SF Bay Area Indymedia indymedia
About Contact Subscribe Calendar Publish Print Donate

U.S. | LGBTI / Queer

Tue Feb 23 2010 (Updated 03/19/10) What Is This Broader Vision of Queer Liberation That Marriage Is a Reform Toward?
Via Gathering Forces JOMO writes: "In the past two years, the issue of gay marriage has dominated the scene of queer struggles. Some of us are actively supportive, others, grudgingly supportive, and more others who rail that yet again, queer struggles are being monopolized by assimilationist, middle class versions of normality and family: 'We are the same as you, except for in bed.'

"Some supporters of gay marriage point to the economic benefits of marriage. Working class and poor queers need marriage to help alleviate their poverty; immigrant queers need marriage to get US citizenship. I agree. Yet, let’s not forget that many queers will never get married because of their suspicions of state institutions. Granting gay marriage doesn’t guarantee that immigrant spouses get visas or are free from ICE harassment. Also, around us we see families for whom marriage has not helped alleviate the race and class oppressions that they face everyday. It is undeniable that the struggle for gay marriage has been dominated by white, middle class queers who support the Democrats and are ashamed of those of us who don’t fit in their status quo.

"One may see gay marriage as a reform to be won to open up space for more gains for queer liberation. Indeed, if gay marriage was simply a tactic within a broader strategy that integrated class, race and queer struggles, perhaps it wouldn’t cause so much anxiety among radical queer circles. In the absence of a broader strategy and vision however, all our hopes get pinned on this one struggle and the questions become stressful, burdensome and intense: Are we betraying our roots? Are we fighting for the society we envision through this struggle? Exactly what is this broader vision of queer liberation that gay marriage is a reform toward?"

Read More | Gathering Forces

imc_audio.gifCritique of Gay Marriage by radical Queers - KPFA's Women's Magazine | Queer of Color's Critique Gay Marriage | Beyond Gay Marriage

Indybay Older Coverage of Same Sex Marriage: Same Sex Couples Try to Apply for Marriage Licenses in San Mateo County | Meeting in the Middle: Marriage Equality and the Struggle for Civil Rights | Protests Follow Supreme Court Decision Upholding Proposition 8

04/13/14 Court's Decision Clears the Way for More Private Money to Enter the Electoral System   Global Justice and Anti-Capitalism | Peninsula
04/13/14 Threatened Snowy Plovers Nest and Brood in Footprint of Proposed Hotel Complex   Environment & Forest Defense | Santa Cruz Indymedia
04/13/14 Failing to Mitigate Impacts of Future Development, Marin Countywide Plan Ruled Unlawful   Environment & Forest Defense | North Bay / Marin
04/12/14 Community Members Hope to Be First "Frontline" County in California to Ban Fracking   Environment & Forest Defense | Santa Cruz Indymedia
04/11/14 Mayor Enforces Rule Barring Unattended Recording Devices in Council Chambers   Government & Elections | Santa Cruz Indymedia
04/08/14 UC Berkeley and Paul Jacobs Make First Cuts To Redwood Grove, Groundbreaking Held   Environment & Forest Defense | Education & Student Activism
04/04/14 Animal Rights Activists Say Chipotle Marketing Amounts to "Humane Washing" of Cruelty   Animal Liberation
04/04/14 IPCC Report Shows Appetite for Meat Is Harming Environment & Threat to a Livable Climate   Environment & Forest Defense | International | Animal Liberation
04/04/14 Fresno Ordinance Forces Homeless to Stay on the Move in Fear of Having Possessions Taken   Health, Housing, and Public Services | Central Valley | Government & Elections
04/03/14 Billboard Modified to Highlight Hassan v. Obama Fight Against Guantanamo Force-Feeding   Anti-War | Arts + Action
04/03/14 Impact of Tech Industry Protested with Apple, Google, & Yahoo Bus Blockades and Home Demo   Health, Housing, and Public Services | Global Justice and Anti-Capitalism