From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
HOW OSCAR GHETTOIZED POITIER
41/2 of the most excruciating hours ever broadcast
ON Sunday night, this nation and the world were subjected to 41/2 of the most excruciating hours ever broadcast on television. The 74th Annual Academy Awards program was so excruciating in so many ways that it might be instructive to enumerate them.
Excruciatingly self-serious: Tom Cruise, who opened the show, and Kevin Spacey, who appeared somewhere in the middle, both generously offered the American people permission to enjoy themselves despite the losses of Sept. 11.
That "America has changed forever so we'd better run this show like it was a funeral" tone pervaded the show. The word "bummer" comes to mind. Oh, and while all the tributes to New York were nice (although dated and unwanted, as though the city were in some kind of post-9/11 coma and needed Hollywood's moral support) couldn't somebody have mentioned the Pentagon and Flight 93?
Excruciatingly patronizing: The spin on the evening was that it made history because two black performers won Best Actor and Best Actress on the same night that the first black movie star, Sidney Poitier, received an honorary Oscar.
But there was something terribly retrogressive about the way all this was treated. The Oscar show worked overtime to make us think of Denzel Washington, Halle Berry and Poitier not as unique and remarkable talents but rather as tokens.
Why were only black actors and actresses given a chance to speak in the three-minute film tribute to Sidney Poitier? Did Poitier's career really have meaning only to black performers? Of course not. His extraordinary dignity and power gave the lie to the racist idea that white audiences could only respond to white performers and white stories.
In a magnificent speech that was the highlight of the otherwise-unspeakable ceremony, Poitier himself paid a powerful and modest tribute to the directors, producers and studio heads who made history by casting him in the films that made him a star. They were all white.
So is Poitier's wife Joanna. Poitier had two daughters with Joanna, who are therefore both black and white. He is an integrationist not only professionally, but personally. For him to be seen as an inspiration only to black people is to ghettoize an extraordinary man who simply refused to accept the limits of race.
Then there was Halle Berry. In an acceptance speech so out-of-control that you worried she might actually have to be carted off the stage in a straitjacket, Berry reduced herself to the status of a "vessel." Berry basically said she was worthy of winning solely because other black actresses hadn't won before her and because "nameless, faceless" women of color everywhere needed a role model.
It must therefore have puzzled the TV audience immensely to watch as Berry gave thanks to her mother, to whom the camera cut immediately only to discover that Judith Hawkins Berry is white. Halle Berry is not a representative black woman and not a vessel. She is very much herself, which is how it should be in America.
Excruciatingly politicized: The show's opening film montage featured five political figures talking about the movies. One was Laura Bush. The other four? Jerry Brown, the leftoid Democratic weirdo mayor of Oakland. Willie Brown, San Francisco's Democratic mayor. Lani Guinier, the leftist law professor whom Bill Clinton deemed too radically quota-conscious for his administration. And New York's own Al Sharpton, who intends to be a Democratic candidate for president.
That's a 4-to-1 Democratic, left-wing tilt. Are people still willing to argue that Hollywood doesn't have a liberal bias?
Worse still was a pointed salute during that montage to a little-known 1974 documentary called "Hearts and Minds." At the Oscar ceremony in 1975, producer Bert Schneider read a telegram of thanks from the North Vietnamese government - the same government whose military had just concluded a 12-year war against the United States that led to the deaths of 58,000 young American men.
Oscar-show producer Laura Ziskin knows that perfectly well. She could have had the tribute to "Hearts and Minds" eliminated. In my view, she left it in to send some kind of subliminal message to the country about the war on terrorism.
Here's a not-so-subliminal message to Laura Ziskin: If you're going to run this show in the future, try not to bore America to death, OK? Then maybe we can talk politics.
Excruciatingly self-serious: Tom Cruise, who opened the show, and Kevin Spacey, who appeared somewhere in the middle, both generously offered the American people permission to enjoy themselves despite the losses of Sept. 11.
That "America has changed forever so we'd better run this show like it was a funeral" tone pervaded the show. The word "bummer" comes to mind. Oh, and while all the tributes to New York were nice (although dated and unwanted, as though the city were in some kind of post-9/11 coma and needed Hollywood's moral support) couldn't somebody have mentioned the Pentagon and Flight 93?
Excruciatingly patronizing: The spin on the evening was that it made history because two black performers won Best Actor and Best Actress on the same night that the first black movie star, Sidney Poitier, received an honorary Oscar.
But there was something terribly retrogressive about the way all this was treated. The Oscar show worked overtime to make us think of Denzel Washington, Halle Berry and Poitier not as unique and remarkable talents but rather as tokens.
Why were only black actors and actresses given a chance to speak in the three-minute film tribute to Sidney Poitier? Did Poitier's career really have meaning only to black performers? Of course not. His extraordinary dignity and power gave the lie to the racist idea that white audiences could only respond to white performers and white stories.
In a magnificent speech that was the highlight of the otherwise-unspeakable ceremony, Poitier himself paid a powerful and modest tribute to the directors, producers and studio heads who made history by casting him in the films that made him a star. They were all white.
So is Poitier's wife Joanna. Poitier had two daughters with Joanna, who are therefore both black and white. He is an integrationist not only professionally, but personally. For him to be seen as an inspiration only to black people is to ghettoize an extraordinary man who simply refused to accept the limits of race.
Then there was Halle Berry. In an acceptance speech so out-of-control that you worried she might actually have to be carted off the stage in a straitjacket, Berry reduced herself to the status of a "vessel." Berry basically said she was worthy of winning solely because other black actresses hadn't won before her and because "nameless, faceless" women of color everywhere needed a role model.
It must therefore have puzzled the TV audience immensely to watch as Berry gave thanks to her mother, to whom the camera cut immediately only to discover that Judith Hawkins Berry is white. Halle Berry is not a representative black woman and not a vessel. She is very much herself, which is how it should be in America.
Excruciatingly politicized: The show's opening film montage featured five political figures talking about the movies. One was Laura Bush. The other four? Jerry Brown, the leftoid Democratic weirdo mayor of Oakland. Willie Brown, San Francisco's Democratic mayor. Lani Guinier, the leftist law professor whom Bill Clinton deemed too radically quota-conscious for his administration. And New York's own Al Sharpton, who intends to be a Democratic candidate for president.
That's a 4-to-1 Democratic, left-wing tilt. Are people still willing to argue that Hollywood doesn't have a liberal bias?
Worse still was a pointed salute during that montage to a little-known 1974 documentary called "Hearts and Minds." At the Oscar ceremony in 1975, producer Bert Schneider read a telegram of thanks from the North Vietnamese government - the same government whose military had just concluded a 12-year war against the United States that led to the deaths of 58,000 young American men.
Oscar-show producer Laura Ziskin knows that perfectly well. She could have had the tribute to "Hearts and Minds" eliminated. In my view, she left it in to send some kind of subliminal message to the country about the war on terrorism.
Here's a not-so-subliminal message to Laura Ziskin: If you're going to run this show in the future, try not to bore America to death, OK? Then maybe we can talk politics.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network
a rather entertaining article, but with a shitty right-wing, at most pluralist, view on race and tokenizing. but i didn't know halle berry was half white, and that she went so far as trying to call herself a role model for women of color... i'll have to follow up on that.
as for denzel, that homie should've dedicated that Oscar to the Rampart division of the LAPD, the fucking pigs themselves! if it wasn't for them, there wouldn't be fucked up racist and corrupt cops in LA for Hollywood to make movies about.
as for sidney, of course he's a role model to black folks. whites can like him too, but HE IS BLACK. don't you right-wingers get it?
and about that "subliminal message"... maybe it was to let America keep in mind that not just 58,000 US soldiers (most of them minorities) died in Vietnam while at the same time the US's War against Vietnam murdered and butchered over 2,000,000 Indochinese.
-M
I guess I should be happy for Denzel and Berry, they were amazing in their films, but what about Spike Lee? When is that man going to get the credit he deserves? I guess little will change when the Board is a bunch of old white guys.
Halle played a single black mother with an ex husband who spent time in jail. Denzel played a corrupt policeman.
Doesn't sound like Hollywood has stopped its stereotyping roles to me.
Of course, these Hollywood actors are the same people who for years have thrown it in the face of average Americans that we are bigoted, racist, homophobes. We the people vote with our money at the ticket booth and time and time again we have shown that these things are not an issue when judging talent. If it's entertaining, people will go.
It has nothing to do with "old white guys". The board for the oscars is made up of a very diverse group of people. Making racist remarks about white people is wrong.
Berry and Washington CHOSE to take the roles they did. If it was stereotyping, they walked right into it with their eyes wide open. I don't think they're that stupid. Maybe you do.
Role models have nothing to do with right or left wing. If blacks are inspired by seeing other blacks succeed in any endeavor, I feel sorry for them. I would say that about any race of people. Role models should be people who inspire us and lift us up to do our best, and it should never be based on race. If we as a country continue to insist, for example, that only black actors can inspire future black actors, that only black political office holders can only truly represent the voice of other black citizens, and other things such as this, we do ourselves a great disservice. We simply must stop looking at each other in view of color.
I believe Berry and Washington won their oscars because they were the best in their field of work for the past movie season. I certainly hope they were not "given" these awards because of their color. That would be a slap in the face.