Publish to Newswire
Add an EventFrom the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Support That Marine!
Screw the treasonous Left!
GET RID OF THE JOURNALISTS & GIVE THE F--KIN' MARINE A MEDAL
-- War Is Not Pretty!
by Yale Kramer
No sooner than I had heard the story on the six o'clock news it was on the Internet.
The story boils down to something like this. Fifteen insurgents had been using a Mosque as a fortress from which to kill marines. The marines killed ten of their enemy and apparently wounded another five. The following day another group of marines came upon the five wounded insurgents and one of the marines thought that one of the insurgents was faking being dead and shot him dead to make sure. Unfortunately, there was an embedded camera crew from NBC which filmed the event. The reporter, Kevin Sites, reported the story as though the marine were a war criminal, and the Marine Command relieved the marine from duty in order to investigate the case. And I'm sure we'll continue to hear a lot more about it from the NY Times.
Now, let's cut to the chase, and cut out the hypocrisy. If there had not been an embedded journalist in that action, we would not be reading or hearing about the matter. It is only because of the delicate feelings of correspondent Kevin Sites that the event has been elevated to a moral crisis--another example of entertainment-media-morality-as fraudulent and phony as most of what appears on the media.
The marine who shot the mujahedeen insurgent had been wounded in the face the day before and had finished a week of heroic fighting of the kind that is the most challenging in modern warfare. House to house fighting in a town that had been waiting and making preparations for the marines. The insurgents had prepared booby traps, tunnels, explosive devices of all sorts. They are not beneath using any deception, firing from behind innocent children, dressing as women or pretending to be legitimate policemen, booby-trapping bodies, pretending to be wounded and then killing our men when they approach to give aid. They don't care about dying as long as they take one of our men with them. Our men have rules of engagement, the insurgents do not.
Such conditions require split-second responses, hair trigger reactions, and a high degree of suspiciousness-paranoia is highly adaptive in such a situation, not only for oneself but for one's whole squad.
The marine was doing his job when he shot the insurgent, thinking that the man was faking death and about to spring a trap. The young marine should be given a medal instead of investigated. Everyman and marine in this kind of warfare believes that it is better to err on the side of killing the other guy if there is any doubt. Only those holier-than-us journalists would disagree.
Embedded reporting worked during the early phase of this war, but it doesn't in this phase. The beginning of the war, in which there was little or no hand-to-hand fighting at close quarters, was an opportunity for journalists to get to see warfare close up. It allowed the reporters to get some idea what our fighting men were up against-and, hopefully, so the Pentagon thought, the journalists would empathize with our soldiers. And this worked because the anxiety level among our men was high but not at its zenith. The kind of fighting in Fallujah raises anxiety to a much higher pitch because the actions are so much more risky, ambiguous, and fast. Our fighters, in this situation, are bound to make a greater number of mistakes-some fatal for themselves or the enemy. Keeping journalists around in this situation is only adding to the burdens of our fighting men if they also have to give consideration to the moral sensibilities of journalists. Get rid of them!
Yale Kramer is the co-publisher of the much-praised conservative Web site, Horsefeathers!.
-- War Is Not Pretty!
by Yale Kramer
No sooner than I had heard the story on the six o'clock news it was on the Internet.
The story boils down to something like this. Fifteen insurgents had been using a Mosque as a fortress from which to kill marines. The marines killed ten of their enemy and apparently wounded another five. The following day another group of marines came upon the five wounded insurgents and one of the marines thought that one of the insurgents was faking being dead and shot him dead to make sure. Unfortunately, there was an embedded camera crew from NBC which filmed the event. The reporter, Kevin Sites, reported the story as though the marine were a war criminal, and the Marine Command relieved the marine from duty in order to investigate the case. And I'm sure we'll continue to hear a lot more about it from the NY Times.
Now, let's cut to the chase, and cut out the hypocrisy. If there had not been an embedded journalist in that action, we would not be reading or hearing about the matter. It is only because of the delicate feelings of correspondent Kevin Sites that the event has been elevated to a moral crisis--another example of entertainment-media-morality-as fraudulent and phony as most of what appears on the media.
The marine who shot the mujahedeen insurgent had been wounded in the face the day before and had finished a week of heroic fighting of the kind that is the most challenging in modern warfare. House to house fighting in a town that had been waiting and making preparations for the marines. The insurgents had prepared booby traps, tunnels, explosive devices of all sorts. They are not beneath using any deception, firing from behind innocent children, dressing as women or pretending to be legitimate policemen, booby-trapping bodies, pretending to be wounded and then killing our men when they approach to give aid. They don't care about dying as long as they take one of our men with them. Our men have rules of engagement, the insurgents do not.
Such conditions require split-second responses, hair trigger reactions, and a high degree of suspiciousness-paranoia is highly adaptive in such a situation, not only for oneself but for one's whole squad.
The marine was doing his job when he shot the insurgent, thinking that the man was faking death and about to spring a trap. The young marine should be given a medal instead of investigated. Everyman and marine in this kind of warfare believes that it is better to err on the side of killing the other guy if there is any doubt. Only those holier-than-us journalists would disagree.
Embedded reporting worked during the early phase of this war, but it doesn't in this phase. The beginning of the war, in which there was little or no hand-to-hand fighting at close quarters, was an opportunity for journalists to get to see warfare close up. It allowed the reporters to get some idea what our fighting men were up against-and, hopefully, so the Pentagon thought, the journalists would empathize with our soldiers. And this worked because the anxiety level among our men was high but not at its zenith. The kind of fighting in Fallujah raises anxiety to a much higher pitch because the actions are so much more risky, ambiguous, and fast. Our fighters, in this situation, are bound to make a greater number of mistakes-some fatal for themselves or the enemy. Keeping journalists around in this situation is only adding to the burdens of our fighting men if they also have to give consideration to the moral sensibilities of journalists. Get rid of them!
Yale Kramer is the co-publisher of the much-praised conservative Web site, Horsefeathers!.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Donate
$230.00 donated
in the past month
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network
By: Jack Dalton
11/29/04 : "ICH" -- That the United States is a militarized imperial empire is beyond question at this point in time. The level of nationalism, xenophobia, and mindless hatred has divided this nation even worse, in some ways, than what I remember taking place during the civil rights and anti-war movements during the 1960’s. The “my country right or wrong” and “love it or leave it” hysteria today makes the past pale in comparison in many, many ways.
If ever a nation exemplified a “crisis in democracy” it is the United States under George W. Bush and the Bush Brigade, and it’s legions of cheerleaders throughout the nation. Everything has been turned upside down. Up is down; in is out; wrong is right; war is peace; occupation is liberation; fact is fiction; and now, freedom is the freedom to agree and do what you are told.
This nation under the Bush cabal has launched a brutal, senseless and bloody war. Not against a state, but against a tactic—terrorism. The result has been a self-fulfilling prophecy. Iraq is now what it never was, ground zero for fools and fanatics—ours as well as “theirs” whoever they may be.
Iraq had no suicide bombers until after this country invaded, occupied and then proceeded to sell off all of Iraq’s infrastructure, assets and resources to U.S. multinational corporations. It would appear that the people running this absurd and perverted “Twilight Zone” episode (Bush’s “war on terrorism”) have given no thought to “cause and effect” or “for every action there is an opposite reaction.”
Every warning given to BushCo that invading Iraq would result in urban, guerilla war, exactly what is being faced in Iraq now, were ignored and discounted by them. The cost of this has been paid by the over 100,000 Iraqi’s that have been killed and by the over 1200 U.S. personnel killed—and there is no end in sight for the death and destruction. The dynamic duo of Bush-Cheney, has done what Osama bin Ladin needed and that is to provide a recruiting tool for insurgents thru the radicalization of so many in the Muslim world. In that context, Bush has become a “uniter.”
This BushCo war of choice has convinced me that Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz and the rest of that pack of ideologues could care less about how many die or are maimed. Thousands have had their bodies torn apart; head and faces; legs missing; arms missing; burns that maim and cripple from the use of napalm bombs. What do we hear from the Bush camp? “We will win no matter what the cost.” What the final tally of dead and wounded will be is anyone’s guess considering all that have been contaminated by depleted uranium and the slow destruction it will cause in those exposed.
Then there are the wounds that no one sees; the wounds that haunt the mind day and night, the pain of which leads one to question if you still have a soul. These are the wounds that seem never to heal—wounds of the soul, the mind, the emotions—that stay ever present to varying degrees as you attempt to make sense of a world that, to you, no longer makes any sense.
These are the wounds that are born out of fear, guilt, and terror. No name death falling from the sky—that is terrorism--bombs, rockets, and mortars that fall unannounced, at any time, in any place that are capricious, indiscriminate and arbitrary when they kill and maim. I’ve seen men that have gone thru literal hand to hand combat that turned into shaking piles of sobbing flesh during sustained mortar attacks—abject helplessness.
Since this BushCo war of choice was launched there have been close to 30,000 of this nation’s people in uniform that have been medically evacuated from Iraq. Approximately 7,000 of them due to “physiological” reasons—try PTSD. It’s estimated by the Pentagon that one in six are showing significant PTSD problems. That’s what war does, that is the cost of war and the brutality that is war. Those of us that have seen the face of war know and understand this—you lose a part of your humanity, your “soul” when we participate in mass murder of our fellow human beings no matter what the reason.
I wonder what the toll on Iraqi’s will be in terms of PTSD as a result of all the bombs, rockets, mortars and artillery shells the U.S. has dropped and fired on every city and town in Iraq? Iraq is a nation (or was) of 26 million people with over 50% of them under the age of 18. Half of Iraq is children. We know the effects of PTSD on adults, we’ve seen it with those of our people in uniform that are still affected from the Vietnam war; If adults are affected that severely, what about Iraq’s children?
We’re talking about 12-13 million children that have been subjected to almost daily bombings for over ten years and are currently being bombed by an occupying Army. What will be the result of all this on them? I can only imagine, but I do know from my own experiences that it will not be anything nice. In all probabilities, the next generation of insurgents, freedom fighters, and radicalized fundamentalists are being born out of the madness that has become Iraq.
“We're the good guys. We are Americans. We are fighting a gentleman's war here -- because we don't behead people, we don't come down to the same level of the people we're combating;” so said a LT Col in charge of some of the Marines that recently attacked Fallujah. How absurd! There is no such thing as a “gentleman’s war” not by any stretch of the imagination. Where is the so-called “moral High-ground” when you drop a bomb on a house and blow up children. Where is the moral high-ground when a sniper puts a bullet in the head of a 6 year old? Where is the moral high-ground when a hospital is used as a base of combat operations while people, children bleed to death from their wounds because they can’t get medical treatment?
“Smart” bombs that keep going to the wrong address and this country pontificates about having the moral high-ground. That would be a joke if not so pathetic and heartbreaking.
Bush & Co. say that “they” through all of this killing in Iraq, are making us safer and promoting “freedom and democracy” in Iraq. At the rate people are being killed in Iraq, the only thing that nation will be free of is human life--with the kids of that country that are left alive having learned that “life is death, and death is life.” So much for the “moral high-ground,” and a “gentleman’s war” as articulated by this nation’s alleged leaders.
As for those wearing this nation’s uniform coming back from Iraq multi-symptomatic PTSD because of what they have seen and done in Iraq, they also will suffer as even now they are being written off as “anxiety disorder” not exacerbated by war. This government did the very same thing to those of us that fought in Vietnam—why are the people in this country allowing this to once again happen. Like I said, so much for the “moral” high-ground.
Jack Dalton is a disabled Vietnam veteran and independent writer that lives in Portland, Oregon. He welcomes all comments, good, bad and everything in-between. While not all can be answered all are read. His email address is jack_dalton [at] ommp.org His articles have been published by The Project for the Old American Century, Axis of Logic, Uncommon Thought Journal, Crisis Papers, On Line Journal, the Smirking Chimp, Op/Ed News, Democratic Underground, Information Clearing House, Double Standards as well as multiple print newspapers.
http://www.indybay.org/news/2004/08/1693167.php