SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
About Contact Subscribe Calendar Publish Print Donate

California | Central Valley | Environment & Forest Defense | Government & Elections

Starrh & Starrh Cotton Growers: $10 million in taxpayer subsidies behind the 'tears'
by Dan Bacher
Friday Apr 4th, 2014 10:19 AM
"What Larry Starrh did not explain is that Starrh businesses took over $10 million in subsidies for growing thirsty cotton in Kern County from 1995-2012," Restore the Delta noted. "West Side San Joaquin Valley growers help secure their water through political contributions."
stop_the_tunnels.jpg
stop_the_tunnels.jpg

Starrh & Starrh Cotton Growers: $10 million in taxpayer subsidies behind the 'tears'

by Dan Bacher

To understand what is really going on in California water politics, you have to "follow the money."

Restore the Delta, opponents of Governor Jerry Brown's Bay Delta Conservation Plan to build the salmon-killing peripheral tunnels, is doing just this in its series of reports entitled, "INTRODUCING THE TOP 1% WATER TAKERS: Water subsidies, cotton subsidies, and the corporate agribusiness elite 1%"

It turns out those are crying the loudest in the campaign by agribusiness interests to build the twin tunnels and to pump more Delta water south in the drought are corporate mega-farmers who receive millions in taxpayer subsidies.

Starrh & Starrh Cotton Growers, who received $10 million in taxpayer subsidies, exemplify this hypocrisy of the subsidized agribusiness.

"Corporate agribusiness tycoons take taxpayer-subsidized water exported from the Delta and receive taxpayer subsidies for cotton and other crops," according to Restore the Delta (RTD). "Is the cost, plus the harm to the Delta, worth the benefit? Exported water supports a business model that is bad for taxpayers, and antithetical to the hope of a sustainable economy and environment for the Delta and California."

On March 19, 2014, Larry Starrh, co-owner of Starrh Ranch in Shafter, gave "tearful testimony" regarding his need for farm water at the U.S. House Natural Resources Committee Field Hearing in Fresno, reported Restore the Delta.

"Shortages that were created and controlled by regulations that have been imposed and brandished like weapons," Starrh claimed. "Sadly, in the real world, water is about power, water is a weapon, water is a hostage."

While giving his testimony, Mr. Starrh talked about his third-generation farm, and how they had to remove 1000 acres of almonds from their 9000 acres of almonds this year due to reduced water deliveries during the drought.

Starrh was one of nine witnesses at a loud House Natural Resources Committee field hearing on California's water crisis convened in the Fresno City Council chambers. He echoed the thoughts of many in the audience about environmental regulations that curb farm water deliveries.

"What Larry Starrh did not explain is that Starrh businesses took over $10 million in subsidies for growing thirsty cotton in Kern County from 1995-2012," RTD noted. "West Side San Joaquin Valley growers help secure their water through political contributions."

RTD revealed that Starrh family members made over $50,000 in political contributions (2012 - 2014), including to many of the Central Valley Congressmen who heard Larry Starrh’s testimony on how the Starrhs need “their water.”

RTD said, "The Starrhs chose to plant 9000 acres of almonds with exported water on arid, poorly draining land in a state that experiences drought 40% of the time. Fred Starrh complains that they have paid money for water, and the fish paid nothing, forgetting how many millions of Chinook salmon, Sturgeon, Threadfin Shad, and Delta Smelt have been killed by excessive water exports from the Delta. The Starrhs had enough money to make significant political contributions over the last three years partly because they pay for project water that does not cover the cost of the destroyed fisheries."

Star is Director and Founding President of the San Joaquin Valley Quality Cotton Growers Association, the Vice Chairman of the Global Marketing Committee - Cotton Incorporated, a Director of Cotton Incorporated and a Treasurer of Belridge Water Storage District.

To watch Starrh's testimony, go to: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LqYBZqRf2Uw&feature=youtu.be

In other Delta news, Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla, Executive Director, Restore the Delta; Colin Bailey, Executive Director, Environmental Justice Coalition for Water; Bill Jennings, California Sportfishing Protection Alliance; and Osha Meserve, Local Agencies of the North Delta, will provide a teleconference update on harm from Peripheral Tunnels proposed under Governor Jerry Brown's Bay Delta Conservation Plan on Monday, April 7 at 11 am.

They will detail in the teleconference on April 7 "the permanent, significant and unavoidable negative impacts, including the forced relocation of up to 1,000 Contra Costa County residents." RTD also criticizes Sen. Dianne Feinstein’s “reckless” bill to ignore long-term good to pump water for mega-growers in drought.

"The Brown Administration admits the tunnels would have '52 Significant and Unavoidable Adverse Impacts' on the Delta region, including permanently degraded groundwater quality, long-term reduction of navigation opportunities, and exposure to air quality in Byron bad enough to require people to move in order to avoid an increased cancer risk," said RTD Executive Director Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla.

Please contact Steve [at] hopcraft.com for dial in information; space is limited, with preference given to news media.

Comments  (Hide Comments)

by Wes Rolley
( wrolley [at] charter.net ) Friday Apr 4th, 2014 1:00 PM
While I applaud Dan for posting this,there are several facts that he did not add to the story and which make the political implications even more insidious. Starrh and Starrh have struck a deal to buy over 3,700 acre feet of water from the Buena Vista Water Storage District. They share part of the Buena Vista auction with Paramount Farms, whose owners Stewart and Linda Resnick are closely associated with Sen. Diane Feinstein. That was reported in the Bakersfield Californian on 2/28/2014.

In addition Larry Starrh is on the Board of Directors of the Belridge Water Storage District that actively resells water to Aera Energy LLC for use in fracking of W. Kern / Ventura County wells. Did I mention that the Belridge Board President is William Phillimore, Ex. VP of the same Paramount Farms that shared the proceeds of the Buena Vista water auction. It is a cozy little group, isn't it.