SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
Indybay About Contact Newsletter Calendar Publish Community

Santa Cruz Indymedia | Education & Student Activism | Environment & Forest Defense | Health, Housing, and Public Services

Strong Turnout to Protect UCSC Upper Campus Prompts LAFCO to Delay Decision
by Alex Darocy ( alex [at] alexdarocy.com )
Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
It was standing room only in the county government center for the Santa Cruz LAFCO meeting on June 6th, where over 50 community members spoke before the commission in support of protecting the forest and open space of the UC Santa Cruz upper campus from future development. During the meeting, university chancellor George Blumenthal threatened that UCSC would take legal action or withdraw the application entirely if the conditions LAFCO laid out on March 7 that limit extending water service to the north campus were imposed. After a break, commissioners John Leopold and Don Lane returned with amendments to the March 7 conditions, but ultimately LAFCO decided the next vote on the matter would be held in October. [scroll down for video, audio, photos, and LAFCO documents and proposed amendments]
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-1.jpg
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2...

"I find it interesting that three months after we voted on a new set of conditions that today is the first day in which the city and the university are coming up with alternatives," said LAFCO commissioner and Santa Cruz County Supervisor John Leopold at the June 6th meeting. "I think it is useful to engage in negotiations where we can meet our shared goals, it's not useful to try and intimidate the commission with threats of legal action, or even withdrawing the application, as was suggested [by George Blumenthal] earlier today."

The conditions Leopold referred to include protection for the locally endangered Coho Salmon and Steelhead fish species whose habitat have been negatively effected by the diversion of water from local streams by the City of Santa Cruz in the process of increasing the municipal water supply. A February 10, 2012 letter from the National Marine Fisheries Service stated, "To date, it does not appear that current water supplies are sufficient to meet current demand and protect listed salmonids, let alone allow for increased demands resulting from expansion of the City's service area. Decisions by LAFCO that facilitate the expansion of the City's service area, absent additional water supply, will exacerbate ongoing and future impacts to listed salmonids in the Santa Cruz Mountains."

To mitigate this, LAFCO added the following condition, in addition to several others, to terms of the approval of water service on March 7th: "The City of Santa Cruz will commit to reducing stream and river diversions to a level authorized by the federal and state resource agencies. To ensure this condition is fulfilled, the City shall not commence the delivery of water to the UCSC campus, outside of the City's water service area as that water service area exists on March 7, 2012, until the City has entered into a binding Habitat Conservation Plan agreement with and has received an incidental take permit from the National Marine Fisheries Service."

The idea of finding an "additional water supply" is what has those who oppose the concept of building a water desalination plant in the City of Santa Cruz interested in the expansion of UCSC's upper campus. For them, the growth of the university is seen as inextricably linked to the perception of a need to build a desal plant.

For those interested in the preservation of natural habitat, the issue of upper campus expansion involves three different possible impacts: a variety of sea life would be adversely effected by a water desalination plant; salmon and steelhead would be adversely effected in local streams by any increase in water demand; and the loss of forest and open space in the north campus area would effect the habitat of animals such as mountain lions.

UCSC undergrads, graduate students, faculty members, and residents of Santa Cruz, spoke to a variety of additional reasons as to why LAFCO should act to protect the UCSC upper campus from development and limit the university's water supply, insisting LAFCO follow their official responsibilities of, "discouraging urban sprawl, preserving open-space, and encouraging the orderly formation and development of local agencies based upon local conditions and circumstances."

Some comments made by the public focused on how the leadership of the institutions key in the decision making process concerning the expansion of the upper campus do not adequately represent the public, and especially minorities. Council member and former mayor Ryan Coonerty spoke on behalf of the city of Santa Cruz, standing before his father Neal Coonerty, chair of LAFCO, and a county supervisor and former mayor of Santa Cruz himself. That all seven LAFCO commissioners are white males did not go without audible comments by community members, one of whom noted in her comments that the university has used minority enrollment figures at UCSC to justify the expansion, regardless of the fact that UCSC has one of the lowest graduation rates in the UC system. Using minority enrollment as the justification for expansion for her is, "illogical, irresponsible, environmentally and financially risky, and dishonest," and she concluded that, "this proposal does not provide environmental justice for the citizens of California."

Before the meeting, community members gathered in front of the court house. The organization "Teach the Forest" distributed t-shirts, and people circled up and said a few words before entering the meeting as a group. A short presentation to LAFCO commissioners was first made by Chancellor Blumenthal, which was followed by a presentation on behalf of the City of Santa Cruz by council member Ryan Coonerty. Gary Patton spoke on behalf of the local organization the Community Water Coalition, which has opposed the university's water application on a variety of legal grounds. Of the more than 50 community members who spoke, only two were in favor of expansion into the upper campus, one of them being William Tysseling, the Executive Director of the Santa Cruz Chamber of Commerce.

A protest was planned that would make its way up to the university's administration building if any decisions permitting the development of the upper campus were made, but in light of LAFCO's decision to delay its decision, community members gathered outside of the court house instead to discuss the events of the day.

The general sentiment of those who spoke before LAFCO was that no development whatsoever should be allowed in the upper campus, and that LAFCO should flatly attempt to prevent it by any means necessary.


For more information about the Santa Cruz Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO), see:
http://santacruzlafco.org/


Alex Darocy
http://alexdarocy.blogspot.com/
§
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
Copy the following to embed the movie into another web page:
download video:

lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012.flv (43.0MB)

UC Santa Cruz chancellor George Blumenthal enters the meeting, followed by community members in support of the protection of the upper campus, who fill up the room.
§Public Comments
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
Listen now:
Embed code:
Download audio:
Download audio
lafco-public-comments-santa-cruz-june-6-2012.mp3 125.5MB

Complete audio of the public comment period.
§
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
Listen now:
Embed code:
Download audio:
Download audio
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012.mp3 59.7MB

After a break, commissioners Leopold and Lane each return with amendments to the March 7 conditions, and discuss how to proceed.
§Save Upper Campus
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
save-upper-campus-ucsc-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-5.jpg
save-upper-campus-ucsc-la...

Save Upper Campus
240 Acres of Redwood Forest is Higher Education
§Save UCSC's Ecology! Stop the LRDP!
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-6.jpg
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2...

§Gary Patton
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
garry-patton-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-7.jpg
garry-patton-lafco-santa-...

§
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
lafco-santa-cruzjune-6-2012-8.jpg
lafco-santa-cruzjune-6-20...

§
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
save-upper-campus-lafco-santa-cruzjune-6-2012-9.jpg
save-upper-campus-lafco-s...

§John Leopold, Roger Anderson, Daniel Dodge
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
john-leopold-roger-anderson-daniel-dodge-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-10.jpg
john-leopold-roger-anders...

Santa Cruz LAFCO commissioners (from l to r): John Leopold, Roger Anderson, and Daniel Dodge.
§Jim Anderson, James Rapoza, Don Lane
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
jim-anderson-james-rapoza-don-lane-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-11.jpg
jim-anderson-james-rapoza...

Santa Cruz LAFCO commissioners (from l to r): Jim Anderson, James Rapoza, and Don Lane.
§Daniel Dodge, Neal Coonerty, Jim Anderson
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
daniel-dodge-neal-coonerty-jim-anderson-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-12.jpg
daniel-dodge-neal-coonert...

Santa Cruz LAFCO commissioners (from l to r): Daniel Dodge, Neal Coonerty, and Jim Anderson.
§George Blumenthal and Entourage
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
george-blumenthal-dean-fitch-jim-burns-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-13.jpg
george-blumenthal-dean-fi...

UC Santa Cruz Chancellor George Blumenthal, and his entourage, including Director of Public Information, Jim Burns, and Dean Fitch (in maroon) who is in charge of physical environment planning at UCSC, and was the manager of the 2005 LRDP planning process..
§
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
george-blumenthal-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-14.jpg
george-blumenthal-lafco-s...

§George Blumenthal
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
george-blumenthal-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-15.jpg
george-blumenthal-lafco-s...

§City Officials
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
barisone-connerty-bernal-kocher-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-16.jpg
barisone-connerty-bernal-...

Representatives from the City of Santa Cruz, City Attorney John Barisone, Council Member Ryan Coonerty, City Manager Martin Bernal, and Water Department Director Bill Kocher. Community members can be seen in the background sitting on the floor in the center aisle of the meeting room.
§Ryan Coonerty
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
ryan-coonerty-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-17.jpg
ryan-coonerty-lafco-santa...

§George Blumenthal, Dean Fitch
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
george-blumenthal-dean-fitch-lafco-uc-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-18.jpg
george-blumenthal-dean-fi...

George Blumenthal (foreground), Dean Fitch (background)
§Gary Patton
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
garry-patton-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-19.jpg
garry-patton-lafco-santa-...

§
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:17 PM
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-20.jpg
lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2...

Community members line up to speak during the open comment period.
§Redwood Branches
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:18 PM
redwoods-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-21.jpg
redwoods-lafco-santa-cruz...

Redwood Branches
§Teach The Forest
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:19 PM
teach-the-forest-ucsc-lafco-santa-cruz-june-6-2012-22.jpg
teach-the-forest-ucsc-laf...

Teach the Forest
§Public Comment
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:20 PM
lafco-june-6-2012-23.jpg
lafco-june-6-2012-23.jpg

Public Comment
§Public Comment
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:21 PM
lafco-june-6-2012-24.jpg
lafco-june-6-2012-24.jpg

Public Comment
§Public Comment
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:22 PM
lafco-june-6-2012-25.jpg
lafco-june-6-2012-25.jpg

Public Comment
§Public Comment
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:23 PM
lafco-june-6-2012-26.jpg
lafco-june-6-2012-26.jpg

Public Comment
§Public Comment
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:24 PM
lafco-june-6-2012-27.jpg
lafco-june-6-2012-27.jpg

Public Comment
§William Tysseling
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:25 PM
lafco-june-6-2012-28.jpg
lafco-june-6-2012-28.jpg

William Tysseling, the Executive Director of the Santa Cruz Chamber of Commerce.
§March 7th "Substitute Motion"
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:29 PM

March 7th Conditions - Substitute Motion

from:

http://santacruzlafco.org/pages/agenda/20120307materials/Substitute%20Motion%203-7-12.pdf
§June 6th - Leopold Draft
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:31 PM

Leopold Draft

from:

http://santacruzlafco.org/pages/agenda/20120606materials/June%206%202012%20for%20web/Leopold%20Draft%20June%206%202012.pdf
§June 6th - Lane Draft
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:33 PM

June 6th - Lane Draft

from:
http://santacruzlafco.org/pages/agenda/20120606materials/June%206%202012%20for%20web/Lane%20Draft%20June%206%202012.pdf
§National Marine Fisheries Service Letter - February 10, 2012
by Alex Darocy Thursday Jun 21st, 2012 7:36 PM

National Marine Fisheries Service Letter - February 10, 2012

from:
http://santacruzlafco.org/pages/agenda/20120307materials/Feb%2010%202012%20NMFS%20letter%20to%20LAFCO.pdf