SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
Indybay About Contact Newsletter Calendar Publish Community

Santa Cruz Indymedia | Government & Elections | Health, Housing, and Public Services | Police State and Prisons | Front Page

Mon Dec 20 2010 Court Finds Free-Speech Issue in Nazi Salute
9th Circuit Mandates New Trial in Free Speech "Nazi Salute" Lawsuit Against City Tim Hull, Courthouse News writes: The 9th Circuit on Wednesday [Dec. 15] revived the First Amendment claim of a man who was kicked out of a Santa Cruz City Council meeting for giving a Nazi salute. Chief Judge Alex Kozinski wrote that a councilman's ensuing "hissy fit" may have disrupted the meeting more than the silent gesture.

Robert Norse was ejected from a Santa Cruz City Council meeting and arrested in 2002 for giving the board a "silent Nazi salute."

A full panel of the Pasadena-based federal appeals court ruled that the district court had failed to give Norse adequate notice and an opportunity to present evidence before dismissing his complaint in 2004.

In a separate, concurring opinion, joined by Judge Stephen Reinhardt, Kozinski said the incident would not have caused any disturbance if Councilman Tim Fitzmaurice had not thrown "a hissy fit."

"Councilman Fitzmaurice clearly wants Norse expelled because the 'Nazi salute' is 'against the dignity of this body and the decorum of this body' and not because of any disruption," Kozinski wrote. "But, unlike der Führer, government officials in America occasionally must tolerate offensive or irritating speech."

imc_pdf.gifimc_video.gifRead more | previous coverage: Jun 28th, 2010 | Mar 12th, 2010 | Nov 21st, 2009 | Apr 12th, 2007 | Dec 3rd, 2004

02/27/15 Five People Killed by Multiple Law Enforcement Agencies in Oakland in the Last 13 Months   Police State and Prisons | Racial Justice
02/25/15 Results of Santa Cruz Police Investigation Kept Secret   Police State and Prisons | Santa Cruz Indymedia
02/25/15 Dream Inn Workers Refuse to Accept Three-Year Wage Freeze   Labor & Workers | Santa Cruz Indymedia
02/25/15 Interview with Linda Grant on the Struggle at Triangle Park in Oakland   Health, Housing, and Public Services
02/24/15 Santa Cruz Community Supporters Say Case Against Alix Tichelman is a 'Witch Hunt'   Womyn | Santa Cruz Indymedia
02/24/15 Civil Disobedience Action Pushes for Answers in Police Killing of Yuvette Henderson   Police State and Prisons
02/19/15 Council Members Say BearCat Issue May Return to Agenda in March   Police State and Prisons | Santa Cruz Indymedia
02/18/15 Resolutions Call on University of California to Invest in Socially Responsible Companies   Education & Student Activism | Palestine
02/18/15 Family and Friends Remember 23-Year-Old Killed by San Jose Police   Police State and Prisons | South Bay
02/17/15 EPA Urged to Shut Down Oil Industry Wastewater Wells Threatening California Aquifers   Health, Housing, and Public Services | California
02/17/15 CSUMB Police Officer to be Fired for Not Using Taser Against Student   Police State and Prisons | Santa Cruz Indymedia