From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
In Defense of Christine O' Donnell's Witchcraft
Whomever said politics makes for strange bed fellows wasn't kidding. As a pagan, or someone who practices what is commonly known as "witchcraft," I wouldn't be caught dead voting for Delaware Tea Party candidate Christine O'Donnell.
Whomever said politics makes for strange bed fellows wasn't kidding. As a pagan, or someone who practices what is commonly known as "witchcraft," I wouldn't be caught dead voting for Delaware Tea Party candidate Christine O'Donnell. And yet, the fact that O'Donnell is being drawn and quartered for admitting to "dabbling in witchcraft" on the Bill Mahrer show over a decade ago, is, how do I put it lightly? an overblown "scandal" worthy of a response.
Witchcraft - the very utterance of the word has been enough to set off a media feeding frenzy even more blood-thirsty than this past summer's "World Trade Center Mosque" hysteria. But unlike the good hearted liberals who have called for religious tolerance in the face of Glen Beck/Sarah Palin's anti-Muslim bigotry, there's been scarcely a peep on behalf of those who practice a traditional earth-based spirituality. Why is that?
In the most basic sense, Pagan spirituality involves recognizing the sacredness of the earth and all the sentient creatures that exist upon it. Though there is considerable variation in how this is practiced, some ways this is manifested include honoring male and female deities through ceremony, celebrating the seasons, and striving to live in harmony with all our relations. And yet, the very idea that Paganism would be taken seriously as a religion remains outside the possibility of American political discourse.
Only earlier this week, one of my favorite blogs (http://www.themessageshow.blogspot.com) mused that the end of organized religion may be near because England now recognizes Druids as a legitimate religion, worthy of tax-exempt status. In the eyes of the dominant culture, it would seem that Wiccans/Pagans, Druids, (and I'd add American Indian spiritual practices), don't qualify as true religions - one, because most people don't know anything about them; and two, because they don't fit the dominant paradigm's conception of what constitutes a "true" religion.
This is no accident - We tend to define religion as an institution requiring a hierarchy; where a group of followers (congregation) gather every weekend to sit facing forward and listen to an authority (priest, minister, etc), usually a male one, inside a designated building (church). Pagans on the other hand, often conduct their ceremonies outside, in a circle, with temporarily designated male and female priests and priestesses, who do not hold any institutional power over anyone else. The thrust is to invoke a communal experience with a power greater than ourselves, one that is founded on participation amongst equals, and grounded in the earth. This may not sound so strange to you, but ask yourself this - Can you imagine any American politician being openly pagan?
Even within my own circle of non-pagan friends and family, my wife and I remain cautious about being "openly" pagan lest we make folks feel uncomfortable. To put it another way, I know more gay couples who can be open about their love for each other amongst non-gay people than I know Pagan families who can be open about their spirituality amongst non-Pagans.
Christine O'Donnell may indeed be a fool unworthy of public office, but not because she "dabbled in witchcraft." And Bill Mahrer, an atheist liberal, is just as guilty of the kind of ignorant bigotry his conservative counterparts are notorious for, by bringing O'Donnell's attention-seeking butt on his show and mocking and condescending to her.
To be sure, American political discourse is notorious for being unashamedly sensationalist and superficial - Did candidate so n' so snort coke or inhale the herb during their twenties? Did what's-his-face have sexual relations with a male/female intern? Is that other guy who's skin color doesn't match mine really a gay socialist Muslim? ad nauseum. If anything, these bed-room hyped "scandals" reflect our own cultural ignorance, repressions and fears, and together, O'Donnell and Mahrer has inadvertently exposed yet another one.
Witchcraft - the very utterance of the word has been enough to set off a media feeding frenzy even more blood-thirsty than this past summer's "World Trade Center Mosque" hysteria. But unlike the good hearted liberals who have called for religious tolerance in the face of Glen Beck/Sarah Palin's anti-Muslim bigotry, there's been scarcely a peep on behalf of those who practice a traditional earth-based spirituality. Why is that?
In the most basic sense, Pagan spirituality involves recognizing the sacredness of the earth and all the sentient creatures that exist upon it. Though there is considerable variation in how this is practiced, some ways this is manifested include honoring male and female deities through ceremony, celebrating the seasons, and striving to live in harmony with all our relations. And yet, the very idea that Paganism would be taken seriously as a religion remains outside the possibility of American political discourse.
Only earlier this week, one of my favorite blogs (http://www.themessageshow.blogspot.com) mused that the end of organized religion may be near because England now recognizes Druids as a legitimate religion, worthy of tax-exempt status. In the eyes of the dominant culture, it would seem that Wiccans/Pagans, Druids, (and I'd add American Indian spiritual practices), don't qualify as true religions - one, because most people don't know anything about them; and two, because they don't fit the dominant paradigm's conception of what constitutes a "true" religion.
This is no accident - We tend to define religion as an institution requiring a hierarchy; where a group of followers (congregation) gather every weekend to sit facing forward and listen to an authority (priest, minister, etc), usually a male one, inside a designated building (church). Pagans on the other hand, often conduct their ceremonies outside, in a circle, with temporarily designated male and female priests and priestesses, who do not hold any institutional power over anyone else. The thrust is to invoke a communal experience with a power greater than ourselves, one that is founded on participation amongst equals, and grounded in the earth. This may not sound so strange to you, but ask yourself this - Can you imagine any American politician being openly pagan?
Even within my own circle of non-pagan friends and family, my wife and I remain cautious about being "openly" pagan lest we make folks feel uncomfortable. To put it another way, I know more gay couples who can be open about their love for each other amongst non-gay people than I know Pagan families who can be open about their spirituality amongst non-Pagans.
Christine O'Donnell may indeed be a fool unworthy of public office, but not because she "dabbled in witchcraft." And Bill Mahrer, an atheist liberal, is just as guilty of the kind of ignorant bigotry his conservative counterparts are notorious for, by bringing O'Donnell's attention-seeking butt on his show and mocking and condescending to her.
To be sure, American political discourse is notorious for being unashamedly sensationalist and superficial - Did candidate so n' so snort coke or inhale the herb during their twenties? Did what's-his-face have sexual relations with a male/female intern? Is that other guy who's skin color doesn't match mine really a gay socialist Muslim? ad nauseum. If anything, these bed-room hyped "scandals" reflect our own cultural ignorance, repressions and fears, and together, O'Donnell and Mahrer has inadvertently exposed yet another one.
Add Your Comments
Latest Comments
Listed below are the latest comments about this post.
These comments are submitted anonymously by website visitors.
TITLE
AUTHOR
DATE
no joke
Thu, Oct 7, 2010 1:43PM
One small piece that I can support
Thu, Oct 7, 2010 10:48AM
Not witchcraft
Thu, Oct 7, 2010 9:58AM
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network