
Solidarity nourishes
hope in Haiti's prisons
by Sasha Kramer
 |
 |
 |
| Haitian political prisoners Father Jean Juste,
Sò Anne and Jacques Mathalier send their love to Bay
View readers, some of their strongest supporters. Despite their
imprisonment for months and years, they keep encouraging each
other and organizing inside and outside the walls. Father Jean
Juste, who has just been diagnosed with leukemia - note his
swollen neck - and folksinger Sò Anne have both been
officially designated political prisoners by Amnesty International.
While they all continue to demand the return of President Aristide,
they urge solidarity behind the candidacy of former President
René Préval, who promises to release political
prisoners. "We have no doubt that President Préval
will win the election. We are sure that we will get out of here,"
says Jacques Mathalier. |
Amid headline news reports of electoral campaigning,
Haiti's political prisoners continue to languish behind bars. They
spend their days wondering if the election will bring their freedom,
wondering if their friends and family are safe. Without access to
information, without their freedom, they can do little more than
wonder and hold onto the hope that those on the outside have not
forgotten their plight.
Many of these prisoners have been illegally held for over 18 months,
living in crowded and unsanitary conditions, isolated from their
families and communities. Who are they? They are grassroots organizers,
former officials from the Lavalas government and family members
of community activists who have been forced into exile or hiding.
They are people who threaten the current unelected government
through their persistent calls for respect for the Haitian Constitution
and the restoration of democracy. Months of imprisonment have not
dampened the commitment of many of Haiti's political prisoners,
an incredible testament to the courage and resilience of the Haitian
people.
Most well known is Father Gérard Jean Juste, beloved priest and
advocate for the poor, who has been imprisoned for close to six
months. Father Jean Juste was arrested on July 21, 2005, after being
assaulted by a crowd at the funeral of kidnapped journalist Jacques
Roche.
He was initially brought to the police station by U.N. forces,
who turned him over to the police after telling him he was being
brought in for his own safety. That night Father Jean Juste was
placed behind bars under allegations that he was involved in the
journalist's death, despite the fact that he was at a demonstration
at the Brazilian consulate in Miami when the journalist was kidnapped.
Even after nearly six months in prison, Father Jean Juste retains
his spirit of optimism, fueled, he says, by his faith in God. Each
day he prays with the other prisoners. He says, "It is the love
and support of my friends on the outside that keeps me alive. I
am trying to spread that love everywhere, to share the hope that
you bring me with the other prisoners."
Though his spirit is strong, Father Jean Juste's physical health
is declining. After the beating at Roche's funeral, Father Jean
Juste became ill and his neck swelled. The swelling was initially
thought to be temporary and related to the beating, but it worsened,
and now he says that it is difficult to hear out of his left ear.
Several weeks ago, Father Jean Juste was diagnosed with chronic
lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) by Dr. Paul Farmer of Harvard, a friend
and physician who has been working in rural Haiti for decades. Though
CLL is highly treatable, it jeopardizes the immune system, leaving
the body susceptible to infection.
Given how quickly Father Jean Juste's condition has progressed
and the potential for infection in prison, doctors are urging the
unelected Haitian government and Ministry of Justice to release
Jean Juste for medical care outside of Haiti. These calls for Jean
Juste's release match the demands of 42 members of Congress, Amnesty
International, Human Rights Watch and thousands of solidarity activists,
religious leaders and concerned citizens around the world.
Father Jean Juste received over 700 letters just before Christmas
from people around the world concerned for his life. In a move that
signifies a response to public pressure, the U.S. Embassy is urging
Jean Juste to receive treatment in a hospital in Haiti, an option
considered unsafe by lawyers and inadvisable by medical professionals.
Undaunted, Father Jean Juste calls on activists around the world
to "keep up the pressure. The new year will bring freedom for all
the courageous prisoners unjustly accused."
Jacques Mathalier, a former Lavalas delegate from southern Haiti,
shares a cell with Father Jean Juste at the National Prison Annex
at Pacot. This is not the first time these men have found themselves
imprisoned under the same roof. Father Jean Juste also spent several
months in the National Penitentiary with Mathalier following his
arrest in October 2004, when he was dragged out of the church rectory
while feeding children from the neighborhood.
The National Penitentiary is a densely overcrowded prison in Port
au Prince. In March 2005 the prison had 902 prisoners, only one
of whom had been convicted of a crime. Father Jean Juste was released
in November 2004 following massive pressure from the international
community. Jacques Mathalier remained in the National Penitentiary
until his recent transfer to Pacot.
Mathalier was arrested in June 2005 in his hometown of Les Cayes
soon after the former Justice Minister for the unelected government,
Bernard Gousse, came to Les Cayes with people from the Group of
184, an organization led by the business community that directed
the opposition to Aristide. Gousse and the Group of 184 made a series
of unsubstantiated allegations about the Lavalas leadership in Les
Cayes being involved in violence, and several days later Mathalier
was arrested.
At the time of his arrest, the police produced a warrant charging
him with attempted assassination and house burning, but the authorities
refused to disclose who he had attempted to kill or which houses
he may have planned to burn. After several months in prison in Les
Cayes, he was transferred to Port au Prince, where the charges shifted
to murder and arson. The Justice Department has yet to provide the
name of the person who was killed or the house that was burned.
Meanwhile Jacques Mathalier has spent 18 months behind bars away
from his family and community, much of that time in the National
Penitentiary. On Feb. 19, 2005, there was a prison break at the
National Penitentiary, and hundreds of prisoners escaped. Mathalier
recalls that he was forced out of his cell at the time like many
other prisoners.
Unlike many of the other prisoners, Mathalier returned the next
day with his family. When offered a choice between escaping from
prison and living the life of a fugitive for crimes that he didn't
commit or returning to prison where he could fight for justice assured
of his own innocence, Mathalier chose the latter. He said, "I came
in with my head held high, and I was not going to leave with it
hanging down."
Described by friends as a man of integrity and dedication, Mathalier
holds onto hope that the situation will change, saying, "You see
I am optimistic. There is no other choice."
In the Pétionville Penitentiary across town, Annette Auguste,
known as Sò Anne, has spent 20 months in prison. On Tuesday, Amnesty
International officially declared Sò Anne a "political prisoner"
and launched a belated appeal case on her behalf.
Activists have been pressuring Amnesty to take on Sò Anne's case
since her illegal arrest on May 10, 2004, Mother's Day, when U.S.
Marines - who were briefly in Haiti following the Feb. 29, 2004,
coup d'état - entered her house at 1 a.m., using a grenade to break
down the door. No Haitian police were present during the arrest,
and no warrant was produced at the time.
During the arrest, all members of Sò Anne's family, including
several children, were cuffed and dark hoods placed over their heads.
Marines raided the house, breaking many of the family's personal
belongings and confiscating all family members' passports. The family's
two dogs were beheaded during the violent entry.
Other family members were released, but Sò Anne remains behind
bars, subject to ever shifting allegations against her, ranging
from racist to patently absurd. Marine spokesman David Lapan originally
alleged that Sò Anne had been collaborating with members of a local
mosque to attack U.S. troops. Allegations against her now oscillate
between the vague charge of inciting violence at a demonstration
on Dec. 5, 2003, to her having killed a baby with a mortar and pestle
then wiped the blood on President Aristide during a voodoo ceremony
in 2000.
Like Jean Juste and Mathalier, Sò Anne has not lost the fierce
spirit which made her such an effective community organizer before
her arrest. Prior to her imprisonment, she worked with women's groups
and community nutrition centers in Port au Prince. Now she works
with the other prisoners, sharing her food brought by friends and
teaching other women to read.
Sò Anne speaks out vehemently against the human rights abuses
perpetrated by the current government and against the role of the
United States, France and Canada in overthrowing Haiti's democracy.
She says that they are afraid to release her because "they know
I am a powerful organizer. They know I'm not afraid to speak out
against the injustice that is happening in Haiti."
The Pétionville Penitentiary is now a women's prison, where hundreds
of women are crammed into cells, sometimes up to 20 women per cell.
In August 2004 there were only 45 prisoners, now there are over
200. Most of these women are poor women from Bel Air, Cité Soleil,
Martissant and other poor neighborhoods in Port au Prince where
support for Aristide remains strongest.
Many of the women now imprisoned at Pétionville were swept up
in police raids of their neighborhoods. Some of them are activists;
others are family members of activists. These are the forgotten
political prisoners, the hundreds of women and men who find themselves
behind bars for their commitment to democracy.
These prisoners have not only been denied due process, they have
also been denied the right to participate in Haiti's elections,
either as candidates or voters. The fact that so many important
leaders remain in prison or exile is a stain which will tarnish
the upcoming elections if they are not released.
Their plight challenges international demands for "free and fair"
elections and should be a foremost consideration for governments
claiming to support democracy in Haiti. Unfortunately, the United
States, Canada and France, the three countries most heavily involved
in the destabilization and overthrow of Haiti's democratically elected
government in 2004, have remained silent on the issue of political
prisoners. These world powers are so focused on the appearance of
free and fair elections in Haiti that they are willing to overlook
substance to forward their own political agendas.
The high profile cases of Father Jean Juste, Jacques Mathalier
and Sò Anne illustrate a much wider pattern of injustice. All three
expressed hope that their cases will draw attention to the plague
of political repression that has swept Haiti since the overthrow
of the democratically elected government in February 2004. SF Bay
View readers help to feed that hope.
Dr. Sasha Kramer, sash@stanford.edu, is a freelance ecologist
and human rights observer who visits and reports from Haiti frequently.
|