SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
About Contact Subscribe Calendar Publish Print Donate

Palestine | Arts + Action | Front Page

Mon Sep 22 2008 (Updated 09/24/08) "Z32", Movie About an Israeli Soldier Who Committed a War Crime, Is Showing in Israel
Z32, a Musical Documentary is Restricted by The Israeli Censure. “Z32” follows the testimony of a soldier (Roni) who with his unit carried out an order to avenge the death of six Israeli soldiers by ambushing and killing two Palestinian policemen. During the movie the soldier never shows his face, and his identity remains hidden behind a digital mask. The soldier is shown confessing to his friends and his girlfriend about participating in the war crime, and his quest for forgiveness. At one point in the movie the couple discusses whether someone can be forgiven for an act that any court would describe as a murder.

In Israel the phrase “shoot and then cry” (yorim vebochim) is a very common term used to criticize the behavior of the occupying soldiers who should have known better than to carry out war crimes. Many Israeli movies feature Israeli soldiers asking for forgiveness and redemption for crimes that they performed in the occupied territories. Z32, however, does not allow the viewers to be carried away with Roni’s search for forgiveness, and instead deals with the question of how the listener should act. With commentary in the form of songs, the viewer is forced to not passively forgive Roni for killing two innocent people. The viewer is confronted with dilemmas such as the responsibility to expose the soldier’s identity so he can face trial. Or that that by hiding the identity of the soldier and allowing him to redeem himself through confession, the viewer (and the director) become accomplices in defending and aiding a war criminal.

The movie was restricted at first to people over the age of 16, and after Avi Mugraby, the director of the movie appealed, the restriction was reduced to people over the age of 14. Although it doesn't contain sex scenes or violence, the Censor for Movies and Theater justified its decision, saying that “the subject of the film, which describes in different ways the involvement of IDF soldiers in the murder of two Palestinian policemen in order to avenge the killing of Jews, and the apparent abstruseness in its various parts…requires the viewer to watch the film in a rational manner and justifies its classification as suitable for viewers over the age of 14.” In an article posted to Indymedia Israel, Avi Mogarbi opposed the decision saying that “the Censor does not have the right to restrict movies because they are challenging, the Censor is using its power to restrict a movie that is politically sensitive.”

The name Z32 is taken from the testimony number on the Breaking The Silence website. For many years, Breaking the Silence has been collecting testimonies from soldiers who have committed atrocities and war crimes as part of their service in the Israeli Defense Force. Read More

Breaking The Silence | Z32-Restricted by Censor (Hebrew), Indymedia Israel | 15 Palestinians killed as Israel strikes back, The Independent

11/22/09 Minnesota Activists Jailed for Grand Jury Contempt and AETA Charge   Police State and Prisons | Animal Liberation
11/21/09 Ends Peacefully - No Arrests   Education & Student Activism | Central Valley | California
11/20/09 California Students Protest and Occupy as UC Regents Approve 32% Fee Hike   Education & Student Activism
11/19/09 Occupations at UC Santa Cruz Expands to Kerr Hall   Education & Student Activism | Santa Cruz Indymedia
11/19/09 Gay Puerto Rican Teen Murdered, Suspect to Use “Homosexual Panic” Defense   Global Justice and Anti-Capitalism | LGBTI / Queer | Womyn | Americas
11/18/09 UC Students Protest As UC Regents Raise Undergraduate Fees 32%   Education & Student Activism | Santa Cruz Indymedia
11/17/09 City of Santa Cruz May Ban New Medical Marijuana Clubs on November 19th   Health, Housing, and Public Services | Santa Cruz Indymedia
11/15/09 Building Solidarity Through Hip Hop at the Brown Berets Bike Shack in Watsonville   Arts + Action | Santa Cruz Indymedia
11/15/09 Hoods Unite and Bang for Freedom in the Mission District   Police State and Prisons | Racial Justice
11/14/09 UCSC Students Study-in to Protest Reduced Library Hours   Education & Student Activism | Santa Cruz Indymedia
11/13/09 23 CIA Agents Sentenced to 8-5 years for Kidnapping and Torture   Police State and Prisons | International