SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
About Contact Subscribe Calendar Publish Print Donate

U.S. | Education & Student Activism | Global Justice and Anti-Capitalism | Labor & Workers

Chicago Teachers Union Sellout
by Stephen Lendmanl
Sunday Sep 16th, 2012 12:39 AM
education
Chicago Teachers Union Sellout

by Stephen Lendman

It's in the air. You can smell and taste it. It's not pleasant. Union bosses and city officials struck a deal. A previous article headlined Capitulation in Chicago?

Final details aren't known, but bet on it. It's baked in the cake. By the time this article circulates, it may be official. It practically is now.

Unions in Chicago and across America ill represented rank-and-file members for decades. Corporate and government negotiators know it. Beating labor means staying hardline and waiting them out. They'll cave like they always do.

Months of discussions produced stalemate. On September 10, teachers walked out. Board of Education (BoE) and Chicago Public Schools (CPS) officials spurned them on core issues. Resolving them in five days reveals sellout.

Saving public education is key. It's a fundamental right. It's on the chopping block for elimination. Commodifying it as another business profit center is planned.

Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel is hellbent on doing it. Doing so means placing bottom line priorities over teaching and learning.

Schools aren't businesses. Education isn't a product. It's a bedrock societal obligation. Keeping it out of profiteer hands is essential. Teachers are on their own to save it. It's also up to them to preserve their jobs with decent pay and benefits, as well as futures for Chicago kids.

Union bosses think sacrificing what's too important to lose doesn't matter as long as their welfare is secure. There's still a chance to beat them. Grassroots efforts alone can do it. Final contract terms aren't approved.

Chicago Teachers Union (CTU) president Karen Lewis wants House of Delegates approval fast. They're the CTU's governing body. Members elect them. They number over 700. Every city school is represented.

All union members have final say. Tallying their votes will take days. Once strike action ends and classes resume, it'll be too late to say no deal. Saying it now crucial. Later won't matter. Perhaps 24 hours means the difference between victory and defeat.

On September 15, the Chicago Tribune headlined "Tentative deal reached with striking Chicago teachers," saying:

Contract terms are agreed on. A tentative deal was struck. A City Hall source said school officials and union bosses reached a "framework with all points resolved."

Lewis revealed her duplicity. She's "very comfortable" with terms. "We think it's a framework that will get us to an agreement." She didn't explain what's in it, and most important what's not.

"Creative thinking" was involved, she claimed. "They thought about some stuff, and we thought about some stuff."

Education isn't "stuff." It's teaching, learning, and preparing kids effectively to move on for more of the same through graduation.

CTU attorney Robert Block said union officials will recommend the deal to members. He expects House of Delegates approval Sunday.

He and Lewis didn't explain why terms are withheld. CTU vice president Jesse Sharkey spilled the beans, saying:

"If our membership looks at a detailed summary of an entire contract and rejects it, then we are still on strike."

In other words, they'll reveal sellout. A bad deal no one should approve will be scuttled. Union bosses want sugar-coating cover. They want defeat looking like victory. Hopefully rank and file members will act in time to stop them.

School board president David Vitale was upbeat. "The heavy lifting is over," he said. "The general framework is in place. My message (to parents) is they should be prepared to have their kids in school on Monday."

His comments and body language alone show Emanuel got what he wanted. It's at the expense of teachers, parents, and kids. He confirmed it saying the deal is "an honest and principled compromise that is about who we all work for: our students."

He doesn't give a damn about students, teachers, and all ordinary Chicagoans. He represents money and power interests. What benefits them harms others.

"It's a deal," headlined a Tribune editorial, saying:

Parents "no doubt cheered the news." Wait 'till they find out what they got and see their reaction. Wait 'till teachers and student learn they were sold out.

"Schools will open Monday," said the Tribune. "That's all most parents will care to know." Did Emanuel really get the "reform" he wanted, it asked? Will public education destruction continue unabated? Will marketplace rules replace it?

Can teachers be fired or laid off freely? Will seniority rights no longer matter? Will principals have diktat authority? Will teaching to the test still be policy? Will teacher evaluations depend on prioritizing it over learning and good education? It looks certain on all counts and more.

The Tribune seems almost sanguine about dozens of planned school closures, consolidations, and parents left scrambling over where to send their kids when nearby schools close.

A Chicago Sun Times editorial tried having it both ways. Headlined "Stand up to teachers, but don't demonize them," it said:

"Allow us today to come to the defense of the striking Chicago teachers in a way that will fully please almost nobody, certainly not the teachers."

Teachers aren't greedy, it said. They're not striking for themselves alone. Sure they want better pay, good benefits, and job security. "Who doesn't? No apologies necessary."

They also want justifiable school improvements "so they can do their jobs right….These are not faked-up issues." They're real. Kids can't learn properly in classrooms too cold or hot to learn.

Up-to-date textbooks are essential. So are manageable class sizes. Striking teachers aren't "aliens dropped among us, selfish and dumb and duped by their union bosses. They're hardworking Chicagoans…" They take great pride in their work.

They want and deserve "schools they can believe in and be proud of, schools where they can do their job right. They want it for themselves and for their students."

Now the part they won't like. "They have to call of this strike." It's baked in the cake, of course. Unless grassroots displeasure balks its sellout terms, classes will resume Monday.

"They've already gained" enough, said the Sun Times. "There are serious doubts as to whether the city can even afford" concessions made.

What's lost matters most. No matter. The "city must hold the line…"

"As we said, this is an editorial sure to please almost no one….we believe this strike is wrong."

Sun Times editorial writers don't care about what's most important. Nor do Tribune bosses. Neither mentioned public education, its importance, and how Emanuel plans destroying a societal bedrock.

Remember those teachers "who made us what we are today," said the Sun Times. At the same time, it forgot what's most important and why it matters.

A Final Comment

Jerry White is the Socialist Equality Party's presidential candidate. At a Saturday rally, he'll distribute a supportive statement. In part, it says:

"The truth is that the CTU and the AFT (American Federal of Teachers) are preparing a betrayal of the strike and the imposition of a sellout contract that will have devastating consequences for teachers and the future of public education in Chicago and across the country."

CTU agreed on terms reportedly let school officials fire non-tenured teachers immediately. Others can be dismissed after a year. Teacher evaluations will depend on teaching to the test, standardized scores, and principles having diktat authority to decide if its done their way.

Dozens of schools will be closed. Poor and low income neighborhoods will lose theirs. Quasi-private charter schools will proliferate. They prioritize profits over teaching and learning.

"As the presidential candidate of the Socialist Equality Party, I urge teachers to reject this sellout. The teachers have remained solid since the strike began and won powerful support from parents, students and workers throughout the city and across the country."

"Now is the time to broaden the struggle and stand fast against the phony 'reform' agenda of Emanuel, Education Secretary Arne Duncan, Obama, and the entire political establishment."

"The assault on teachers and public education can be defeated only on the basis of a recognition that the struggle against it is a political struggle against both parties of big business and the financial-corporate elite whose interests they serve."

"This elite includes the speculators and parasites looking to cash in on the carve-up of public education and proliferation of privately run schools."

"I urge teachers to broaden their strike and fight to mobilize all school workers, public employees, auto workers, young people and unemployed workers behind them and in opposition to the united front of Democrats and Republicans, the media and big business. The union leadership has no intention of waging such a fight."

"Teachers should organize rank-and-file committees to take control of the conduct of the struggle and oversee the contract negotiations."

Corrupt politicians and corporate profiteers say "How dare teachers strike!" Democrats and Republicans are like-minded. Media scoundrels support them. Teachers are treated like "serfs revolting against their lords."

Parents and kids are treated like they don't matter. Public education isn't mentioned nor its importance. Teachers know what works in classrooms and what doesn't. Principles are hired to enforce federal, state, and City Hall diktats.

What's best for super-rich elites harms most others. Good schools, teaching and learning are incompatible with profit making. Democratic values and social rights can't survive under mandated unequal conditions.

Chicago teachers have a chance to change things. It's their jobs, their schools, and their choice. The futures for thousands of Chicago kids depend on them. They have hours left to do the right thing.

Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at lendmanstephen [at] sbcglobal.net.

His new book is titled "How Wall Street Fleeces America: Privatized Banking, Government Collusion and Class War"

http://www.claritypress.com/Lendman.html

Visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com and listen to cutting-edge discussions with distinguished guests on the Progressive Radio News Hour on the Progressive Radio Network Thursdays at 10AM US Central time and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs are archived for easy listening.

http://www.progressiveradionetwork.com/the-progressive-news-hour

Comments  (Hide Comments)

by J Burger
Sunday Sep 16th, 2012 1:13 PM
I read Stephen Lendmanl piece today. The author appears to posit that because the CTU leadership is not declaring and building a general strike, they are sell outs. This article is filled with fantasy, and does not handle the sum total of all the moving parts. This has been brewing for some time, and the CTU has handled it well.

I live in Chicago. I am a trade unionist (not with the teachers). I have seen this group of teachers unite the union like no other in 25 years. They decided to organize the members and involve them in the struggle around the contract. In that context, the members also helped broaden beyond the system of labor control (the constrictive legal environment) to include the conditions of schools and the context in which kids live and attend schools.

This union has stood up to a bully of a mayor. The members have built struggle in a phenomenal way. I think that it is idealistic to take settlement comments out of context and to cast this leadership group in the same mold as all others. It appears from the article that Mr. Lendlman has no experience in leading working class struggles. The written from afar and quoting of mainstream media misses the real story.

I support the CTU teachers, their leaders and applaud them for a job done already! I would call on the readers of this blog to do the same.
by Solidarity
Wednesday Sep 19th, 2012 8:23 AM
As the writer states, the Chicago Teachers Union is to be commended for striking at all in this backward country where labor calls itself middle class when the 80% of us who sell our labor for less than $77,000 a year are workingclass, and where labor votes for the anti-labor Democrats, and sometimes the equally anti-labor Republicans. What is needed is a general strike to end the profit motive and American labor has not reached that point yet. Hopefully, they will do so very soon as we do not live forever and life cannot continue in a society where 50% of the people live in poverty, 50% of Americans cannot come up with $2,000 within 30 days to pay for an emergency need and 80% of Americans live from paycheck to paycheck.

Most of Steve Lendman's writings are good but sometimes he shows his class origins and this is one of those times. His biography is as follows:
From: http://www.blogger.com/profile/15760852410047128197

About me

Introduction

Born in 1934 in Boston, MA. Raised in a modest middle income family. Attended public schools. Received a Harvard BA in 1956 and a Wharton MBA in 1960. After six years as a marketing research analyst, became part of a new small family business in 1967. Remaining there until retiring in 1999. Have since devoted my time to progressive causes, extensive reading, and since summer 2005 writing on vital world and national topics. They include war and peace, American imperialism, corporate dominance, political persecutions, and a range of other social, economic and political issues. In early 2007, began regular radio hosting. Now host The Progressive Radio News Hour on The Progressive Radio Network. Full information above.