. But none of that would have made any difference to those who assaulted me and my friends. They wanted, to put it simply, to kill Jews. What they ended up doing, though, was to put me on the path to a lesson I will never forget.

The first indication of the lesson came as I lay in my hospital bed, recovering from a stab wound in my thigh, multiple gashes to my head, and a broken nose. I started receiving phone calls from Jews all over the world, each offering support and compassion. Total strangers showed up at the hospital to visit me and asked what they could do to help me. What I began to realize then is what it is that characterizes us Jews as a nation. The Hebrew word is "achdut", which translates as "unity": a connection that binds us all. As I learned in yeshiva, the sages of the Talmud teach that "kol Yisrael areivim zeh lazeh," - all Jews are "intertwined" each with every other.

That concept includes not only all Jews alive today, but all who ever lived, a thought central to the holidays we Jews celebrate. On Passover we are required to imagine ourselves as redeemed from Egypt along with our forefathers; the matzos and bitter herbs we eat connect us - and have connected every Jewish generation - to the Jews who actually labored in and escaped ancient Egypt. On Shavuot, which commemorates the giving of the Torah, we rejoice with the same happiness as if we ourselves were standing at Mt. Sinai receiving the Torah today.

When my picture was published in The New York Times and countless other newspapers and magazines with the distorted caption identifying me as a Palestinian being beaten by the soldier who had actually saved my life, a powerful outpouring of complaints from Jews around the world compelled many of those papers, including The Times, to republish the photograph with a corrected caption and accurate story.

I feel that the overwhelming response to the photo that led to that correction was born of the very aspect of "achdut" that I first realized in my hospital bed. Jews around the world felt that the bond holding us together had been somehow violated by the misidentification of one of our people, and simply refused to allow it to go unchallenged. It was as if the misrepresentation of any Jew was the misrepresentation of every Jew.

That is the lesson I learned, the lesson I am still learning, the lesson all we Jews so need to learn. Even if we feel somewhat removed from the situation in Israel, we must all realize that the suffering of any Jew is the suffering of us all. The whole Jewish nation felt assaulted by my assault, and all of us must feel that we, not just our brothers and sisters in Israel, are under siege, threatened and despised. It is not, in other words, "what goes on in Israel"; it is what goes on in all of our hearts.

And as we share in each other's suffering, may we merit to share in common rejoicing as well.

AM ECHAD RESOURCES
Tuvia Grossman lives in Chicago and is planning to return to his studies in a Jerusalem yeshiva shortly.
by Konrad
The ghettos were created by the German Nazis in many countrys - including Poland. How dare you say that Poland itself created the ghettos? DO you know how many Jews fled to Poland after the Nazis gained power in Germany? Learn some history...
by Troy

I dare you to look at these web sites. You are all a bunch of ignorant hate mongers.

http://www.projectonesoul.com/consequences.htm

http://www.rotter.net/israel/

http://www.walk4israel.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=Victims
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$230.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network