SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
Indybay About Contact Newsletter Calendar Publish Community

International | Santa Cruz Indymedia | Anti-War | Global Justice and Anti-Capitalism | Government & Elections

Belarus: President Lukashenko Vows to Prevent a Coup Similar to Ukraine
by Steven Argue
Wednesday Mar 5th, 2014 11:55 AM
[Photo: May 2, 2012: Belarusian soldiers rehearsing for the Victory Day parade in central Minsk, Belarus. This is a celebration of the USSR's victory over Nazi Germany. 2.2 million Belarusians were murdered by the Nazi occupiers, including most of Belarus's Jews. Today, among the "democratic" reforms of the new neo-Nazi infested government of Ukraine is the legalization of the destruction of WW II memorials celebrating the heroes of WW II. Unlike U.S. allies in Kiev, the Belarusian deformed workers state continues to celebrate the USSR's victory over Nazi Germany. (Photo Credit: Vasily Fedosenko/Reuters)]

Belarus: President Lukashenko Vows to Prevent a Coup Similar to Ukraine

On February 22, 2014, a far right movement overthrew the elected government of Ukraine and seized power in Kiev. They did this with major U.S. and European Union sponsorship. Since taking power that movement has abolished the language rights of Hungarian, Romanian, Tatar, and Russian speaking minorities, banned political parties, announced their intention to ban abortion, given neo-Nazis important positions in the new government, and announced their intention to carry out extreme austerity as demanded by the IMF as a condition for membership in the European Union

In the wake of the U.S. engineered coup in Ukraine, Belorussian President Alexander Lukashenko reflected on the tragedy saying:

"Our military will carry out duty and tasks to maintain peace and stability in the country. We should not lose vigilance here. We should learn from other people's mistakes and prevent even the slightest manifestations of instability in our country."

Unlike Ukraine, Belarus is a deformed workers state that continues to maintain a planned socialist economy. With the capitalist counterrevolution in the USSR, Ukraine did the same as Russia in imposing a devastating capitalist economy that caused the standard of living of the working class to decline dramatically by every measurable standard, including life expectancy. In Ukraine with the capitalist counterrevolution wages were cut and unemployment went from zero to 41%.

In socialist Belarus most of the economy remains in public hands.

Despite economic problems since the end of the Soviet Union, unemployment remains officially under 1%, at 0.6%. As in the United States, real unemployment is far higher than official figures, but is still lower than in Belorussia’s capitalist neighbors. In 2009 an official census found 6.1% of the population identify themselves as unemployed, so this is a far more realistic figure. That is still far better than capitalist Ukraine.

In Belarus education remains a well funded state priority which is free at all levels including higher education.
Belarusian healthcare is also free and state owned with infant mortality lower than the United States’ 6 per thousand live births, at 3.9 per thousand live births in Ukraine instead.

So far, Belarus has avoided privatization. Unfortunately, President Lukashenko laid out plans for privatization in his May 8, 2012 state of the union address. Fortunately, though, he isn’t allowing the wholesale plundering of the economy as has happened in the other republics of the former USSR that have destroyed their socialist economies. In fact, as he points out, he requires the permission from the workers collective involved for privatization to proceed:

“In order to privatize an enterprise, a prospective buyer should go not to the president but to the enterprise, and it is the work collective that has to decide whether or not privatization will take place. Then the deal must be approved by local authorities, then departmental officials and then by the government which only after considering all pros and cons can submit it to the president.”

Of course then, workers are likely to decide against turning their enterprises over to capitalist exploiters.

The breakup of the Soviet Union has also hurt the economy of Belarus. This has not hurt Belarus as badly as the neighboring republics that restored capitalism. Yet, the lack of local socialist trading partners and the lack of a wider planned socialist economy caused an economic crisis after the breakup of the USSR that has continued. In addition, the imposition of imperialist economic sanctions by the US and EU has compounded the problem. This has put Belarus in a position of looking for help from the IMF, Russia, and China.

Belarus has tried to turn to the IMF for help, but the IMF has demanded privatization in return. In response, President Lukashinko said that Belarus rejects the capitalist shock therapy imposed on their neighbors in the 1990’s and further stressed:

"Our economic potential and current conditions won't let reckless experiments, which will negatively affect the welfare of the population. The policy of our state has always been serving the people, and no one may deviate from this principle."

In contrast, the imperialist backed coup government in Ukraine is offering no such protections. While capitalism has already devastated Ukraine, the U.S. engineered coup in Ukraine now promises even worse as the new government in Ukraine seeks to impose increased austerity on the working class, including a 40% increase in the price of heating fuel (a change that will kill people in the cold of winter).

Russia and China have provided credit for Belarus without the imperialist meddling in Belarus’s economy as is demanded by the IMF.

It is this lack of privatization that has put President Lukashenko in the crosshairs of U.S. imperialism. In the 2006 elections, when the heavily western backed candidate, Alexander Milinkevich, won only 6% of the vote against President Lukashenko’s 83%, the European Union and the United States instituted economic sanctions and a travel ban against Belarus. Any time the imperialist backed candidates lose, anywhere in the world, the imperialists declare the government undemocratic. Of course the problems the imperialists have with President Lukashenko is not the lack of democracy, the U.S. supports the worst dictators in the world from Saudi Arabia to Egypt. The real cause of U.S. imperialist problems with Belarus is Belorussia’s planned socialist economy and a lack of privatization to open the economy up to capitalist exploitation.

In 2011, Obama deepened the economic sanctions against Belarus for the government’s crackdown on imperialist backed dissidents. Even if what Obama was backing was a just cause, economic sanctions only hurt the people and are a terrible form of collective punishment.

While Leninist-Trotskyists oppose economic sanctions and defend the socialist economy of Belarus from imperialist attacks and internal capitalist counterrevolution, we see big problems with President Lukashenko. While measures are needed to suppress imperialist influence and internal capitalist counterrevolution, Lukashinko also has high motivation to silence criticism of his own corruption. While the legalized corruption of President Lukashenko’s presidency is far lower than that which exists under capitalist systems, with capitalists in places like the United States raking in billions from the exploitation of workers and the environment and buying governments, President Lukashenko’s privileges are still astounding. Among Lukashenko’s privileges is his own private jet. His purchase of that $125-160 million jet caused his popularity to drop from 53% approval to 20% approval in 2011.

Like Cuba, North Korea, Vietnam, China, and Laos, Leninist-Trotskyists stand in defense of the Belarusian deformed workers state from imperialist attack and internal capitalist counterrevolution. We support the right of President Lukashinko to suppress imperialist financed NGOs and other imperialist financed political organizations as a means of defending Belarus’s national sovereignty. Yet, there are real violations of workers democratic rights in Belarus that are intended to protect the bureaucratic privileges of those who rule. As a result, Leninist-Trotskyists advocate a program of political revolution that overthrows the ruling Stalinist bureaucracy and ends the material privileges of Belarus’s ruling bureaucracy, bringing their income down to levels of the working class. In addition, we seek the institution of true workers democracy where competing tendencies of the working class have access to state media and the ability to organize while foreign backed bourgeois parties are banned.

With big limitations, Belarus is better off than its former Soviet neighbors due to its planned socialist economy. While defending that socialist economy, Leninist-Trotskyists fight for new socialist revolutions across the region that would restore socialist mutual aid between socialist republics and strengthen the ability of republics to exclude imperialist intervention. This would be somewhat similar to what the USSR was before Yeltsin’s 1991 capitalist counterrevolution, except we fight for a political system with true workers’ rights and democracy where the working class really does have the power in a system of democratic communism. Likewise, we fight for an end to imperialist intervention in the east.

End U.S. and E.U. Imperialist Economic Sanctions against Belarus!

-Steven Argue of the Revolutionary Tendency


This is an article of Liberation News, subscribe free:
https://lists.riseup.net/www/info/liberation_news


Also from this author, see:

Why The Russian Revolution is Still Important
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2012/03/03/18708611.php

Syria: As Rebels Escalate Genocide Against Kurds, Obama Prepares Air Strikes to Bring Them to Power
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2013/08/31/18742429.php

For Women’s Liberation through Socialist Revolution!
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2013/03/08/18733326.php

Comments  (Hide Comments)

by Steven Argue
Wednesday Mar 5th, 2014 12:46 PM
little_old_lady_beaten_1_1.jpg
little_old_lady_beaten_1_...


US & EU Imperialist Hands Off Crimea, Ukraine, Belarus, & Russia!
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2014/03/05/18751998.php

[Photo: Woman being beaten by fascist thugs for trying to lay flowers at the foot of a statue of Lenin. Fascist violence is now rampant as neo-Nazis have taken the government in a U.S. and E.U. sponsored coup.]
by Steven Argue
Wednesday Mar 5th, 2014 8:50 PM
vasilko_stepanovich.jpg
vasilko_stepanovich.jpg

Check out my new in depth article:

US & EU Imperialist Hands Off Crimea, Ukraine, Belarus, & Russia!
http://boston.indymedia.org/newswire/display/219851/index.php

[Photo: Rostislav Vasilko, First Secretary of the Regional Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine, being beaten. He described from his hospital bed being kidnapped and tortured by neo-Nazis for 12 hours in Mariinsky Park. The fascists stuck needles under his fingernails, beat him severely, bruised him very badly, broke three ribs, and gave him a second degree concussion with a broken skull. They also threatened to kill his wife and children and send his mother to prison. Where were the security forces in a park for twelve hours? Simple, they offer no protection because in Ukraine it is the fascist thugs who run things
by John Thielking
Thursday Mar 6th, 2014 4:46 AM
I read both of your 3-5-14 articles on Ukraine and Balarus. I was sorry to see that old lady get beat up by Nazi thugs. It was good that you had an actual photo of that as I'm not sure that Ukraine media is too reliable since I've heard that they tend to take sides at least as much as Western media does. It would be nice to see some sources footnoted in your articles so we can verify the veracity of some of your statements. Statements made by Ukrainian media that are contrary to the local population's interests in either the West or East Ukraine, depending on the location of the source, might carry more weight for instance. I'm dismayed to find that one of your articles was apparently deleted from Indybay.org/santacruz. I guess that was because it was a duplicate posting (also posted to Boston Indymedia on March 5, 2014).

On the kpfa program Flashpoints of 3-5-14, archived at http://www.kpfa.org, Ray McGovern and Richard Becker were interviewed about Ukraine and Dennis opened the phone lines to callers. I called in and told them about our articles and reprints posted on Indybay and also plugged http://www.rt.com. It seems that there is quite a bit of buzz being generated in the anti-war movement about the snipers in Kiev shooting at people from both sides and possibly being hired by the neo-Nazis currently in power and not by the duly elected, now deposed, president Mr. Yanukovych. For an online printed source on that, go to:

http://www.globalresearch.ca/kiev-snipers-hired-by-new-coalition-not-yanukovych-estonian-fm-to-ashton/5372033?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=kiev-snipers-hired-by-new-coalition-not-yanukovych-estonian-fm-to-ashton

http://www.rt.com was also broadcasting stories about the snipers being hired by the neo-Nazis all day yesterday at least. They are probably still blabbing about it today.
by Steven Argue
Friday Mar 7th, 2014 11:20 AM
The other article was deleted by my request. The reason was that I had put a lot of work into verifying everything in the article, but was tired and sloppy when I was finished and used the photo of the lady being beaten without verifying it. Immediately after I realized I had forgotten to do this and then realized I had made a big mistake because I was not able to find a reliable source for it. It may be real, but I don't want to be sloppy with my work and try to pass on something that may not be authentic. Especially after otherwise working so hard and being so careful.

I also wrote the Indybay moderators a couple days ago and asked them to delete the same photo from this thread as well, but nothing has happened.

While I was waiting for that article to get deleted, I was unable to post a corrected version here, so I posted it at Boston Indymedia, with the link above.

Regarding citations, it is a tedious process when I'm already limited for time and I'm synthesizing a lot of information from a large number of different sources. I am very careful with my sources, however, and can provide you with sources for specific facts upon request.
While we are waiting for the urgently needed protests nationwide of Democrat Obama's support of Nazis in Ukraine, in addition to Steve Argue's and Steve Lendman's excellent articles, we have KPFA, 94.1 FM, providing excellent coverage on certain programs:

1. Guns & Butter, hosted by Bonnie Faulkner, heard Wednesdays at 1 p.m.
We heard that story and a comprehensive description of the ramifications of Ukrainian history, economy and politics from Professor Michel Chossudovsky on KPFA's Guns & Butter, 3/5/14 at 1 p.m., which can be heard online at
http://www.kpfa.org/archive/id/100667
Chossudovsky's website, http://www.globalresearch.ca/ is a must read, daily, on Ukraine and many other issues.

2. Flashpoints, hosted by Dennis Bernstein heard Monday through Friday, 5-6 p.m. has had on his show, within the past 2 weeks, Prof. Francis Boyle, whose latest article on the CIA’s operation in Ukraine is at:
“Ukraine was a playbook CIA coup d'état” – Prof Francis Boyle, 2/28/14
http://voiceofrussia.com/2014_02_28/Ukraine-was-a-playbook-CIA-coup-d-tat-Prof-Francis-Boyle-6845/
reprinted at
http://www.globalresearch.ca/ukraine-was-a-playbook-cia-coup-detat/5371296

On 3/5/14, Dennis Bernstein devoted an entire hour to Ukraine, interviewing former CIA analyst Ray McGovern and leader of ANSWER, Richard Becker, and providing a forum for the listening public to call in with lots of worthwhile statements supporting Russia in its position against Nazi Ukraine. It can be heard at:
http://www.kpfa.org/archive/id/100672

Richard Becker was excellent as usual but Ray McGovern seems to think Democrat Obama is innocent when in fact he is part of the whole CIA coup in Ukraine. After all, he came from a CIA family, and every American president, whether Democrat or Republican, is there to do the bidding of the US capitalist class, which the entire CIA does by definition, so as to maximize the profits of the capitalist class. The CIA was a haven for old Nazis, and now they sponsor new Nazis, all for the same reason, to promote the capitalist profit motive.

Black Agenda Report (BAR) is also worth checking. On the front page for a few days now has been an excellent photo of Nazi Ukrainians with swastikas painted on their bodies, accompanying an article by BAR editor, Glen Ford,

"Hillary and Other Assorted Barbarians at Russia’s Gate" dated 3/5/14 at
http://www.blackagendareport.com/content/hillary-and-other-assorted-barbarians-russia%E2%80%99s-gate

In case you haven't heard, the illegal Ukrainian Prime Minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk, will be at the White House on March 12, and Crimea has a referendum on whether or not to rejoin Russia on Sunday, March 16. Remember that illegal US invasion and occupation of Iraq for oil on March 19, 2003 and all the protests preceding that terrible, genocidal event? We need even bigger nationwide protests over this grab for Ukrainian oil and gas pipelines and threatening Russia. This time we have a Democrat in the White House proudly promoting anti-Semitic Nazis.

You can start your protest now by changing your party registration to the only two peace and anti-fascist parties on the ballot, Peace & Freedom and the Green Party. It is not enough that you may occasionally vote for their candidates; they need your registration to stay on the ballot after 2014.

You can register online at:
https://rtv.sos.ca.gov/elections/register-to-vote/

For more information, see:
http://www.peaceandfreedom.org/home/
http://www.peaceandfreedom.org/home/campaign/june-2014
http://www.peaceandfreedom.org/home/about-us/platform/full-platform
http://www.cindy2014.org/second_place_wins_the_race (Cindy Sheehan for Governor Campaign)

http://www.sfgreenparty.org/
http://www.cagreens.org/elections/2014
http://www.cagreens.org/platform
http://www.gp.org/index.php
http://www.gp.org/index.php/what-we-believe/our-platform.html
by Erkmon
Wednesday Jun 25th, 2014 5:35 AM
Privatization is not a bad thing if it is anti-capitalist, not to mention anti-statist. http://c4ss.org/content/23838